Evaluate the effectiveness of tonsillectomy and long-acting penicillin on the levels of the antistreptolysin O titer in children with recurrent tonsillitis

Alekh Kumar, Nupur KumariInternational Journal of Research in Medical Sciences 2019 · DOI

Abstract

Background: Tonsillitis is widespread among children and has serious poststreptococcal complications. Clinicians often face the question of whether long-acting penicillin is a viable alternative to surgery. This study evaluates the effectiveness of tonsillectomy compared with long-acting penicillin in treating recurrent tonsillitis by comparing their effects on Antistreptolysin O Titer (ASOT) levels.

Methods: 100 patients aged 4-15 years with recurrent tonsillitis were divided into two groups of 50. Group one underwent tonsillectomy, while group two received monthly long-acting penicillin for 6 months. ASOT levels were recorded before and after the 6-month period.

Results: The mean ASOT for the tonsillectomy group dropped from 518.29 to 117.13 IU/ml (P < 0.004). For the penicillin group, it dropped from 526.70 to 262.98 IU/ml (P < 0.072).

Conclusions: Tonsillectomy is the effective first-line treatment for recurrent chronic tonsillitis in children. Long-acting penicillin remains a secondary option for patients with contraindications for surgery.

Introduction

Recurrent tonsillitis is a common pediatric ailment, but its implications extend beyond simple throat pain. Chronic infection by Streptococcus bacteria can lead to serious post-streptococcal complications, including rheumatic fever and glomerulonephritis.

Clinicians face a persistent dilemma: should they recommend surgical removal of the tonsils (tonsillectomy) or opt for long-term antibiotic prophylaxis? While surgery is definitive, it carries inherent risks. Conversely, long-term antibiotic use raises concerns about compliance and the discomfort of repeated injections. This study provides a quantitative comparison of these two paths by measuring their impact on ASOT levels—a blood marker indicating recent or ongoing streptococcal infection.

Methods and Data

The researchers conducted a prospective study involving 100 children (aged 4–15) at the Rajendra Institute of Medical Sciences in Ranchi, India. The cohort was divided into two groups:

  1. Tonsillectomy Group: Patients underwent standard surgical intervention.
  2. Penicillin Group: Patients received monthly intramuscular injections of benzathine penicillin G for six months.

The primary metric was the ASOT level, recorded at baseline and after six months. The study excluded patients with pre-existing conditions like anemia or bleeding disorders. The baseline mean ASOT for all patients was 522.49 IU/ml, significantly above the normal threshold of 200 IU/ml.

Key Results

The quantitative results showed a clear advantage for surgical intervention in normalizing immunological markers.

  • Tonsillectomy Group: Mean ASOT levels dropped significantly from 518.29 IU/ml to 117.13 IU/ml ($P < 0.004$).
  • Penicillin Group: Mean ASOT levels dropped from 526.70 IU/ml to 262.98 IU/ml ($P < 0.072$). While levels decreased, the drop was less dramatic and did not reach the standard significance threshold within the 6-month window.
Distribution of ASOT titer levels after 6 months of treatment.

As illustrated in the figure above, 43 out of 50 surgical patients (86%) achieved ASOT levels below the 200 IU/ml threshold, compared to only 15 out of 50 (30%) in the penicillin group.

Discussion and Insights

The most striking insight is the speed of "immunological recovery." Tonsillectomy appears to act as a physical "reset" for the immune system by removing the reservoir of bacteria, leading to a rapid decline in antibody production.

While penicillin is effective, its slower results and the discomfort of monthly injections make it better suited as a second-line treatment—specifically for children who have contraindications for surgery, such as bleeding diathesis. Interestingly, the study noted a strong parental preference for surgery, which sometimes influenced group retention.

Limitations

The authors acknowledge that the six-month follow-up is relatively short. Other research suggests that ASOT levels in non-surgical patients might take up to two years to normalize, suggesting a need for longer longitudinal studies. Additionally, larger multi-center trials would provide more robust data than this single-center cohort of 100 patients.

Conclusion

This study demonstrates that tonsillectomy is the preferred first-line treatment for recurrent chronic tonsillitis in children, as it is both clinically effective and provides a faster return to normal immunological markers. Long-acting penicillin remains a vital alternative for patients where surgery is not an option.

Summary updated

Abstract

Background: Tonsillitis is widespread among children and has serious poststreptococcal complications, and both the patients and clinician have to face the question on what is the role and benefit of using long-acting penicillin and whether it is an alternative method of treatment to surgery?. This study was carried out to evaluate the effectiveness of tonsillectomy compared with long-acting penicillin in the treatment of recurrent tonsillitis, comparing their effects on the levels of the antistreptolysin O titer (ASOT).Methods: A total of 100 patients aged 4-15 years with recurrent tonsillitis and signs of chronic tonsillitis, after exclusion of patients with bleeding diathesis, anemia, chronic illness, and criteria of rheumatic fever, were included in this study, they were divided to two groups comprising 50 patients each. The first group was treated by tonsillectomy, whereas the second group was treated using long-acting penicillin monthly for 6 months. They were clinically evaluated, ASOT levels were recorded for all patients before management and after 6 months.Results: The mean ASOT readings before management and after 6 months for the tonsillectomy group were 518.29 and 117.13 IU/ml, respectively (P value &lt;0.004), whereas for the penicillin group, they were 526.70 and 262.98 IU/ml, respectively (P value &lt;0.072).Conclusions: This study demonstrates that the first line of treatment of recurrent chronic tonsillitis is tonsillectomy, as it is both clinically effective and cost-effective for children and that the second line of treatment is long-acting penicillin with a long-term follow-up and in patients have contraindications for surgery such as bleeding diathesis.
BibTeX
@article{kumar2019evaluate,
  author = {Alekh Kumar and Nupur Kumari},
  title = {{Evaluate the effectiveness of tonsillectomy and long-acting penicillin on the levels of the antistreptolysin O titer in children with recurrent tonsillitis}},
  journal = {International Journal of Research in Medical Sciences},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.18203/2320-6012.ijrms20191660},
}
Figure