EUS- versus ERCP-guided biliary drainage for malignant biliary obstruction: evidence from randomized controlled studies

Ke Chen, Zheling Chen, Weiwei Jin, Qicong Zhu, Chao Lü, Yuanyu Wang, Yucheng Zhou, Yiping MouAnnals 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This meta-analysis of three randomized controlled trials (RCTs) suggests that Endoscopic Ultrasound-guided Biliary Drainage (EUS-BD) is as effective as Endoscopic Retrograde Cholangiopancreatography-guided Biliary Drainage (ERCP-BD) for malignant biliary obstruction. Crucially, EUS-BD demonstrates a significantly lower incidence of post-procedure pancreatitis and a reduced need for reintervention, making it a strong contender for first-line treatment.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Malignant biliary obstruction, often caused by cancers like pancreatic cancer, leads to jaundice and can significantly impact patient quality of life. The standard treatment to relieve this blockage has been ERCP-BD. However, ERCP has limitations, including a failure rate of around 7% and higher rates of complications like pancreatitis, especially in cases with anatomical challenges or prior interventions. EUS-BD has emerged as a technically feasible alternative, particularly when ERCP fails. This paper addresses the critical question: can EUS-BD be considered a first-line treatment option, directly comparable to ERCP-BD, and does it offer advantages in terms of safety and efficacy?

Methods

The researchers conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis of published randomized clinical trials (RCTs) comparing EUS-BD and ERCP-BD for malignant biliary obstruction. They searched major databases (PubMed, Embase, Cochrane) for studies published before January 25, 2019. Studies were included if they were RCTs, involved malignant biliary obstruction, and provided comparable data on therapeutic efficacy and complications. Methodological quality was assessed using the modified Jadad scoring criteria. Data on technical success, clinical success, procedure time, stent patency, and various adverse events (pancreatitis, cholangitis, reintervention) were extracted and analyzed using Review Manager 5.3 software. Fixed-effects or random-effects models were employed based on heterogeneity.

Datasets

The study did not introduce new datasets. Instead, it synthesized data from three existing randomized controlled trials:

  • Paik et al. (2018)
  • Park et al. (2018)
  • Bang et al. (2018)

These trials collectively included 220 patients (111 in the EUS-BD group and 109 in the ERCP-BD group).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • EUS-BD as a Viable First-Line Option: The most significant insight is that EUS-BD is not just a salvage therapy but can be considered a primary treatment for malignant biliary obstruction, offering comparable efficacy to the established ERCP-BD.
  • Reduced Pancreatitis Risk: The finding of a significantly lower incidence of procedure-associated pancreatitis with EUS-BD is a major advantage, as pancreatitis is a common and often debilitating complication of ERCP.
  • Lower Reintervention Rates: EUS-BD's reduced need for reintervention suggests better long-term patency or fewer complications requiring repeat procedures, which is crucial for patient management and quality of life.
  • Improved Long-Term Stent Patency: While short-term stent patency was similar, EUS-BD showed a statistically significant advantage in 12-month stent patency, indicating its potential for more durable relief.

Key Results

  • Therapeutic Efficacy: No significant differences were found between EUS-BD and ERCP-BD in terms of technical success rate (OR = 1.02), clinical success rate (OR = 1.04), or procedure time (OR = -0.24).
  • Stent Patency: While 3-month (OR = 1.67) and 6-month (OR = 2.87) stent patency were similar, EUS-BD demonstrated significantly higher 12-month stent patency (OR = 3.23, P < 0.0001).
  • Complications:
    • Overall adverse events were similar between groups (OR = 0.52).
  • Procedure-related cholangitis was also comparable (OR = 0.56).
  • Procedure-related pancreatitis was significantly lower in the EUS-BD group (OR = 0.08, P = 0.02).
    • Reintervention rate was significantly lower in the EUS-BD group (OR = 0.25, P = 0.0004).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Small Sample Size: The meta-analysis was based on only three RCTs, with a relatively small number of patients. This limits the statistical power and generalizability of the findings.
  • Procedure Learning Curve: The impact of the learning curve for EUS-BD, which can vary significantly between operators, was not explicitly detailed in the included studies.
  • Stent Variability: The use of different stent types from various manufacturers across the studies could introduce heterogeneity.

The authors suggest that large-scale RCTs are still needed to validate these results and further solidify EUS-BD's role as a first-line treatment. Future research could also focus on standardizing EUS-BD techniques and evaluating long-term outcomes, including quality of life, in larger patient cohorts.

Summary updated

Abstract

Background: Endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography-guided biliary drainage (ERCP-BD) is the first-line technique for the management of malignant biliary obstruction. Previous evidence demonstrated that endoscopic ultrasound-guided biliary drainage (EUS-BD) is technically safe and feasible, and EUS-BD has been used as the alternative palliative treatment when ERCP fails. We aimed to compare the therapeutic efficacies and procedure-associated complications of EUS-BD and ERCP as the first treatment option. Methods: Studies comparing efficacies and complications of EUS-BD and ERCP-BD for the management of malignant biliary obstruction published before January 25, 2019 were searched. The patient characteristics, variables regarding to the therapeutic efficacies and procedure-associated complications of EUS-BD were compared to that of ERCP-BD by meta-analyses. Results: After screening 821 studies, three randomized clinical trials (RCTs) comparing the therapeutic efficacies and complications of EUS-BD and ERCP-BD for the palliative treatment of malignant obstructive jaundice were included. No significant difference was found between EUS-BD and ERCP-BD regarding to the technical success rate, clinical success rate, procedure time, and stent patency at 3 months and 6 months. The incidence of overall adverse events was also similar between the two groups. EUS-BD showed higher frequency of stent patency at 12 months. In addition, EUS-BD showed significant decreased incidence of procedure-associated pancreatitis [odds ratio (OR) =0.08, 95% confidence intervals (CI): 0.01 to 0.62, P=0.02) and reintervention rate (OR =0.25, 95% CI: 0.12 to 0.54, P=0.004). Conclusions: Compared to ERCP-BD, EUS-BD showed equivalent therapeutic efficacy with decreased incidence of pancreatitis and reintervention rate. EUS-BD, like ERCP-BD, could be the first-line technique for the management of malignant biliary obstruction.
BibTeX
@article{chen2019eus,
  author = {Ke Chen and Zheling Chen and Weiwei Jin and Qicong Zhu and Chao Lü and Yuanyu Wang and Yucheng Zhou and Yiping Mou},
  title = {{EUS- versus ERCP-guided biliary drainage for malignant biliary obstruction: evidence from randomized controlled studies}},
  journal = {Annals},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.21037/apc.2019.08.01},
}
Figure