European Society of Biomechanics S.M. Perren Award 2018: Altered biomechanical stimulation of the developing hip joint in presence of hip dysplasia risk factors

Stefaan W. Verbruggen, Bernhard Kainz, Susan C. Shelmerdine, Owen J. Arthurs, Joseph V. Hajnal, Mary Rutherford, Andrew Phillips, Niamh C. NowlanJournal of Biomechanics 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses advanced MRI and computational modeling to quantify how restricted fetal movement in conditions like breech presentation or low amniotic fluid alters hip joint biomechanics. The findings suggest that reduced mechanical stimulation during development is a key factor contributing to developmental dysplasia of the hip (DDH), offering a new mechanistic explanation for this common birth defect.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Developmental dysplasia of the hip (DDH) is a common condition where the hip joint doesn't form correctly, often requiring significant medical intervention. While genetic factors are known, a major contributor is a restrictive intrauterine environment that limits fetal movement. However, the precise biomechanical link between these restrictive conditions and the development of DDH has remained unclear. This paper aims to bridge this gap by investigating how specific risk factors for DDH—breech position, oligohydramnios (low amniotic fluid), and primiparity (firstborn pregnancy)—alter the biomechanical forces experienced by the developing fetal hip joint. Interestingly, twin pregnancies, which also have restricted space, do not show an increased risk of DDH, presenting a contrasting case to explore.

Methods

The researchers employed a sophisticated computational pipeline to analyze fetal movements and their impact on the hip joint. This involved:

  1. Cine-MRI Data Acquisition: Fetal movements were tracked from cine-MRI scans of fetuses in various conditions (cephalic, breech, oligohydramnios, twins, firstborn vs. non-firstborn).
  2. Kinematic Tracking: Key joint movements during fetal kicks were precisely quantified.
  3. Finite Element (FE) Modeling of Uterine Interaction: An FE model was used to estimate the reaction force generated by fetal kicks against the uterine wall, considering uterine wall displacement.
  4. Musculoskeletal Modeling (OpenSim): A scaled musculoskeletal model of the fetal lower limb was used to predict muscle forces and their lines of action based on the tracked kinematics and estimated reaction forces.
  5. FE Modeling of Fetal Hip Joint: Finally, the predicted muscle forces were applied to FE models of fetal hip joint geometries (derived from post-mortem MRI) to characterize the resulting stress and strain within the hip joint. This allowed for the quantification of mechanical stimuli.

This multi-stage approach, combining imaging, biomechanical modeling, and FE analysis, is novel in its application to understanding prenatal hip development under specific risk conditions.

Datasets

The study utilized a database of fetal cine-MRI scans retrospectively collected from previous pregnancies at Hammersmith Hospital and St. Thomas' Hospital (London, UK). Post-mortem MR scans of fetal leg bones were also obtained from the radiology information system at Great Ormond Street Hospital. The specific sample sizes for each condition are detailed in Table 1 of the paper. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing archived data was analyzed.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Mechanobiology as a Driver of DDH: The core idea is that DDH isn't just a structural issue, but a consequence of altered mechanical signaling during development. Reduced fetal movement leads to reduced mechanical stress and strain, which in turn affects how the hip joint cartilage and bone develop.
  • Breech and Oligohydramnios as Low-Stimulus Environments: These conditions significantly reduce the forces and strains experienced by the hip joint, providing a direct mechanistic link to why they are risk factors for DDH.
  • Firstborns' Unique Biomechanics: Firstborn fetuses exhibit lower kick forces, potentially due to stiffer maternal tissues in a first pregnancy, suggesting a subtle but significant difference in mechanical exposure.
  • Twins as a Control for Space Restriction: The finding that twins, despite less space, do not have a higher risk of DDH is crucial. This suggests that factors beyond just physical space, like the quality or nature of the mechanical stimulation, are more important. The paper speculates that interactions between twins might compensate.

Key Results

  • Breech Position: Fetuses in breech presentation exhibited significantly lower uterine wall displacement, kick reaction force, maximum principal stress, and maximum and minimum principal strains in the hip joint compared to cephalic fetuses.
  • Oligohydramnios: Similar to breech, oligohydramnios conditions showed significantly lower uterine wall displacement, kick forces, and pronounced decreases in hip joint stress and strain compared to healthy fetuses.
  • Firstborn vs. Non-Firstborn: Firstborn fetuses generated significantly lower kick forces due to reduced uterine wall displacement. While stress and strain differences weren't statistically significant, a consistent trend of decrease was observed in firstborn fetuses.
  • Twins vs. Singletons: No significant differences were found in hip joint stress or strain between twin and singleton pregnancies, despite twins being smaller. This suggests that the overall mechanical environment, rather than just limb size, is key.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Single Time Point Analysis: The study analyzed kicks at specific time points (20 or 30 weeks gestational age) due to data availability. A longitudinal study tracking development over time would provide a more complete picture, especially as DDH risk increases later in pregnancy.
  • Uterine Pressure Data: Uterine pressures were measured in singleton pregnancies and may differ in twin pregnancies, introducing a potential variability.
  • Sample Size: Only a fraction of available scans showed clear, trackable kicks, leading to relatively small sample sizes for some conditions. Larger datasets could improve statistical power.
  • Model Assumptions: The study acknowledges assumptions regarding uterine muscle tissue properties and potential errors in applying muscle forces to fetal geometries due to incomplete anatomical landmark development.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that their findings provide crucial data for developing more accurate mechanobiological models of hip joint development and DDH. They also highlight the clinical implications for targeted ultrasound screening for breech position and oligohydramnios, and the potential for earlier intervention (e.g., external cephalic version) to mitigate DDH risk.

Summary updated

Abstract

Fetal kicking and movements generate biomechanical stimulation in the fetal skeleton, which is important for prenatal musculoskeletal development, particularly joint shape. Developmental dysplasia of the hip (DDH) is the most common joint shape abnormality at birth, with many risk factors for the condition being associated with restricted fetal movement. In this study, we investigate the biomechanics of fetal movements in such situations, namely fetal breech position, oligohydramnios and primiparity (firstborn pregnancy). We also investigate twin pregnancies, which are not at greater risk of DDH incidence, despite the more restricted intra-uterine environment. We track fetal movements for each of these situations using cine-MRI technology, quantify the kick and muscle forces, and characterise the resulting stress and strain in the hip joint, testing the hypothesis that altered biomechanical stimuli may explain the link between certain intra-uterine conditions and risk of DDH. Kick force, stress and strain were found to be significantly lower in cases of breech position and oligohydramnios. Similarly, firstborn fetuses were found to generate significantly lower kick forces than non-firstborns. Interestingly, no significant difference was observed in twins compared to singletons. This research represents the first evidence of a link between the biomechanics of fetal movements and the risk of DDH, potentially informing the development of future preventative measures and enhanced diagnosis. Our results emphasise the importance of ultrasound screening for breech position and oligohydramnios, particularly later in pregnancy, and suggest that earlier intervention to correct breech position through external cephalic version could reduce the risk of hip dysplasia.
BibTeX
@article{verbruggen2018european,
  author = {Stefaan W. Verbruggen and Bernhard Kainz and Susan C. Shelmerdine and Owen J. Arthurs and Joseph V. Hajnal and Mary Rutherford and Andrew Phillips and Niamh C. Nowlan},
  title = {{European Society of Biomechanics S.M. Perren Award 2018: Altered biomechanical stimulation of the developing hip joint in presence of hip dysplasia risk factors}},
  journal = {Journal of Biomechanics},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1016/j.jbiomech.2018.07.016},
}
Figure