European land CO2 sink influenced by NAO and East-Atlantic Pattern coupling

Ana Bastos, Ivan A. Janssens, Célia M. Gouveia, Ricardo M. Trigo, Philippe Ciais, Frédéric Chevallier, Josep Peñuelas, Christian Rödenbeck, Shilong Piao, Pierre Friedlingstein, Steven W. RunningNature Communications 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper reveals that the European land CO2 sink's variability is not solely driven by the North Atlantic Oscillation (NAO), but by the interplay between the NAO and the East Atlantic (EA) pattern. This coupling significantly influences heat and water transport, leading to distinct impacts on photosynthesis and respiration, ultimately explaining fluctuations in Europe's carbon uptake.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the variability of the terrestrial carbon sink is crucial for predicting future atmospheric CO2 concentrations and their impact on climate change. While large-scale climate patterns like the El Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO) are known to influence global carbon sinks, the specific drivers of regional sinks, like Europe's, are less clear. The North Atlantic Oscillation (NAO) has been identified as a key factor influencing European vegetation and climate. However, the East Atlantic (EA) pattern, which modulates the NAO's strength and location, also plays a significant role in European climate. This paper addresses the need to understand how the combined influence of these two teleconnections, NAO and EA, shapes the inter-annual variability of the European land CO2 sink (Net Biome Productivity, NBP). Previous studies have often looked at NAO in isolation, potentially missing crucial interactions that govern carbon uptake.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach combining observational data and climate models. They utilized atmospheric CO2 inversions, which are top-down methods that estimate surface CO2 fluxes by analyzing atmospheric CO2 concentration measurements. Specifically, they used two versions of the MACC-II inversion and the Jena s81 inversion. To complement these, they also incorporated outputs from eleven Dynamic Global Vegetation Models (DGVMs) which provide a bottom-up estimation of NBP. The study analyzed data from 1982 to 2012, focusing on the combined influence of the NAO and EA patterns by categorizing years into four distinct phase combinations (NAO+EA+, NAO-EA-, NAO+EA-, NAO-EA+). They analyzed climate variables such as sea-level pressure, 500 mb geopotential height, heat and water vapor transport, cloud cover, temperature, soil water content, and snow depth. To assess the ecological response, they used Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) data and partitioned NBP into Gross Primary Productivity (GPP) and respiration components from the DGVMs. Statistical analyses, including analysis of variance (ANOVA), were used to determine the significance of the observed relationships.

Datasets

  • Atmospheric CO2 Inversions:
    • MACC-II (two versions: v11.2 and v13.1)
    • Jena s81 (v3.6)
  • Dynamic Global Vegetation Models (DGVMs): Outputs from eleven DGVMs compiled in the TRENDY project (simulation S3).
  • Climate Reanalysis Data: ERA-Interim reanalysis for variables like sea-level pressure, geopotential height, heat and water vapor transport, cloud cover, temperature, soil water content, and snow depth.
  • Teleconnection Indices: Monthly indices for NAO and EA from NOAA's Climate Prediction Center.
  • Vegetation Data: Biweekly NDVI fields from the GIMMS NDVI dataset.
  • Drought Index: Self-calibrated Palmer Drought Severity Index (PDSI).

The paper does not introduce new benchmark datasets but rather utilizes and integrates existing, well-established datasets to investigate the complex interactions between climate and carbon cycling.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • NAO-EA Synergy is Key: The study's most significant finding is that the European land CO2 sink's variability is not adequately explained by the NAO alone. The interaction between the NAO and EA patterns is crucial, as it modulates heat and water transport, leading to distinct climate anomalies that impact carbon uptake.
  • "In-Phase" Enhancement: The European carbon sink is significantly enhanced when both NAO and EA are in their negative phases (NAO-EA-). This combination leads to cooler, wetter summers that favor photosynthesis.
  • "Anti-Phase" Reduction: Conversely, when NAO and EA are in opposing phases (NAO+EA- or NAO-EA+), the carbon sink is reduced. This is due to a complex interplay of climate anomalies affecting both photosynthesis and respiration differently.
  • Explaining Past Trends: The prevalence of anti-phase years in the early 2000s is proposed as a key reason for the observed reduction in Europe's carbon uptake during that period.
  • Model Improvement Needed: The findings underscore the importance of accurately simulating atmospheric circulation patterns in coupled carbon-climate models to improve their ability to predict regional carbon sink variability.

Key Results

  • The combined NAO-EA variability explains a significant portion of the inter-annual variability in European Net Biome Productivity (NBP) from 1982 to 2012.
  • The NAO-EA- composite showed a consistent enhancement of NBP across inversions and most DGVMs, indicating a stronger carbon sink.
  • Anti-phase combinations (NAO+EA- and NAO-EA+) consistently resulted in reduced NBP, though the magnitude and sign of anomalies varied between inversions and DGVMs for the NAO+EA+ case.
  • The NAO-EA- phase is associated with cool summers and wet soils, which enhance photosynthesis.
  • Anti-phase periods lead to reduced NBP through distinct impacts on photosynthesis and respiration, often driven by drier conditions or altered temperature regimes.
  • The early 2000s, characterized by a predominance of anti-phase years, coincided with a weaker European carbon sink.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Regional Uncertainty: The paper acknowledges that atmospheric inversions have higher uncertainty at regional scales compared to continental scales, partly due to limitations in observational networks and transport models. DGVMs are expected to better capture regional ecological variability.
  • Model Disagreements: While inversions and DGVMs generally agree on the NAO-EA- enhancement, there are discrepancies in the anti-phase combinations, particularly for NAO+EA+, where MACC inversions and DGVMs differ on the sign of anomalies.
  • Limited Years in Composites: The small number of years in some NAO-EA phase composites (e.g., four years for NAO+EA+) necessitates caution in their interpretation.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that improving the simulation of atmospheric circulation patterns in Earth System Models is crucial for better understanding and predicting land carbon sink variability. They also highlight the need for more long-term, high-quality observation-driven data sets to further refine our understanding of multi-year land sink variability and its relationship with climate. The study also points to the need to consider other teleconnections and their potential influence on North Atlantic sea-level pressure.

Summary updated

Abstract

Large-scale climate patterns control variability in the global carbon sink. In Europe, the North-Atlantic Oscillation (NAO) influences vegetation activity, however the East-Atlantic (EA) pattern is known to modulate NAO strength and location. Using observation-driven and modelled data sets, we show that multi-annual variability patterns of European Net Biome Productivity (NBP) are linked to anomalies in heat and water transport controlled by the NAO-EA interplay. Enhanced NBP occurs when NAO and EA are both in negative phase, associated with cool summers with wet soils which enhance photosynthesis. During anti-phase periods, NBP is reduced through distinct impacts of climate anomalies in photosynthesis and respiration. The predominance of anti-phase years in the early 2000s may explain the European-wide reduction of carbon uptake during this period, reported in previous studies. Results show that improving the capability of simulating atmospheric circulation patterns may better constrain regional carbon sink variability in coupled carbon-climate models.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bastos2016european,
  author = {Ana Bastos and Ivan A. Janssens and Célia M. Gouveia and Ricardo M. Trigo and Philippe Ciais and Frédéric Chevallier and Josep Peñuelas and Christian Rödenbeck and Shilong Piao and Pierre Friedlingstein and Steven W. Running},
  title = {{European land CO2 sink influenced by NAO and East-Atlantic Pattern coupling}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1038/ncomms10315},
}
Figure