Euedaphic Rather than Hemiedaphic or Epedaphic Collembola Are More Sensitive to Different Climate Conditions in the Black Soil Region of Northeast China

Chunbo Li, Shaoqing Zhang, Baifeng Wang, Zihan Ai, Yongbo Shao, Jing Du, Chenxu Wang, Syed Aftab Wajid, Donghui Wu, Liang ChangInsects 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that the deepest-dwelling Collembola (euedaphic) are more sensitive to climate variations in Northeast China's black soil region compared to their surface-dwelling counterparts. Agricultural practices, particularly shifting from rice to soybean and maize cultivation, significantly boost Collembola populations, suggesting land use is a stronger driver of soil biodiversity than climate in this region.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Soil biodiversity is crucial for ecosystem health and agricultural productivity, yet it's increasingly threatened by climate change and altered land use. While aboveground biodiversity has received considerable attention, the impact of these factors on soil-dwelling organisms, particularly in vital agricultural regions like Northeast China's black soil, remains less understood. This paper aims to fill this knowledge gap by investigating how climate variations and different agricultural land use practices (soybean, maize, rice) affect the density and species richness of Collembola, a key group of soil invertebrates, considering their different life forms (euedaphic, hemiedaphic, epedaphic).

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach:

  • Sampling Design: They selected three distinct climatic areas within the black soil region of Northeast China, representing a gradient of temperature and humidity. Within each area, they sampled three common agricultural land use types: soybean, maize, and rice.
  • Collembola Extraction and Identification: Soil samples were collected and Collembola were extracted using the Tullgren funnel method. Species were identified, and their life forms (euedaphic, hemiedaphic, epedaphic) were classified based on their typical soil depth distribution.
  • Environmental Data Collection: Climate data (Mean Annual Temperature - MAT, Mean Annual Precipitation - MAP) were obtained from WorldClim. Soil properties like pH, total carbon, and total nitrogen were also measured.
  • Microbial Community Analysis: Phospholipid Fatty Acid (PLFA) analysis was used to characterize the soil microbial community structure.
  • Statistical Analysis: Two-way ANOVA was used to analyze the effects of climate, land use, and their interactions on Collembola density and species richness. Constrained Redundancy Analysis (RDA) was employed to explore the relationships between Collembola community composition, environmental factors, and microbial communities.

Datasets

The study utilized publicly available climate data from WorldClim. Soil samples were collected from agricultural fields in Northeast China. No new benchmark datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Euedaphic Sensitivity: The most striking finding is that euedaphic Collembola (those living deepest in the soil) are significantly more sensitive to climate variations (temperature and humidity) than their hemiedaphic and epedaphic counterparts. This suggests climate change might disproportionately affect the deeper soil fauna.
  • Land Use Dominance: While climate has an effect, land use practices appear to be a more dominant driver of Collembola communities in this agricultural landscape. The shift from rice cultivation to soybean and maize significantly boosted Collembola density and species richness.
  • Rice as a Limiting Factor: Rice fields, likely due to waterlogging and soil compaction, seem to harbor less diverse and abundant Collembola communities compared to soybean and maize fields.
  • Environmental Factors Trump Feeding Resources: The study's analysis (RDA) indicated that environmental factors (land use practices and MAP) explained a larger portion of the variation in Collembola community composition than feeding resources (microorganisms like fungi and AMF). This supports the hypothesis that the physical and chemical environment is a primary determinant.
  • Vertical Stratification Shifts: The differential sensitivity of Collembola life forms to climate suggests that future climate change could alter the vertical distribution of soil fauna, potentially impacting soil ecological processes.

Key Results

  • Higher temperatures and humidity were associated with higher total Collembola density and species richness.
  • Soybean and maize fields showed significantly higher Collembola density and species richness compared to rice fields.
  • Euedaphic Collembola density and species richness were particularly enhanced under warmer and more humid climatic conditions.
  • Land use practices explained a substantial portion of the variance in Collembola community composition (40.1%), followed by MAP (6.1%).
  • Environmental factors collectively explained a greater proportion of the variance in Collembola communities than microbial feeding resources.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sampling Timing: The study acknowledges that sampling in autumn, during the rice maturity phase, might have influenced the results for rice fields, as Collembola may not have fully adapted to the post-flooding soil conditions.
  • Interaction Effects: While individual effects of climate and land use were significant, their interaction effect on total Collembola density and species richness was not significant. However, a significant interaction was observed for hemiedaphic Collembola species richness.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that understanding how climate differences alter the vertical distribution of soil fauna is crucial for predicting future ecological processes in agricultural systems. Further research could explore the long-term impacts of these changes and investigate specific mechanisms driving the observed sensitivities. The findings also highlight the importance of considering land use practices for soil biodiversity conservation in the face of global environmental changes.

Summary updated

Abstract

Soil biodiversity is profoundly affected by variations in climate conditions and land use practices. As one of the major grain-producing areas in China, the belowground biodiversity of the black soil region of the Northeast is also affected by the variations in climate conditions and land use types. However, most of the previous studies have focused on aboveground biodiversity, and the research of soil biodiversity is limited. The main aim of this study was to investigate the effects of variations in climate conditions and land use practices on Collembola communities of different life forms in the black soil region of Northeast China. Here, we selected three climatic areas from high to low latitudes in the black soil region of the Northeast, with three variations in land use practices (soybean, maize, and rice) sampled in each area. We found that higher temperatures and higher humidity and land use practices from rice to soybean and maize are associated with a higher Collembola density and species richness. Specifically, the density and species richness of euedaphic Colmbola are higher in climate conditions with higher temperatures and humidity, while the density and species richness of all three life forms of Collembola are higher in land use practices from rice to soybean and maize. Additionally, we discovered that environmental factors and feeding resources (soil microorganisms) both have significant effects on Collembola communities, with environmental factors exerting a more substantial influence. Our results suggest that euedaphic Collembola are more vulnerable to climate differences than epedaphic and hemiedaphic Collembola. Consequently, this may alter the vertical distribution characteristics of soil fauna (e.g., increasing soil-dwelling fauna) as well as the ecological processes associated with soil fauna in different agricultural environments.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2025euedaphic,
  author = {Chunbo Li and Shaoqing Zhang and Baifeng Wang and Zihan Ai and Sha Zhang and Yongbo Shao and Jing Du and Chenxu Wang and Syed Aftab Wajid and Donghui Wu and Liang Chang},
  title = {{Euedaphic Rather than Hemiedaphic or Epedaphic Collembola Are More Sensitive to Different Climate Conditions in the Black Soil Region of Northeast China}},
  booktitle = {Insects},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/insects16030275},
}
Figure