Ethics, Prosperity, and Society: Moral Evaluation Using Virtue Ethics and Utilitarianism

Aditya Hegde, Vibhav Agarwal, Shrisha RaoIJCAI 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel agent-based modeling framework that integrates both ethical decision-making and moral evaluation using virtue ethics and utilitarianism. By simulating societies with "virtue agents" that possess varying ethical levels, they demonstrate that unethical agents achieve short-term gains but are less prosperous in the long run, with prosperity directly correlating to ethicality.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding and modeling ethical behavior in artificial agents is a complex challenge. While existing approaches often focus on either embedding ethics into agent strategies or using ethics solely for evaluating agent actions, there's a need for a unified framework that handles both aspects. This paper aims to bridge this gap by proposing a system where agents not only make ethical decisions but also evaluate the ethicality of others, exploring how these dynamics influence societal prosperity and individual agent outcomes. The authors are motivated by the desire to understand the macro-societal implications of different ethical theories and agent behaviors.

Methods

The core of the paper is a cellular automaton model where agents interact on a grid. The framework incorporates two primary interaction types:

  • Continuous Prisoner's Dilemma (CPD): An extension of the classic Prisoner's Dilemma, allowing agents to choose continuous levels of cooperation (0 to 1). This models resource exchange and cooperation dynamics.
  • Moral Interaction: A novel interaction type where agents can choose to either donate resources to or steal from another agent. This is designed to model high-stakes ethical decisions. A key feature is that moral interactions occur with a low probability ($\theta$), reflecting their relative rarity compared to everyday interactions.

The framework introduces a "virtue agent" type, parameterized by an "ethics level" ($\epsilon$). Agent decisions and evaluations are influenced by:

  • Opinion: Agents maintain opinions ($\Psi$) about other agents, representing their perception of their ethicality. These opinions are updated based on interactions, drawing from principles of virtue ethics (focusing on the inherent morality of actions like cooperation or donation) and utilitarianism (focusing on the consequences, specifically resource changes).
  • Resource: Agents have a resource parameter ($r$) representing their prosperity, which is updated through interactions.

Opinion updates are crucial for moral evaluation. After interactions, details are broadcast to a fraction of other agents, allowing them to update their opinions based on the observed ethicality of the action. The paper also defines "positivity bias" (rewards for ethical actions outweigh penalties for unethical ones) and "negativity bias" (penalties for unethical actions outweigh rewards for ethical ones) in society, which influence opinion updates.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper relies on simulations with synthetic agent populations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Ethics Pays Off (Eventually): Unethical agents might gain short-term advantages, but ethical agents ultimately achieve greater prosperity and reputation in the long run. This suggests that ethical behavior is a more sustainable strategy for individual success and societal well-being.
  • The Power of Moral Interactions: While CPD interactions are important for resource dynamics, the introduction of low-probability, high-stakes "moral interactions" significantly amplifies the impact of ethical decisions and evaluations on agent outcomes and societal structure.
  • Societal Bias Shapes Incentives: The balance between rewarding ethical behavior and punishing unethical behavior (positivity vs. negativity bias) profoundly influences agent behavior. Negativity bias can lead to more extreme ethical divergence, while positivity bias can incentivize unethical agents to become more ethical.
  • Reputation is Key: Agent reputation, derived from opinions, plays a critical role in subsequent interactions, particularly in CPD. Higher reputations lead to better cooperation and less targeting for theft.
  • Virtue Agents as a Flexible Tool: The "virtue agent" concept provides a modular way to instantiate agents with varying ethical levels, allowing for systematic study of ethics in agent-based models.

Key Results

  • Simulations show that agents with higher levels of ethics ($\epsilon$) consistently achieve higher mean resources and reputations after 1500 iterations.
  • The difference between the prosperity of ethical and unethical agents increases over time, especially after reputation stabilizes.
  • Societies with negativity bias exhibit a steeper increase in reputation and resource for ethical agents, while positivity bias leads to more convergent trends where unethical agents are incentivized to become ethical.
  • Moral interactions, even at a low probability ($\theta=0.05$), lead to a much larger divergence in agent resources compared to simulations with only CPD interactions.
  • Global utility (total societal resource) rises steeply with the level of ethics of agents, indicating that even a small proportion of ethical agents can significantly boost societal prosperity.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Agent Types: The primary simulations focus on "virtue agents." The paper briefly explores comparing virtue agents with traditional strategies (TFT, Grim Trigger, etc.) but acknowledges that these strategies need adaptation for moral interactions.
  • Static Ethical Levels: Virtue agents have a fixed ethical level ($\epsilon$). The authors suggest future work could explore agents that dynamically update their ethical levels based on past interactions, potentially using reinforcement learning.
  • Simplified Bias Models: The paper defines positivity and negativity bias based on fixed parameters ($w_d, w_t$). Future work could explore more nuanced models of societal bias.
  • Focus on Individual vs. Societal Ethics: While the paper models societal impact, a deeper dive into the interplay between individual ethical choices and emergent societal norms could be explored.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{hegde2020ethics,
  author = {Aditya Hegde and Vibhav Agarwal and Shrisha Rao},
  title = {{Ethics, Prosperity, and Society: Moral Evaluation Using Virtue Ethics and Utilitarianism}},
  booktitle = {International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.24963/ijcai.2020/24},
}

Loading related content...

Figure