Etale homotopy types of moduli stacks of algebraic curves with\n symmetries

Paola Frediani, Frank NeumannarXiv 2004 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

This paper determines the étale homotopy types of moduli stacks for algebraic curves with a fixed group of symmetries over the algebraic closure of the rationals ($\bar{\mathbb{Q}}$). The authors show that these complex geometric objects have a "shape" (homotopy type) that is entirely determined by the profinite completion of the normalizer of the symmetry group within the mapping class group.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In algebraic geometry, a moduli stack is a sophisticated geometric space where each point represents a specific type of object—in this case, smooth algebraic curves of a certain genus $g$. Understanding the "shape" or homotopy type of these spaces is crucial because it reveals deep connections between topology, geometry, and number theory.

Previously, mathematician Takayuki Oda determined the étale homotopy type for the "standard" moduli stack of curves ($\mathcal{M}_g$). He showed it was essentially the profinite completion of a classifying space for the mapping class group. However, many interesting curves possess inherent symmetries (automorphisms), such as hyperelliptic curves. This paper fills the gap by extending Oda's work to moduli stacks $\mathcal{M}_{g,G}$, which parametrize curves of genus $g \ge 2$ that come equipped with a specific action by a finite group $G$.

Methods

The authors bridge the gap between abstract algebraic geometry and classical topology using several high-powered mathematical tools:

  1. Artin-Mazur Étale Homotopy Theory: This is the primary "machinery" used to define the homotopy type of an algebraic variety or stack in a way that makes sense over fields like $\bar{\mathbb{Q}}$.
  2. Teichmüller Theory: To understand the algebraic stack, the authors first look at its complex analytic counterpart ($\mathcal{M}_{g,G}^{an}$). They use Teichmüller space—a contractible space of marked Riemann surfaces—to describe the stack as an orbifold quotient.
  3. Nielsen Realization Problem: The authors rely on the solution to this famous problem (by Kerckhoff) to prove that the fixed-point locus of the group $G$ acting on the Teichmüller space is itself contractible. This is a critical step in simplifying the homotopy type.
  4. Comparison Theorems: Finally, they use comparison theorems (by Artin, Mazur, Cox, and Friedlander) to show that the "algebraic" shape over $\bar{\mathbb{Q}}$ matches the "topological" shape over $\mathbb{C}$ after a process called profinite completion.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. As a theoretical mathematics paper, it relies on logical proofs and existing mathematical frameworks rather than empirical datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Normalizer is Key: The most significant insight is that the homotopy type of the moduli stack $\mathcal{M}_{g,G}$ is governed by $\Gamma_{g,G}$, the normalizer of the group $G$ inside the mapping class group $\Gamma_g$. This group captures how the symmetries of the curve interact with the overall topological transformations of the surface.
  • Contractibility Simplifies Everything: Because the fixed-point locus $T_g^G$ in Teichmüller space is contractible, the resulting moduli stack behaves like a "classifying space" ($K(\pi, 1)$). This means all the complex "loops" and "holes" in the space are entirely described by the fundamental group $\Gamma_{g,G}$.
  • Arithmetic Links: By determining the étale fundamental group, the authors provide a way to relate the absolute Galois group $\text{Gal}(\bar{\mathbb{Q}}/\mathbb{Q})$ to the profinite completion of mapping class groups. This supports Grothendieck's vision of the "Lego-Teichmüller game," where arithmetic information is encoded in the symmetries of moduli spaces.

Key Results

  • Main Theorem (3.6): The authors prove a weak homotopy equivalence: $$\{\mathcal{M}_{g,G} \otimes \bar{\mathbb{Q}}\}_{et}^\wedge \simeq K(\Gamma_{g,G}, 1)^\wedge$$ This states that the étale homotopy type of the moduli stack is the profinite Artin-Mazur completion of the Eilenberg-MacLane space of the normalizer group.

  • Higher Homotopy Groups: A consequence of the main result is that all higher étale homotopy groups $\pi_n^{et}$ for $n \ge 2$ are trivial (zero).

  • Hyperelliptic Case: They specifically derive the homotopy type for the stack of hyperelliptic curves $\mathcal{H}_g$, showing it relates to the hyperelliptic mapping class group.
  • Galois Exact Sequence: They establish a short exact sequence of profinite groups: $$1 \to \Gamma_{g,G}^\wedge \to \pi_1^{et}(\mathcal{M}_{g,G}, x) \to \text{Gal}(\bar{\mathbb{Q}}/\mathbb{Q}) \to 1$$ This provides a concrete path for studying how the Galois group acts on the fundamental groups of these moduli spaces.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Genus Constraint: The results are strictly for genus $g \ge 2$. The case for $g=1$ (elliptic curves) or $g=0$ involves different boundary conditions and group behaviors.
  • "Goodness" of Groups: The authors raise an open question regarding which pairs of $(g, G)$ result in "good" groups in the sense of Serre. A group is "good" if its cohomology matches that of its profinite completion; while this holds for the standard mapping class group, it is not yet fully proven for all normalizers $\Gamma_{g,G}$.
  • Hurwitz Stacks: The paper suggests that extending these techniques to more general Hurwitz stacks (which involve branched coverings) would be a promising direction for future research.

Summary updated

Abstract

Using the machinery of etale homotopy theory a' la Artin-Mazur we determine\nthe etale homotopy types of moduli stacks over $\\bar{\\Q}$ parametrizing\nfamilies of algebraic curves of genus g greater than 1 endowed with an action\nof a finite group G of automorphisms, which comes with a fixed embedding in the\nmapping class group, such that in the associated complex analytic situation the\naction of G is precisely the differentiable action induced by this specified\nembedding of G in the mapping class group.\n
BibTeX
@misc{frediani2004etale,
  author = {Paola Frediani and Frank Neumann},
  title = {{Etale homotopy types of moduli stacks of algebraic curves with\textbackslash\{\}n symmetries}},
  year = {2004},
  eprint = {math/0404387},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/math/0404387},
}
Figure