Eta products, BPS states and K3 surfaces

Yang‐Hui He, John McKayJournal of High Energy Physics 2014 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores a deep connection between number theory and theoretical physics, specifically linking multiplicative eta-products to the geometry of K3 surfaces and the counting of BPS states in string theory. The authors demonstrate that these seemingly disparate mathematical objects are, in fact, intimately related through string duality and exhibit surprising connections to the sporadic Mathieu group M24.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper investigates a question that arises from the study of multiplicative functions in number theory, particularly those involving Dedekind eta-functions. Specifically, it asks whether these elegant mathematical constructs, which have a rich history in number theory and are related to modular forms, can be physically realized as partition functions that count fundamental states in string theory. The authors aim to bridge the gap between the abstract properties of eta-products and their concrete manifestations in physical theories, particularly in the context of K3 surfaces and BPS states in string compactifications.

Methods

The authors employ a multi-pronged approach, drawing from both number theory and theoretical physics. Key methods include:

  • Dedekind Eta-Products: The paper extensively uses products of Dedekind eta-functions, denoted as $\prod \eta(n_i z)^{b_i}$, which are known to be modular forms.
  • String Duality: The concept of string duality is crucial, allowing the authors to map between different string theory compactifications (heterotic and type IIB) and thus connect different mathematical descriptions.
  • K3 Surfaces and Elliptic Fibrations: The study of K3 surfaces, particularly those that are elliptically fibered, plays a central role. The classification of these surfaces and their properties, such as Nikulin automorphisms, is key.
  • Congruence Subgroups and Coset Graphs: The paper leverages the classification of torsion-free, genus zero congruence subgroups of the modular group and their associated Schreier coset graphs.
  • BPS State Counting: The authors connect eta-products to the generating functions for BPS states in supersymmetric theories, a fundamental concept in string theory.
  • Dessins d'Enfants: These combinatorial objects, representing ramified covers of the complex plane, are used to visualize and understand the relationships between K3 surfaces and modular groups.
  • q-Expansions and L-functions: The paper analyzes the q-expansions of eta-products and their connection to L-functions, which are important in number theory and physics.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical constructions and classifications rather than empirical data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Unification of Mathematical Objects: The paper reveals a profound and unexpected unity between multiplicative eta-products, specific types of K3 surfaces (those admitting Nikulin automorphisms), and the counting of BPS states in certain string theory compactifications.
  • String Duality as a Bridge: String duality acts as a powerful tool, enabling the authors to show that the K3 surfaces arising from heterotic string compactifications are precisely the same as those encountered in type IIB string theory.
  • The Significance of 24: The number 24 appears repeatedly, notably in the exponent of the Dedekind eta-function and in the partitions of 24, highlighting its fundamental role in these connections.
  • Mathieu Group M24 Connection: The paper establishes a surprising link between eta-products and the sporadic Mathieu group M24, suggesting that the coefficients of these eta-products encode representations of this group. This connection is termed "multiplicative Moonshine."
  • Geometric Interpretation of Eta-Products: The authors demonstrate that eta-products can be interpreted as partition functions that generate geometric objects, specifically K3 surfaces with specific properties.
  • Dessins d'Enfants as a Visual Tool: The use of dessins d'enfants provides a beautiful and intuitive way to visualize the relationships between modular subgroups, K3 surfaces, and their associated mathematical structures.

Key Results

  • The paper identifies a set of 30 multiplicative eta-products that correspond to specific K3 surfaces admitting Nikulin automorphisms.
  • It shows that these K3 surfaces are precisely those that arise from the compactification of type IIB string theory on K3 × T².
  • The paper establishes a correspondence between these K3 surfaces and torsion-free, genus zero congruence subgroups of the modular group.
  • Explicit equations for these K3 surfaces are derived from both the modular and Nikulin perspectives, demonstrating their equivalence.
  • A connection is made between the coefficients of certain eta-products and the characters of the sporadic Mathieu group M24.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Scope of Eta-Products: While the paper focuses on multiplicative eta-products, it acknowledges that other types of eta-quotients exist and could be explored.
  • Generalization of Mathieu Moonshine: The paper suggests that their "multiplicative Moonshine" is complementary to other forms of Mathieu Moonshine and that further investigation into their relationship is warranted.
  • Physical Interpretation of All Eta-Products: The authors pose the question of whether all eta-products can find interpretations as physical quantities, such as Gromov-Witten invariants.
  • Mirror Symmetry: The possibility of a mirror-type transformation mapping the geometric interpretations of eta-products from type IIB on Calabi-Yau spaces to those arising from string compactifications on K3 surfaces is suggested as a future research direction.
  • Further Exploration of M24 Connections: The paper hints at deeper connections between eta-products and the sporadic group M24, particularly in relation to elliptic genera and partition functions of dual heterotic compactifications.

Summary updated

Abstract

Inspired by the multiplicative nature of the Ramanujan modular discriminant, Δ, we consider physical realizations of certain multiplicative products over the Dedekind eta-function in two parallel directions: the generating function of BPS states in certain heterotic orbifolds and elliptic K3 surfaces associated to congruence subgroups of the modular group. We show that they are, after string duality to type II, the same K3 surfaces admitting Nikulin automorphisms. In due course, we will present identities arising from q-expansions as well as relations to the sporadic Mathieu group M 24.
BibTeX
@article{he2014eta,
  author = {Yang‐Hui He and John McKay},
  title = {{Eta products, BPS states and K3 surfaces}},
  journal = {Journal of High Energy Physics},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1007/jhep01(2014)113},
}
Figure