Abstract
Los sistemas de enseñanza convencional y de instrucción personalizada son comparados en relación al nivel de dominio de aprendizaje y al número de alumnos aprobados al finalizar el curso. Se seleccionaron 120 estudiantes del V ciclo de Psicología. La instrucción se realizó durante un semestre académico alternado, en el mismo curso y con igual contenido; consistió en la aplicación de la enseñanza convencional (grupo control) a cargo de un profesor mediante objetivos conductuales y la instrucción personalizada (grupo experimental) a cargo de un profesor y monitores, mediante unidades instruccionales cancelatorias. Aprobaron el 91.6 % de alumnos del grupo control y el 88.3 % del grupo experimental; el porcentaje de alumnos que obtuvieron un excelente dominio de las unidades fue el 16.6 % en el grupo control y el 88.3 % en el grupo experimental. Lo que indica mejores resultados cualitativos en el curso dictado con el sistema de instrucción personalizada (SIP) en comparación con el sistema de enseñanza convencional (SIC).
Introduction
This research, conducted at the Universidad Nacional Federico Villarreal in Peru, addresses a fundamental pedagogical question: Does the traditional lecture-based model prioritize schedules over actual student mastery? By comparing the Personalized System of Instruction (SIP/PSI)—also known as the Keller Plan—against Conventional Teaching (SIC/CTS), the study demonstrates that while traditional methods may achieve similar passing rates, personalized instruction leads to significantly deeper learning and higher academic excellence.
Methodology and Metrics
The study utilized a quasi-experimental design involving 120 Psychology students divided into two groups of 60. The Conventional System (SIC) followed a traditional lecture format with fixed exam dates, while the Personalized System (SIP) utilized modular units, self-pacing, and a mastery requirement where students had to prove competency before advancing.
To evaluate performance, the researchers categorized student outcomes into three distinct mastery levels based on their final grades:
Key Results
The most striking finding was the shift in grade distribution. While the conventional group had a slightly higher raw passing rate (91.6% vs 88.3%), the quality of that achievement differed drastically. In the SIC group, the majority of students fell into the "Good" category (grades 11-15), whereas in the SIP group, the distribution was heavily skewed toward "Excellent" (grades 16-20).
As shown in the data, the SIP group achieved a significantly higher mean grade of 16.4 compared to 13.7 in the conventional group. Remarkably, 88.3% of SIP students reached the "Excellent" mastery level, compared to only 16.6% in the SIC group. This suggests that when time is treated as a variable and mastery as a constant, students are capable of much higher levels of achievement.
Discussion and Conclusion
The results indicate that the Personalized System of Instruction (SIP) produces superior qualitative outcomes. By requiring students to be active participants who must master one concept before moving to the next, the "knowledge gaps" common in traditional education are minimized.
However, the study also noted challenges, such as the need for administrative support and the resource intensity of training student monitors. Future research should focus on long-term knowledge retention and strategies to help students transition from passive, lecture-based backgrounds into active, self-paced mastery systems.
Summary updated