Estimativa do impacto econômico da implantação de um protocolo hospitalar para detecção e tratamento precoce de sepse grave em hospitais púbicos e privados do sul do Brasil

Álvaro Köenig, Paulo Dorneles Picon, Janaína Feijó, Eliezer Silva, Glauco Adrieno WestphalRevista 2010 · DOI

Abstract

A protocol for early detection and treatment of in-hospital septic patients is highly cost-effective from a societal perspective.

Introduction

Sepsis is a critical medical emergency where organ dysfunction results from a dysregulated host response to infection. In Brazil, mortality rates for severe sepsis in Intensive Care Units (ICUs) can exceed 50%, representing a significant burden on the healthcare system. The "golden hour"—the initial period following the onset of sepsis—is vital for survival; however, many hospitals rely on reactive diagnosis rather than proactive screening. This study evaluates whether a structured, nurse-led early detection protocol can improve clinical outcomes and provide societal economic benefits in both public and private healthcare settings.

Methods

Researchers conducted a prospective "before-after" study across two general hospitals (one public, one private) in Joinville, Brazil, involving 217 patients with severe sepsis.

  • Phase I (Baseline): Patients received standard care based on Surviving Sepsis Campaign (SSC) guidelines without a proactive screening protocol.
  • Phase II (Intervention): A nurse-led early detection protocol was implemented. This included specialized training for nurses to identify early "red flags" (e.g., altered consciousness, decreased urine output) and systematic monitoring of vital signs every shift. If signs were detected, an intensivist performed an immediate evaluation.

The study measured clinical outcomes (mortality, time to detection) and economic impact. Economic analysis included direct hospital costs and indirect societal costs calculated via the Human Capital Approach, which values productive years of life lost (PYLL) due to premature death.

Results

Clinical Outcomes

The implementation of the protocol led to a dramatic reduction in the time required to detect sepsis. In the public hospital, detection time plummeted from 33.8 hours to just 6.9 hours. This faster identification translated directly into improved survival rates.

Table 3: Clinical characteristics and outcomes across study phases and hospital types.

As shown in the clinical data, absolute mortality dropped from 50% to 32.2% in the private hospital and from 67.6% to 41% in the public hospital (p < 0.05). These results underscore that the primary bottleneck in sepsis care is often identification rather than the treatment itself.

Economic and Societal Impact

While direct hospital treatment costs trended slightly higher in Phase II—likely because survivors require more intensive care than those who succumb quickly—the protocol proved highly cost-effective from a societal standpoint. The intervention was remarkably inexpensive to implement, costing approximately $1,382 USD per hospital for training and materials.

Table 2: Reduction in productive years of life lost (PYLL) per patient by hospital type.

By preventing premature deaths, the protocol saved an average of 2.38 years of productive life per patient in the private hospital and 5.16 years in the public hospital. The higher gain in the public sector is attributed to a younger average patient demographic. On a national scale, implementing this protocol across Brazil could potentially save between $3.2 billion and $9.7 billion USD annually in lost productivity.

Discussion

This study demonstrates that a low-cost, nurse-led screening protocol for sepsis is a powerful tool for both saving lives and preserving economic productivity. The proactive nature of the intervention addresses the critical need for early diagnosis.

Limitations include the study's geographic focus on two hospitals and the observational before-after design. Furthermore, direct cost tracking was more comprehensive for the private hospital than the public one due to reimbursement complexities in the Brazilian Unified Health System (SUS). Future research should aim for multi-center validation to confirm these macroeconomic benefits across diverse regions and hospital structures. Nonetheless, the evidence strongly supports the widespread adoption of early sepsis detection protocols as a high-value healthcare intervention.

Summary updated

Abstract

A protocol for early detection and treatment of in-hospital septic patients is highly cost-effective from a societal perspective.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{koenig2010estimativa,
  author = {Álvaro Köenig and Paulo Dorneles Picon and Janaína Feijó and Eliezer Silva and Glauco Adrieno Westphal},
  title = {{Estimativa do impacto econômico da implantação de um protocolo hospitalar para detecção e tratamento precoce de sepse grave em hospitais púbicos e privados do sul do Brasil}},
  booktitle = {Revista},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.1590/s0103-507x2010000300001},
}
Figure