Abstract
To estimate the weekly excess all-cause mortality in Norway and Sweden, and to estimate the years of life lost (YLL) attributed to COVID-19 in Sweden and the significance of mortality displacement. We found expected mortality by taking the declining trend and the seasonality in mortality into account. From the excess mortality in Sweden in 2019/20, we estimated the YLL attributed to COVID-19 using the life expectancy in different age groups. We adjusted this estimate for possible displacement using an auto-regressive model for the year-to-year variations in excess mortality. We found that excess all-cause mortality over the epidemic year (July to July) 2019/20 was 517 (95%CI -12, 1074) in Norway and 4329 (3331, 5325) in Sweden. There were reported 255 COVID-19 related deaths in Norway, and 5741 in Sweden, that year. During the epidemic period March 11 – November 11, there were 6247 reported COVID-19 deaths and 5517 (4701, 6330) excess deaths in Sweden. The estimated number of life-years lost attributed to the more relaxed Swedish strategy was 45850 (13915, 80276) without adjusting for mortality displacement and 43073 (12160, 85451) after adjusting for possible displacement.
Introduction
The global response to the COVID-19 pandemic saw a sharp divergence in public health strategies. While most nations, including Norway, implemented strict lockdowns and mandatory social distancing, Sweden famously adopted a more relaxed approach, relying heavily on voluntary measures. This policy difference created a natural experiment in the Nordic region. While Sweden's higher raw death toll was immediately evident, a critical academic debate emerged regarding the nature of these deaths. Proponents of the "mortality displacement" or "harvesting effect" hypothesis argued that the pandemic primarily claimed the lives of the very frail who would have died shortly regardless, implying that the "Years of Life Lost" (YLL) might be minimal. This study seeks to quantify the true human cost of Sweden's strategy by calculating YLL and rigorously testing the displacement hypothesis.
Methodology
To move beyond simple death counts, the researchers employed a multi-faceted statistical approach using 20 years of high-quality national registry data from Statistics Sweden (SCB) and Statistics Norway (SSB).
Baseline Estimation
The study established a mortality baseline by accounting for long-term declining trends and natural seasonality. Unlike models that exclude influenza peaks, this 20-year longitudinal analysis provides a robust expectation of what mortality would have looked like in the absence of the pandemic.
Years of Life Lost (YLL) Simulation
YLL was calculated by multiplying excess deaths within specific age groups by the remaining life expectancy for those cohorts. To account for statistical uncertainty, the team utilized Monte Carlo simulations, providing a range of probable outcomes rather than a single point estimate.
The AR(1) Displacement Model
To address the "harvesting" theory, the authors used a first-order auto-regressive (AR(1)) model. This model tested whether "excess" deaths in one period were statistically followed by "deficits" in subsequent periods. A strong negative correlation would support the displacement theory; a weak correlation would suggest that the deaths were truly premature.
Results
The analysis revealed a stark contrast between the two nations. For the epidemic year spanning July 2019 to July 2020, Sweden experienced 4,329 excess deaths (95% CI: 3,331–5,325), whereas Norway saw only 517.
The raw estimate for YLL in Sweden was 45,850 years. Crucially, after adjusting for potential mortality displacement using the AR(1) model, the estimate only decreased to 43,073 years. This indicates that mortality displacement accounted for only approximately 6% of the total years of life lost, effectively refuting the idea that the pandemic was merely "speeding up the inevitable" for the vast majority of victims.
Discussion
The findings debunk several common myths regarding the Swedish experience. One such myth is the "Dry Tinder" hypothesis, which suggested that Sweden's 2020 spike was high only because the 2018/19 flu season was mild. The data shows that the 2018/19 deficit accounts for less than 40% of the 2020 excess, meaning the pandemic's impact far outweighed any previous "savings."
Furthermore, the study found that excess all-cause mortality and reported COVID-19 deaths tracked very closely in Sweden. This validates official statistics, suggesting they were a reliable reflection of the pandemic's actual toll rather than an overcount.
Limitations
The study focuses exclusively on mortality and does not account for the burden of non-fatal illness, such as "Long COVID." Additionally, the model assumes that COVID-19 victims had a life expectancy similar to the average person in their age group. While standard deviations were used to mitigate this, it remains possible that victims had more underlying comorbidities than the average population.
Conclusion
The relaxed Swedish mitigation strategy resulted in a significant loss of life that cannot be explained away by mortality displacement. With over 43,000 years of life lost in a single year, the data suggests that the vast majority of these deaths were significantly premature. Future research incorporating Quality-Adjusted Life Years (QALYs) could provide an even more nuanced understanding of the long-term public health impacts of these divergent strategies.
Summary updated