Estimation of the Transmission Risk of the 2019-nCoV and Its Implication for Public Health Interventions

Biao Tang, Xia Wang, Qian Li, Nicola Luigi Bragazzi, Sanyi Tang, Yanni Xiao, Jian WuJournal of Clinical Medicine 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper estimates the high transmission risk of the early 2019-nCoV outbreak in Wuhan using mathematical modeling, finding a control reproduction number (Rc) as high as 6.47. It demonstrates that interventions like contact tracing, quarantine, and isolation are crucial for mitigating the epidemic, with travel restrictions showing a significant impact on reducing imported cases.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The emergence of the novel coronavirus (2019-nCoV) in Wuhan, China, presented a significant public health challenge due to its rapid spread. A critical need existed to understand the virus's transmission dynamics and the effectiveness of various public health interventions. Specifically, estimating the basic reproduction number (R0) and the control reproduction number (Rc) was essential for quantifying the outbreak's potential severity and guiding the intensity and type of interventions required. The paper aims to fill this gap by providing such estimations and analyzing the impact of measures like contact tracing, quarantine, isolation, and travel restrictions.

Methods

The authors employed a deterministic "Susceptible-Exposed-Infectious-Recovered" (SEIR) compartmental model. This model was extended to incorporate specific interventions by stratifying the population into compartments representing susceptible (S), exposed (E), pre-symptomatic infectious (A), symptomatic infectious (I), hospitalized (H), and recovered (R) individuals. Crucially, they further introduced compartments for quarantined susceptible (Sq), isolated exposed (Eq), and isolated infected (Iq) individuals to explicitly model the effects of quarantine and isolation.

Two primary methods were used for estimation:

  1. Likelihood-Based Method: This approach, based on White and Pagano [23], uses a formula to estimate the reproduction number by considering the serial interval distribution of the disease. Since the serial interval for 2019-nCoV was initially undetermined, they explored the sensitivity of their estimates to different mean generation intervals.
  2. Model-Based Method (Next Generation Matrix): They utilized the next generation matrix [21,22] to derive a formula for the control reproduction number (Rc) when control measures are in place. This involved fitting the SEIR model to the collected data using a Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) method with an adaptive Metropolis–Hastings algorithm.

Sensitivity analyses were conducted to assess the impact of varying contact rates (c) and quarantine rates (q) on the epidemic's peak time and value.

Datasets

The study primarily used publicly available data on laboratory-confirmed 2019-nCoV cases in mainland China. This data was sourced from:

  • World Health Organization (WHO) situation reports.
  • National Health Commission of the People's Republic of China.
  • Health Commission of Wuhan City and Hubei Province.

The data included cumulative reported cases and information on the quarantined and released population. Two revised datasets, dataRev1 and dataRev2, were generated to account for the early phase of the outbreak and to obtain more reliable data for analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • High Initial Transmission Risk: The 2019-nCoV exhibited a very high transmission potential in its early stages, as evidenced by the estimated control reproduction number (Rc) of up to 6.47. This is particularly concerning given the timing of the outbreak coinciding with the Chinese New Year, a period of increased social interaction.
  • Effectiveness of Interventions: The study strongly suggests that comprehensive public health interventions are vital. Intensive contact tracing followed by quarantine and isolation can significantly reduce the control reproduction number and transmission risk.
  • Travel Restrictions as a Powerful Tool: Travel restrictions, like the one implemented in Wuhan, were found to be highly effective in preventing the importation of infected individuals into other regions. The impact of such restrictions on reducing imported cases in Beijing was shown to be almost equivalent to a massive increase in quarantine efforts.
  • Interplay of Interventions: The effectiveness of interventions is not isolated. The paper highlights how reducing contact rates and increasing quarantine rates can collectively lower the peak of the epidemic and reduce the cumulative number of cases.
  • Model's Predictive Power: The developed model demonstrated a good ability to predict confirmed cases in the early days of the outbreak, validating its utility for understanding epidemic dynamics.

Key Results

  • Control Reproduction Number (Rc): The model-based estimation of the mean control reproduction number was 6.47 (95% CI 5.71–7.23).
  • Impact of Quarantine Rate (q): Increasing the quarantine rate by 10 or 20 times was predicted to bring forward the peak by 6.5 or 9 days, respectively, and reduce the peak number of infected individuals by 87% or 93%.
  • Impact of Travel Restriction on Beijing: With travel restrictions (no imported exposed individuals to Beijing), the number of infected individuals in seven days was projected to decrease by 91.14% in Beijing compared to a scenario without restrictions.
  • Peak Prediction: Under the most restrictive measures, the outbreak was expected to peak within two weeks (from January 23, 2020) with a significantly low peak value.
  • Model Prediction vs. Real Data: The model accurately predicted the number of confirmed cases for January 29, 2020, with a predicted value of 7723 closely matching the real number of 7711.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Limitations: The study acknowledges that during the initial phases of an epidemic, datasets are small, and crucial information may be missing. The quality, accuracy, and reliability of data improve over time, and estimations are highly dependent on the specific datasets used.
  • Asymptomatic Transmission: While the model considered asymptomatic cases, the paper notes that the possibility of spreading infection from asymptomatic cases was only recently reported [31], suggesting this aspect might require further refinement.
  • Serial Interval Uncertainty: The serial interval for 2019-nCoV was initially undetermined, leading to sensitivity analyses regarding its impact on reproduction number estimates.
  • Model Revision: The authors state that given the latest events (lock-down of Wuhan, adoption of travel restrictions, new detection technologies), the present model needs to be revised, and the estimated basic reproduction number may no longer be suitable for predicting future epidemic trends. This revision will be the aim of a forthcoming article.
  • Resource-Intensive Measures: The paper highlights the expense and resource intensity of measures like travel restrictions and extensive quarantine, posing challenges for decision-makers and city resilience. Future work could explore cost-effectiveness and sustainability of these measures.

Summary updated

Abstract

Since the emergence of the first cases in Wuhan, China, the novel coronavirus (2019-nCoV) infection has been quickly spreading out to other provinces and neighboring countries. Estimation of the basic reproduction number by means of mathematical modeling can be helpful for determining the potential and severity of an outbreak and providing critical information for identifying the type of disease interventions and intensity. A deterministic compartmental model was devised based on the clinical progression of the disease, epidemiological status of the individuals, and intervention measures. The estimations based on likelihood and model analysis show that the control reproduction number may be as high as 6.47 (95% CI 5.71-7.23). Sensitivity analyses show that interventions, such as intensive contact tracing followed by quarantine and isolation, can effectively reduce the control reproduction number and transmission risk, with the effect of travel restriction adopted by Wuhan on 2019-nCoV infection in Beijing being almost equivalent to increasing quarantine by a 100 thousand baseline value. It is essential to assess how the expensive, resource-intensive measures implemented by the Chinese authorities can contribute to the prevention and control of the 2019-nCoV infection, and how long they should be maintained. Under the most restrictive measures, the outbreak is expected to peak within two weeks (since 23 January 2020) with a significant low peak value. With travel restriction (no imported exposed individuals to Beijing), the number of infected individuals in seven days will decrease by 91.14% in Beijing, compared with the scenario of no travel restriction.
BibTeX
@article{tang2020estimation,
  author = {Biao Tang and Xia Wang and Qian Li and Nicola Luigi Bragazzi and Sanyi Tang and Yanni Xiao and Jian Wu},
  title = {{Estimation of the Transmission Risk of the 2019-nCoV and Its Implication for Public Health Interventions}},
  journal = {Journal of Clinical Medicine},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/jcm9020462},
}
Figure