Estimation of the neuromodulation parameters from the planned volume of tissue activated in deep brain stimulation

Viviana Gómez-Orozco, Mauricio A. Álvarez, Óscar Alberto Henao-Gallo, Genaro Daza-Santacoloma, Álvaro A. Orozco, Universidad Tecnológica de Pereira, Instituto de Epilepsia y Parkinson del Eje Cafetero - Neurocentro, Álvaro Ángel Orozco-GutiérrezRevista 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel machine learning approach to automatically determine the optimal stimulation parameters for Deep Brain Stimulation (DBS) by working backward from a desired "volume of tissue activated" (VTA). This could significantly streamline the complex and time-consuming process of tuning DBS devices, potentially leading to more effective and personalized treatments for movement disorders.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Deep Brain Stimulation (DBS) is a crucial therapy for movement disorders like Parkinson's disease. It involves implanting electrodes to deliver electrical pulses to specific brain regions. The effectiveness of DBS hinges on precisely controlling stimulation parameters such as amplitude, pulse width, and electrode configuration. However, determining these parameters is currently a trial-and-error process, heavily reliant on the experience of medical specialists and often requiring numerous clinical sessions. This is inefficient and can delay therapeutic benefits. The core challenge is the "inverse problem": given a desired therapeutic effect (represented by the spatial extent of neural activation, or VTA), how do we find the corresponding stimulation parameters? Existing methods struggle with complex electrode configurations and isotropic tissue assumptions.

Methods

The authors propose a two-stage methodology:

  1. Direct Problem (Simulation): They first build a sophisticated biophysical model to simulate the "volume of tissue activated" (VTA) for a given set of stimulation parameters. This involves:
  2. Extracellular Potential Model: Using COMSOL Multiphysics and the finite element method (FEM) to compute the electrical potential generated by the DBS electrode in a simulated brain tissue.
  3. Axonal Activation Model: Employing the NEURON simulation environment to model how neurons respond to this electrical potential, determining which axons are activated.
  4. This stage is computationally expensive, taking about an hour per simulation.
  5. Inverse Problem (Machine Learning): To overcome the computational burden of the direct problem, they develop a machine learning framework to solve the inverse problem:
  6. Dataset Generation: They run the direct problem simulation for 500 different combinations of stimulation parameters (amplitude, pulse width, and electrode contact configurations) to generate a dataset of VTA geometries and their corresponding parameters.
  7. Gaussian Process Emulator: To speed up the VTA generation for training, they use a Gaussian Process (GP) emulator, reducing simulation time from hours to minutes per configuration.
  8. Support Vector Machines (SVMs): The core of the inverse problem solution uses SVMs:
  9. Multi-output Support Vector Regression: For continuous parameters like amplitude and pulse width, they use a multi-output SVM regression approach, treating these parameters as correlated outputs.
  10. Support Vector Classification: For discrete parameters like electrode contact configuration (anode, cathode, or inactive), they employ separate SVM classifiers for each contact.
  11. The VTA geometry, represented as a high-dimensional binary vector (indicating activated/inactive mesh elements), serves as the input to the SVMs.

Datasets

The paper does not explicitly mention using pre-existing public datasets. Instead, they generate their own dataset by running simulations of the direct problem. This dataset consists of 500 samples, each containing:

  • A set of neurostimulation parameters (amplitude, pulse width, and electrode contact configurations).
  • The corresponding geometrical representation of the Volume of Tissue Activated (VTA), derived from the biophysical simulation.

This generated dataset serves as both the training and evaluation benchmark for their machine learning models.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging Biophysics and Machine Learning: The paper elegantly combines detailed biophysical modeling of neural activation with powerful machine learning techniques (SVMs) to tackle a complex inverse problem. This interdisciplinary approach is a significant contribution.
  • Solving the "Inverse" Problem: The core innovation is shifting from predicting VTA from parameters (direct problem) to predicting parameters from a desired VTA (inverse problem). This is crucial for practical clinical application.
  • Multi-output SVMs for Correlated Parameters: Using multi-output SVM regression for amplitude and pulse width acknowledges their interdependency in VTA generation, potentially leading to more accurate and robust predictions than treating them independently.
  • High-Dimensionality Handling: The use of SVMs with a Hamming distance kernel is well-suited for handling the high-dimensional binary vector representation of VTA geometries, a common challenge in spatial data analysis.
  • Dimensionality Reduction Impact: The study investigates the impact of VTA representation dimensionality on SVM performance, finding that for isotropic tissue models, lower resolutions can yield comparable results, simplifying the input space.

Key Results

  • Classification Accuracy: The SVM classifiers achieved accuracies over 80% for predicting electrode contact states (anode, cathode, inactive). Specifically, accuracies ranged from approximately 79.5% to 88.1% depending on the contact and input dimensionality.
  • Regression Performance: For amplitude and pulse width, the relative difference between predicted and test values was found to be around 24% for amplitude and 30% for pulse width, even with reduced input dimensionality.
  • Computational Efficiency: The use of a Gaussian Process emulator significantly reduced the computational cost of generating the dataset, making the overall approach more feasible.
  • Dimensionality Impact: The study found that for the isotropic tissue model used, reducing the dimensionality of the VTA representation (from ~178,000 elements down to ~1,780) did not significantly degrade the performance of the SVMs for classification or regression.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Isotropic Tissue Assumption: The current model assumes isotropic conductivity for brain tissue. The authors acknowledge that real brain tissue is anisotropic, and this simplification might limit the generalizability of the findings. Future work should incorporate anisotropic conductivity models.
  • Limited Parameter Space Exploration: While 500 samples were used, a more extensive dataset might further improve model performance.
  • Kernel Choice: The authors found that the Radial Basis Function (RBF) kernel performed poorly, and the Hamming distance kernel was preferred. Exploring other kernels or custom kernels that better exploit the geometric structure of VTA could be beneficial.
  • Simultaneous Classification and Regression: The current approach solves classification and regression problems independently. Future work could explore multi-task learning or transfer learning to solve these simultaneously, potentially improving overall performance.
  • Patient-Specific Models: The current methodology is based on a generic model. Adapting it for patient-specific brain anatomy and tissue properties would be a crucial next step for clinical translation.
  • Clinical Validation: The study presents promising results from simulations. The ultimate validation would involve testing this methodology in real-world clinical settings with actual DBS patients.

Summary updated

Abstract

<p>Deep brain stimulation (DBS) is a therapy with promissory results for the treatment of movement disorders. It delivers electric stimulation via an electrode to a specific target brain region. The spatial extent of neural response to this stimulation is known as volume of tissue activated (VTA). Changes in stimulation parameters that control VTA, such as amplitude, pulse width and electrode configuration can affect the effectiveness of the DBS therapy. In this study, we develop a novel methodology for estimating suitable DBS neuromodulation parameters, from planned VTA, that attempts to maximize the therapeutic effects, and to minimize the adverse effects of DBS. For estimating the continuous outputs (amplitude and pulse width), we use multi-output support vector regression, taking the geometry of the VTA as input space. For estimating the electrode polarity configuration, we perform several classification problems, also using support vector machines from the same input space. Our methodology attains promising results for both the regression setting, and for predicting electrode active contacts and their polarity. Combining biological neural modeling techniques together with machine learning, we introduce a novel area of research where parameters of neuromodulation in DBS can be tuned by manually specifying a desired geometric volume.</p>
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gomezorozco2016estimation,
  author = {Viviana Gómez-Orozco and Mauricio A. Álvarez and Óscar Alberto Henao-Gallo and Genaro Daza-Santacoloma and Álvaro A. Orozco and Universidad Tecnológica de Pereira and Genaro Daza-Santacoloma and Instituto de Epilepsia y Parkinson del Eje Cafetero - Neurocentro and Álvaro Ángel Orozco-Gutiérrez and Universidad Tecnológica de Pereira},
  title = {{Estimation of the neuromodulation parameters from the planned volume of tissue activated in deep brain stimulation}},
  booktitle = {Revista},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.17533/udea.redin.n79a02},
}
Figure