Estimation of Individual Treatment Effect in Latent Confounder Models via Adversarial Learning

Changhee Lee, Nicholas Mastronarde, Mihaela van der SchaararXiv 2018 · OpenReview

Abstract

Estimating the individual treatment effect (ITE) from observational data is essential in medicine. A central challenge in estimating the ITE is handling confounders, which are factors that affect both an intervention and its outcome. Most previous work relies on the unconfoundedness assumption, which posits that all the confounders are measured in the observational data. However, if there are unmeasurable (latent) confounders, then confounding bias is introduced. Fortunately, noisy proxies for the latent confounders are often available and can be used to make an unbiased estimate of the ITE. In this paper, we develop a novel adversarial learning framework, CEGAN, to make unbiased estimates of the ITE using noisy proxies.

Introduction

In fields like medicine and social science, determining the Individual Treatment Effect (ITE)—the specific impact of an intervention on an individual's outcome—is critical. While Randomized Controlled Trials (RCTs) are the gold standard, researchers often must rely on observational data. This data is frequently plagued by confounders, variables that influence both the treatment and the outcome.

Traditional machine learning models for ITE often assume "unconfoundedness," the belief that all relevant factors have been measured. In practice, many confounders are latent (unobserved), such as genetic predispositions or socio-economic status. Ignoring these hidden factors leads to biased estimates. This research introduces CEGAN (Causal Effect Generative Adversarial Network), a framework designed to estimate ITE by leveraging "noisy proxies" (imperfect measurements related to hidden factors) through an adversarial learning approach.

Methodology: The CEGAN Framework

CEGAN addresses the latent confounding problem by combining Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs) with a denoising autoencoder structure. The architecture is divided into two primary components:

  1. The Prediction Network (PN): This acts as the adversarial core. It utilizes a Generator (comprising an encoder, an inference subnetwork, and a prediction decoder) and a Discriminator. The goal is to learn a mapping between observed data (proxies $x$, treatment $t$, outcome $y$) and a latent space $z$. By employing a bidirectional GAN approach, the model matches the joint distribution of the encoded real data with the generated distribution, effectively marginalizing out latent confounders.
  2. The Reconstruction Network (RN): To ensure the latent space $z$ captures meaningful information, a denoising autoencoder is integrated. This forces the shared encoder to retain enough information to reconstruct the original inputs, preventing the model from converging on trivial or useless latent representations.
The CEGAN architecture, featuring the Reconstruction Network (RN) and the Prediction Network (PN) with its adversarial components.

Experimental Evaluation

The researchers evaluated CEGAN against several benchmarks, including Causal Forests, BART, and CEVAE, using two primary datasets:

  • TWINS Dataset: A semi-synthetic dataset based on real-world twin birth records in the USA. The "treatment" is being the heavier twin, and the "outcome" is mortality. Gestational age served as the latent confounder, with noisy proxies generated to test robustness.
  • Synthetic Toy Dataset: A controlled environment used to vary the standard deviation of noise ($\zeta$) in proxy variables, allowing for precise measurement of model failure points.

Key Results

In the TWINS dataset experiments, CEGAN consistently outperformed existing methods, particularly in scenarios involving latent confounding. As shown in the results table, CEGAN achieved the lowest error rates for both the Precision in Estimation of Heterogeneous Effect ($\sqrt{PEHE}$) and the Average Treatment Effect (ATE).

Performance comparison of CEGAN against baseline methods on the TWINS dataset, showing superior accuracy in latent confounding scenarios.

Notably, in the "latent confounding" out-of-sample test, CEGAN's ATE error was 0.021, a significant improvement over CEVAE (0.183) and Causal Forests (0.186). Furthermore, synthetic tests revealed that CEGAN is highly robust to noise; as proxy noise increased, CEGAN’s error grew much more slowly than its competitors.

Discussion and Insights

The superior performance of CEGAN, especially compared to the Variational Autoencoder-based CEVAE, is attributed to its streamlined inference process. While CEVAE must predict intermediate treatments and outcomes to infer the latent variable $z$, CEGAN’s adversarial approach avoids this accumulation of prediction error. Additionally, the reconstruction loss ($L_R$) serves as a vital regularizer, ensuring the GAN finds physically meaningful mappings to the latent space.

Conclusion

CEGAN provides a robust framework for ITE estimation in the presence of latent confounders. By utilizing noisy proxies and an adversarial bidirectional learning approach, it produces more stable and unbiased estimates than traditional methods. Future work may involve extending the model to handle continuous treatments and exploring ways to reduce the computational complexity inherent in adversarial training.

Summary updated

Abstract

Estimating the individual treatment effect (ITE) from observational data is essential in medicine. A central challenge in estimating the ITE is handling confounders, which are factors that affect both an intervention and its outcome. Most previous work relies on the unconfoundedness assumption, which posits that all the confounders are measured in the observational data. However, if there are unmeasurable (latent) confounders, then confounding bias is introduced. Fortunately, noisy proxies for the latent confounders are often available and can be used to make an unbiased estimate of the ITE. In this paper, we develop a novel adversarial learning framework to make unbiased estimates of the ITE using noisy proxies.
BibTeX
@misc{lee2018estimation,
  author = {Changhee Lee and Nicholas Mastronarde and Mihaela van der Schaar},
  title = {{Estimation of Individual Treatment Effect in Latent Confounder Models via Adversarial Learning}},
  year = {2018},
  eprint = {1811.08943},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1811.08943},
}
Figure