Estimation of fossil-fuel CO 2 emissions using satellite measurements of "proxy" species

I. B. Konovalov, E. V. Berezin, Philippe Ciais, Grégoire Broquet, R. Zhuravlev, Greet Janssens‐MaenhoutAtmospheric 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel "top-down" method to estimate fossil-fuel CO2 emissions by combining satellite measurements of "proxy" species (NO2 and CO) with atmospheric transport models and bottom-up emission inventories. The approach offers a way to identify potential biases and inconsistencies in existing CO2 emission inventories, with their most reliable estimate for Western Europe in 2008 being slightly lower than commonly used inventories.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Accurate estimation of carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions is crucial for understanding and mitigating climate change. While "bottom-up" emission inventories, based on economic activity and technology data, are widely used, they are known to have significant uncertainties, especially in rapidly developing economies. This paper addresses the challenge of improving the accuracy and identifying potential biases in these inventories by developing a "top-down" approach. This method leverages satellite observations of gases like nitrogen dioxide (NO2) and carbon monoxide (CO), which are co-emitted with CO2 from fossil-fuel burning, to provide independent constraints on emission estimates. The core problem is to disentangle the fossil-fuel CO2 signal from other atmospheric processes and to quantify the uncertainties associated with these new estimates.

Methods

The authors developed an inverse modeling method that integrates satellite measurements with a mesoscale chemistry transport model (CTM). The key steps are:

  1. Top-down Proxy Species Estimation: They first infer "top-down" estimates of regional anthropogenic NO2 and CO emissions directly from satellite measurements. Crucially, this step avoids using rigid "a priori" constraints from emission inventories, allowing for a more independent assessment.
  2. Emission Factor Application: Emission factors, representing the ratio of CO2 emissions to proxy species emissions (NOx-to-CO2 and CO-to-CO2), are derived from bottom-up emission inventories. These factors link the estimated proxy species emissions to CO2 emissions.
  3. Cross-validation and Combination: Estimates derived from different proxy species (NO2 and CO) are cross-validated and optimally combined to produce a "hybrid" FF CO2 emission estimate. This hybrid approach leverages the strengths of both satellite measurements and inventory data.

A significant aspect of their method is the robust estimation of uncertainties and the handling of systematic discrepancies between model simulations and satellite observations. They also developed techniques to validate their method using synthetic data (Observation System Simulation Experiments - OSSEs).

Datasets

The study utilizes the following datasets:

  • Satellite Measurements:
    • Tropospheric NO2 column retrievals from the OMI (Ozone Monitoring Instrument) satellite.
  • Total CO column amounts from the IASI (Infrared Atmospheric Sounding Interferometer) instrument on the Metop-A satellite.
  • Atmospheric Transport Model:
    • CHIMERE mesoscale CTM, used to simulate atmospheric transport and chemical processes.
  • Emission Inventories (for bottom-up data and conversion factors):
    • EMEP (European Monitoring and Evaluation Programme) regional emission inventory.
  • EDGAR v4.2 (Emission Database for Global Atmospheric Research).
  • CDIAC (Carbon Dioxide Information Analysis Center).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Proxy Species Power: NO2 measurements provide significantly stronger constraints on fossil-fuel CO2 emissions in the study region compared to CO measurements. This is likely due to NO2's shorter atmospheric lifetime and stronger link to combustion processes.
  • Hybrid Approach Value: Combining satellite data with emission inventories (the "hybrid" approach) yields more robust estimates than relying on either source alone. This integration helps to mitigate uncertainties from individual datasets.
  • Uncertainty Quantification is Key: The paper emphasizes the importance of rigorously evaluating uncertainties. Their subsampling technique provides a robust way to estimate confidence intervals, even when error characteristics are poorly known.
  • Potential for Inventory Improvement: The method has the potential to highlight inconsistencies and biases in existing bottom-up emission inventories, serving as a valuable tool for their refinement.
  • CO's Complementary Role: While CO measurements are less constraining than NO2, they still provide valuable additional information and enable cross-validation of estimates derived from NO2.

Key Results

  • The most reliable "hybrid" estimate for total annual fossil-fuel CO2 emissions in the Western European study region for 2008 was 2.71 ± 0.30 Pg CO2.
  • This estimate was approximately 11% lower than the EDGAR v4.2 inventory estimate (3.03 Pg CO2) and 5% lower than the CDIAC estimate (2.86 Pg CO2). The difference with CDIAC was not statistically significant.
  • NO2 measurements provided much stronger constraints on CO2 emissions than CO measurements.
  • The uncertainties in the top-down NO2 emission estimates were found to be relatively low (around 10%), while those for CO were significantly larger (up to 54% for specific sectors).
  • The study found that the EMEP emission inventory data were more consistent with satellite measurements than the EDGAR v4.2 data for NOx emissions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Uncertainty in Conversion Factors: The accuracy of the hybrid estimates is influenced by uncertainties in the emission conversion factors derived from bottom-up inventories. While they explored alternative inventories, a more comprehensive ensemble of inventories would be beneficial.
  • Model Error Representation: The study acknowledges that their error model for OSSEs is simplified and may not fully capture all possible model errors, particularly those related to chemical processes and boundary conditions.
  • Aggregation Errors: Aggregating emissions from different sectors and countries can introduce errors, which they attempted to account for but noted as a potential limitation.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest further research involving multi-model inversions and ensembles of independent emission inventories. They also propose incorporating retrievals from other satellite instruments (like GOME-2, MOPITT, AIRS) and integrating their hybrid CO2 emission estimates into global transport models for further validation. They also highlight the potential for applying this method to developing regions, where emission inventory uncertainties are likely higher.

Summary updated

Abstract

Fossil-fuel (FF) burning releases carbon dioxide (CO2) together with many other chemical species, some of which, such as nitrogen dioxide (NO2) and carbon monoxide (CO), are routinely monitored from space. This study examines the feasibility of estimation of FF CO2 emissions from large industrial regions by using NO2 and CO column retrievals from satellite measurements in combination with simulations by a mesoscale chemistry transport model (CTM). To this end, an inverse modeling method is developed that allows estimating FF CO2 emissions from different sectors of the economy, as well as the total CO2 emissions, in a given region. The key steps of the method are (1) inferring "top-down" estimates of the regional budget of anthropogenic NOx and CO emissions from satellite measurements of proxy species (NO2 and CO in the case considered) without using formal a priori constraints on these budgets, (2) the application of emission factors (the NOx-to-CO2 and CO-to-CO2 emission ratios in each sector) that relate FF CO2 emissions to the proxy species emissions and are evaluated by using data of "bottom-up" emission inventories, and (3) cross-validation and optimal combination of the estimates of CO2 emission budgets derived from measurements of the different proxy species. Uncertainties in the top-down estimates of the NOx and CO emissions are evaluated and systematic differences between the measured and simulated data are taken into account by using original robust techniques validated with synthetic data. To examine the potential of the method, it was applied to the budget of emissions for a western European region including 12 countries by using NO2 and CO column amounts retrieved from, respectively, the OMI and IASI satellite measurements and simulated by the CHIMERE mesoscale CTM, along with the emission conversion factors based on the EDGAR v4.2 emission inventory. The analysis was focused on evaluation of the uncertainty levels for the top-down NOx and CO emission estimates and "hybrid" estimates (that is, those based on both atmospheric measurements of a given proxy species and respective bottom-up emission inventory data) of FF CO2 emissions, as well as on examining consistency between the FF NO2 emission estimates derived from measurements of the different proxy species. It is found that NO2 measurements can provide much stronger constraints to the total annual FF CO2 emissions in the study region than CO measurements, the accuracy of the NO2-measurement-based CO2 emission estimate being mostly limited by the uncertainty in the top-down NOx emission estimate. Nonetheless, CO measurements are also found to be useful as they provide additional constraints to CO2 emissions and enable evaluation of the hybrid FF CO2 emission estimates obtained from NO2 measurements. Our most reliable estimate for the total annual FF CO2 emissions in the study region in 2008 (2.71 ± 0.30 Pg CO2) is found to be about 11 and 5 % lower than the respective estimates based on the EDGAR v.4.2 (3.03 Pg CO2) and CDIAC (2.86 Pg CO2) emission inventories, with the difference between our estimate and the CDIAC inventory data not being statistically significant. In general, the results of this study indicate that the proposed method has the potential to become a useful tool for identification of possible biases and/or inconsistencies in the bottom-up emission inventory data regarding CO2, NOx, and CO emissions from fossil-fuel burning in different regions of the world.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{konovalov2016estimation,
  author = {I. B. Konovalov and E. V. Berezin and Philippe Ciais and Grégoire Broquet and R. Zhuravlev and Greet Janssens‐Maenhout},
  title = {{Estimation of fossil-fuel CO <sub>2</sub> emissions using satellite measurements of \&amp;quot;proxy\&amp;quot; species}},
  booktitle = {Atmospheric},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.5194/acp-16-13509-2016},
}
Figure