Estimating the selection pressure and evolutionary rate of proteins on the non-neutral hypothesis of synonymous mutations

Jiachen Ye, Chunmei Cui, Rui Fan, Qinghua CuibioRxiv 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel method, iKa/Ks, to better estimate protein evolution by accounting for the non-neutral impact of synonymous mutations on miRNA regulation. This improved metric demonstrates superior performance in identifying genes under selection and correlates more strongly with gene expression patterns compared to the traditional Ka/Ks ratio.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The standard method for measuring protein evolution and selection pressure, the Ka/Ks ratio, relies on a key assumption: synonymous mutations (those that don't change the amino acid sequence) are neutral. However, recent research suggests this isn't always true. Synonymous mutations can actually influence gene function by altering how microRNAs (miRNAs) bind to messenger RNA (mRNA), potentially leading to diseases. This challenges the fundamental assumption of the Ka/Ks ratio, necessitating a more refined approach to accurately assess evolutionary dynamics.

Methods

The core of this work is the development of the iKa/Ks algorithm. Unlike the conventional Ka/Ks, which uses the overall synonymous substitution rate (Ks) as a baseline for neutral evolution, iKa/Ks recalculates this baseline. It specifically considers synonymous mutations that do affect miRNA binding, treating these as non-neutral. The algorithm identifies these "miRNA-synonymous" sites and uses them to adjust the calculation of the neutral substitution rate. This allows iKa/Ks to incorporate the impact of miRNA regulation on synonymous mutations, providing a more nuanced view of selection pressure.

Datasets

The study utilized coding sequences of orthologous genes between human (GRCh38) and mouse (GRCm39) obtained from Ensembl. Mature miRNA sequences were retrieved from miRBase v22. Gene expression profiles for 2275 orthologous gene pairs across 27 human and mouse tissues were sourced from a previous study by Su et al.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Synonymous mutations aren't always silent: The paper provides strong evidence that synonymous mutations can have functional consequences, particularly through their influence on miRNA binding.
  • miRNA regulation is a key evolutionary factor: By incorporating miRNA binding into the calculation, iKa/Ks offers a more accurate picture of evolutionary pressures.
  • iKa/Ks is more sensitive to selection: The new metric can identify genes under positive or negative selection that the traditional Ka/Ks ratio might miss.
  • Evolutionary rates correlate with gene expression: iKa/Ks shows a stronger link to gene expression distance, suggesting it better reflects functional divergence.

Key Results

  • Improved identification of selected genes: iKa/Ks identified 366 gene pairs with a ratio greater than 1 (indicating positive selection), compared to only 11 pairs identified by the conventional Ka/Ks ratio.
  • Stronger correlation with expression distance: iKa/Ks demonstrated a significantly higher Spearman's correlation coefficient with gene expression distance across various gene sets compared to Ka/Ks. For example, for N=50 gene pairs, iKa/Ks had a Rho of 0.48 (p-value=4.7e-4), while Ka/Ks had a Rho of 0.22 (p-value=0.12).
  • Case study success: The TMEM72/Tmem72 gene pair, previously thought to be under purifying selection (Ka/Ks=0.21), was identified as positively selected by iKa/Ks (iKa/Ks=1.13), supported by evidence of functional divergence.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that while iKa/Ks focuses on sequence-level disparities in coding regions, other factors like epigenetic modifications and non-coding regulatory elements also contribute to functional divergence. Future work could involve more comprehensive analyses integrating information from the entire genome, including upstream and downstream regions, and structural insights. Additionally, applying iKa/Ks to study SNPs within human populations could help identify important mutation sites relevant to human phenotype and disease.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The Nonsynonymous/Synonymous substitution rate ratio (Ka/Ks) is a commonly used metric to estimate the selection pressure and evolutionary rate of proteins in comparative genomics, which plays critical roles in molecular evolution in both biology and medicine. A fundamental assumption of Ka/Ks is that synonymous mutations are evolutionarily neutral and not subject to natural selection as they do not alter protein sequences and function. However, a number of studies have demonstrated that synonymous mutations are non-neutral and may lead to diseases through a number of mechanisms, such as altering miRNA regulation. This further implies that synonymous mutations also participate in the process of natural selection and thus Ka/Ks should be redefined as well. For this purpose, here we propose an improved Ka/Ks ratio, i Ka/Ks, which re-computed the neutral substitution rate by taking the altered status of miRNA binding into consideration, and thereby incorporate the impact of synonymous mutations on miRNA regulation. As a result, i Ka/Ks shows better performance than Ka/Ks when comparing them using their correlation with expression distance. Moreover, case studies showed that i Ka/Ks is able to identify the positive/negative selection genes that are missed by Ka/Ks. For example, TMEM72/Tmem72 is estimated to be positively selected by i Ka/Ks (1.13) but negatively selected by the conventional Ka/Ks ratio (0.21). Further evidence showed its rapid evolution, which further support the power of the new algorithm.
BibTeX
@misc{ye2024estimating,
  author = {Jiachen Ye and Chunmei Cui and Rui Fan and Qinghua Cui},
  title = {{Estimating the selection pressure and evolutionary rate of proteins on the non-neutral hypothesis of synonymous mutations}},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1101/2024.04.14.589335},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure