Estimating the COVID-19 epidemic trajectory and hospital capacity requirements in South West England: a mathematical modelling framework

Ross D. Booton, Louis MacGregor, Lucy Vass, Katharine J Looker, Catherine Hyams, Philip Bright, Irasha Harding, Rajeka Lazarus, Fergus Hamilton, Daniel J. Lawson, León Danon, Adrian Pratt, Richard M. Wood, Ellen Brooks‐Pollock, Katy TurnermedRxiv 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Early in the COVID-19 pandemic, localized evidence was critical for healthcare planning. This paper describes an open-source, age-structured SEIR (Susceptible-Exposed-Infectious-Recovered) mathematical model developed to estimate infection trajectories and hospital capacity requirements specifically for South West England (SW). By calibrating the model to regional data, the study provided the National Health Service (NHS) with estimates of the reproduction number ($R$), hospital bed occupancy, and the proportion of the population infected. As of May 11, 2020, the model estimated that 3.4% of the SW population had been infected and that lockdown measures had successfully reduced $R$ from 2.6 to 0.6.

Introduction

In the initial stages of the COVID-19 pandemic, national-level forecasting dominated the UK's public health strategy. However, these models were often heavily influenced by the epidemic's progression in London, which experienced an earlier and more intense surge than other regions. South West England presented a unique challenge: it has a distinct demographic profile—characterized by an older and more rural population—and its epidemic curve lagged behind the capital by approximately two weeks.

For local NHS authorities, "one size fits all" national projections were insufficient for managing hospital capacity and resource allocation. This research sought to provide a granular, region-specific modelling framework to support decision-making regarding acute and intensive care (IC) bed requirements and the timing of elective treatment resumption.

Methodology

Model Structure

The authors developed a deterministic, age-structured SEIR variant. To capture the nuances of disease transmission and severity, the population was divided into eight age cohorts (ranging from 0–4 to 70+). The model tracked individuals through several distinct states:

  • Susceptible and Exposed: Individuals at risk and those infected but not yet infectious.
  • Infectious States: Differentiated between asymptomatic and symptomatic individuals.
  • Clinical States: Tracked patients requiring Acute care or Intensive Care (IC).
  • Outcomes: Recovered or Deceased.

Calibration and Uncertainty

To address parameter uncertainty, the team employed Latin Hypercube Sampling (LHS) to generate 100,000 simulations across a range of plausible values. They then used Maximum Likelihood Estimation (MLE) to identify the 100 "best-fit" parameter sets that most closely aligned with observed cumulative cases and deaths in the South West.

Data Sources

The model integrated several key datasets:

  • PHE COVID-19 Dashboard: Regional cumulative cases and death counts.
  • Office for National Statistics (ONS): Weekly provisional death data and regional population estimates.
  • Contact Matrices: Baseline contact patterns from the POLYMOD survey, adjusted for post-lockdown changes using data from the CoMix study.

Key Results

The Impact of Interventions

The model quantified the efficacy of public health measures in the South West. The initial reproduction number ($R$) was estimated at 2.6 (95% CrI 2.0–3.2). Following the introduction of social distancing on March 15, 2020, $R$ fell slightly to 2.3. However, the implementation of full lockdown and school closures on March 23 led to a dramatic reduction, bringing $R$ down to 0.6 (95% CrI 0.5–0.7).

Regional Status as of May 11, 2020

By the time lockdown measures began to ease in mid-May, the model provided the following estimates for the South West:

  • Infection Prevalence: Approximately 5,793 individuals (0.10% of the population) were currently infectious.
  • Cumulative Exposure: An estimated 189,048 people (3.4% of the population) had been infected and recovered.
  • Healthcare Burden: Predicted hospital occupancy stood at 701 patients in acute beds and 110 in IC beds.

Discussion

The Importance of Granularity

By accounting for the South West’s older demographic, the model more accurately predicted the demand for hospital resources than national models might have. Furthermore, the two-week regional lag meant that national interventions were implemented at an earlier stage of the local outbreak, which likely played a significant role in preventing the regional healthcare system from being overwhelmed.

Estimating the Unobservable

A primary strength of this framework is its ability to estimate "unobservable" quantities. While testing was largely limited to hospital settings early in the pandemic, the model allowed researchers to estimate the total number of asymptomatic infections and the true extent of population immunity (recovered individuals).

Limitations and Future Work

The model operates as a closed system, assuming no migration in or out of the region—a reasonable but imperfect assumption during travel restrictions. Additionally, the current iteration does not account for nosocomial (in-hospital) transmission or deaths occurring in care homes and the wider community.

Future applications of this open-source tool include evaluating specific lockdown exit strategies and assessing how limited bed capacity might lead to excess deaths if demand exceeds supply. The framework remains portable and can be adapted for other geographies or more granular local authorities.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Objectives To develop a regional model of COVID-19 dynamics, for use in estimating the number of infections, deaths and required acute and intensive care (IC) beds using the South West of England (SW) as an example case. Design Open-source age-structured variant of a susceptible-exposed-infectious-recovered (SEIR) deterministic compartmental mathematical model. Latin hypercube sampling and maximum likelihood estimation were used to calibrate to cumulative cases and cumulative deaths. Setting SW at a time considered early in the pandemic, where National Health Service (NHS) authorities required evidence to guide localised planning and support decision-making. Participants Publicly-available data on COVID-19 patients. Primary and secondary outcome measures The expected numbers of infected cases, deaths due to COVID-19 infection, patient occupancy of acute and IC beds and the reproduction (“R”) number over time. Results SW model projections indicate that, as of the 11 th May 2020 (when ‘lockdown’ measures were eased), 5,793 (95% credible interval, CrI, 2,003 – 12,051) individuals were still infectious (0.10% of the total SW England population, 95%CrI 0.04 – 0.22%), and a total of 189,048 (95%CrI 141,580 – 277,955) had been infected with the virus (either asymptomatically or symptomatically), but recovered, which is 3.4% (95%CrI 2.5 – 5.0%) of the SW population. The total number of patients in acute and IC beds in the SW on the 11 th May 2020 was predicted to be 701 (95%CrI 169 – 1,543) and 110 (95%CrI 8 – 464) respectively. The R value in SW England was predicted to be 2.6 (95%CrI 2.0 – 3.2) prior to any interventions, with social distancing reducing this to 2.3 (95%CrI 1.8 – 2.9) and lockdown/ school closures further reducing the R value to 0.6 (95CrI% 0.5 – 0.7). Conclusions The developed model has proved a valuable asset for local and regional healthcare services. The model will be used further in the SW as the pandemic evolves, and – as open source software – is portable to healthcare systems in other geographies. Future work/ applications Open-source modelling tool available for wider use and re-use. Customisable to a number of granularities such as at the local, regional and national level. Supports a more holistic understanding of intervention efficacy through estimating unobservable quantities, e.g. asymptomatic population. While not presented here, future use of the model could evaluate the effect of various interventions on transmission of COVID-19. Further developments could consider the impact of bedded capacity in terms of resulting excess deaths.
BibTeX
@misc{booton2020estimating,
  author = {Ross D. Booton and Louis MacGregor and Lucy Vass and Katharine J Looker and Catherine Hyams and Philip Bright and Irasha Harding and Rajeka Lazarus and Fergus Hamilton and Daniel J. Lawson and León Danon and Adrian Pratt and Richard M. Wood and Ellen Brooks‐Pollock and Katy Turner},
  title = {{Estimating the COVID-19 epidemic trajectory and hospital capacity requirements in South West England: a mathematical modelling framework}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1101/2020.06.10.20084715},
  howpublished = {medRxiv},
}
Figure