Estimating the Carbon Emission of Construction Waste Recycling Using Grey Model and Life Cycle Assessment: A Case Study of Shanghai

Ting Wang, Kaiyi Li, Defu Liu, Yang Yang, Dong WuInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the under-quantified carbon emissions from construction waste recycling, a crucial step towards carbon neutrality. By combining a grey model for waste generation forecasting with a life cycle assessment (LCA) for emission estimation in Shanghai, it reveals that recycling 1 ton of construction waste saves 100.4 kg CO2-e, with significant potential for future emission reductions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While significant efforts are made to reduce carbon emissions in building design, construction, and operation, the end-of-life stage, specifically construction waste recycling, has received less attention. This oversight is problematic because the building sector is a major contributor to global carbon emissions, and China, as a rapidly developing nation, generates vast amounts of construction and demolition (C&D) waste. Existing waste management strategies in China lag behind developed economies, and reliable data for C&D waste is often scarce. This paper aims to fill this knowledge gap by providing a quantitative analysis of carbon emissions associated with construction waste recycling in Shanghai, a major urban center facing these challenges.

Methods

The study employs a two-pronged approach:

  1. Grey Model (GM (1,1)): This statistical method is used to forecast the future generation amount of construction waste in Shanghai. The grey model is particularly useful when dealing with limited or uncertain data, making it suitable for regions like China where comprehensive waste data can be challenging to obtain.
  2. Life Cycle Assessment (LCA): This established methodology is applied to estimate the carbon emissions associated with the recycling of different components of construction waste. The LCA considers both the "environmental costs" (emissions from the recycling process itself, including transportation and processing) and "environmental benefits" (the equivalent amount of carbon saved by using recycled materials instead of virgin ones).

Datasets

The study utilizes the following datasets:

  • Shanghai Statistics Yearbook 2021: This provided data on the construction area in Shanghai from 2010 to 2021.
  • Handbook of Green Building Evaluation Standards (GB/T 50378—2019): This provided the average waste generation per construction area (Gc).
  • Shanghai Construction Muck Comprehensive Service Monitoring Platform: This was used to obtain data on current construction sites, district distributions, and waste treatment plants for transportation distance calculations.
  • Composition of construction waste in Shanghai: Data from Ding and Xiao [9] was used to determine the proportions of concrete, brick/block, wood, steel, and mortar.
  • Carbon emission factors for various activities: Data was sourced from established databases like Ecoinvent [35] and previous studies (e.g., Wang et al. [2], Gu [23], Yang [34]) to quantify emissions from transportation, recycling processes, and material production.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Recycling is a Net Carbon Saver: The most significant takeaway is that, despite the energy and resources required for recycling, the overall process results in a net reduction of carbon emissions. This is primarily driven by the avoided emissions from producing new materials.
  • Steel Recycling's Outsized Impact: Steel recycling offers the largest carbon emission reduction per ton, significantly offsetting emissions from other waste streams. This highlights the importance of efficient steel recycling infrastructure and practices.
  • Data Scarcity is a Major Hurdle: The study explicitly mentions the challenge of insufficient data, underscoring the value of methods like the grey model that can operate with limited information. This also points to a broader need for improved waste data collection and standardization.
  • Context Matters: The study's focus on Shanghai demonstrates that the carbon impact of recycling is location-specific, influenced by factors like transportation distances, local recycling rates, and the composition of waste generated.
  • Beyond Direct Emissions: The inclusion of "recycling credits" (environmental benefits) is crucial for a holistic understanding, moving beyond just the direct emissions of the recycling process.

Key Results

  • Carbon Savings: Recycling 1 ton of construction waste in Shanghai saves approximately 100.4 kg CO2-e.
  • Waste Composition Impact:
    • Concrete recycling: 3.62 kg CO2-e saved per ton.
  • Brick recycling: 13.72 kg CO2-e saved per ton.
  • Mortar recycling: 0.12 kg CO2-e saved per ton.
  • Steel recycling: 117.72 kg CO2-e saved per ton.
  • Wood recycling: 0.14 kg CO2-e saved per ton.
  • Future Projections: The total carbon-emission-saving potential in Shanghai is projected to increase from 0.31 million t CO2-e in 2022 to 0.35 million t CO2-e in 2031, assuming current recycling rates.
  • Scenario Analysis: Under improved recycling scenarios (S1 and S2), the carbon emission reduction in 2031 could reach 51.43% and 102.86% respectively, compared to the current scenario.
  • Waste Generation Forecast: The annual generation of construction waste in Shanghai is predicted to increase from approximately 0.63 million t in 2022 to 0.77 million t in 2031.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Assumptions: The study acknowledges limitations due to assumptions, such as the treatment process for mortar waste and the exclusion of demolition waste, construction clay, and mud from the analysis. These omissions likely lead to an underestimation of the total carbon emissions.
  • Comparison with Landfilling: The paper notes that a comparison with traditional landfilling practices was not conducted, which could provide a more comprehensive understanding of the benefits of recycling.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that their methodology can be applied to other regions, especially where data is scarce. They also highlight the need to consider other waste types and disposal methods for a more complete picture. Future research could also focus on developing more accurate data collection methods and exploring advanced recycling technologies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Great efforts have been exerted in reducing carbon emissions in design, construction and operation stages. However, little attention is paid to the quantification of carbon emissions in construction waste recycling at the end-of-life stage. This study aims to quantitatively analyze the carbon emission of construction waste in Shanghai City, PR China. A grey model is used to forecast the generation amount of construction waste, and a life cycle assessment is performed to estimate the carbon emission of construction waste. In this study, both the carbon emission of recycling activities (environmental costs), and the equivalent amount of carbon generated from alternative materials (environmental benefit) are considered. Here, recycling 1 ton (t) of construction waste in Shanghai can save 100.4 kg CO<sub>2</sub>-e. The total carbon-emission-saving potential can be increased from 0.31 million t CO<sub>2</sub>-e (2022) to 0.35 million t CO<sub>2</sub>-e (2031). The carbon emission of recycling concrete, brick, steel, wood and mortar, identified as the key components of construction waste, is investigated. This research can help to reduce carbon emissions and further achieve carbon neutrality for Shanghai City. The proposed methods can also be applied to other regions, especially when the data for construction waste are insufficient.
BibTeX
@article{wang2022estimating,
  author = {Ting Wang and Kaiyi Li and Defu Liu and Yang Yang and Dong Wu},
  title = {{Estimating the Carbon Emission of Construction Waste Recycling Using Grey Model and Life Cycle Assessment: A Case Study of Shanghai}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph19148507},
}
Figure