Estimating multimodal brain variability in schizophrenia spectrum disorders: A worldwide ENIGMA study

Wolfgang Omlor, Finn Rabe, Simon Fuchs, Giacomo Cecere, Stephanie Homan, Werner Surbeck, Nils Kallen, Foivos Georgiadis, Tobias R. Spiller, Erich Seifritz, Thomas W. Weickert, Jason Bruggemann, Cynthia Shannon Weickert, Steven G. Potkin, Ryota Hashimoto, Kang Sim, Kelly Rootes-Murdy, Yann Quidé, Josselin Houenou, Nerisa Banaj, Daniela Vecchio, Fabrizio Piras, Gianfranco Spalletta, Raymond Salvador, Andriana Karuk, Edith Pomarol‐Clotet, Amanda Rodrigue, Godfrey D. Pearlson, David C. Glahn, David Tomeček, Filip Španiel, Antonín Škoch, Matthias Kirschner, Stefan Kaiser, Peter Kochunov, Fengmei Fan, Ole A. Andreassen, Lars T. Westlye, Pierre Berthet, Vince D. Calhoun, Fleur M. Howells, Anne Uhlmann, Freda Scheffler, Dan J. Stein, Felice Iasevoli, Murray J. Cairns, Vaughan J. Carr, Stanley V. Catts, Maria A. Di Biase, Assen Jablensky, Melissa J. Green, Frans Henskens, Paul Klauser, Carmel M. Loughland, Patricia T. Michie, Bryan Mowry, Christos Pantelis, Paul E. Rasser, Ulrich Schall, Rodney J. Scott, Andrew Zalesky, Andrea de Bartolomeis, Annarita Barone, Mariateresa Ciccarelli, Arturo Brunetti, Sirio Cocozza, Giuseppe Pontillo, Mario Tranfa, Annabella Di Giorgio, Sophia I. Thomopoulos, Neda Jahanshad, Paul M. Thompson, Theo G.m. van Erp, Jessica A. Turner, Philipp HomanbioRxiv 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

Schizophrenia is characterized by significant variability in brain structure, but the precise nature of this heterogeneity remains unclear. This study, using a massive international dataset, reveals that individuals with schizophrenia exhibit greater variability in frontotemporal brain regions compared to healthy controls, suggesting potential subtypes of the disorder. Conversely, certain areas like the left parahippocampal region show more consistent structural patterns across individuals with schizophrenia, hinting at core features of the illness.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Schizophrenia is a complex disorder with a wide range of symptoms and underlying biological mechanisms. A key challenge in understanding schizophrenia is its inherent heterogeneity, both in how it manifests and in the brain alterations observed. While previous research has often focused on average differences in brain structure between individuals with schizophrenia and healthy controls, this study shifts the focus to variability itself. The authors argue that understanding this variability is crucial for identifying distinct subtypes of schizophrenia, discovering reliable biomarkers, and potentially tailoring treatments. They aim to provide a comprehensive picture of how structural brain measures vary across individuals with schizophrenia and how this differs from healthy individuals.

Methods

The researchers employed a meta- and mega-analysis approach, combining data from 22 international sites through the Enhancing Neuroimaging Genetics through Meta-Analysis (ENIGMA) consortium. This allowed them to analyze a large sample size (up to 6139 individuals for certain measures) to overcome the limitations of smaller, individual studies.

They investigated several MRI-based brain measures:

  • Cortical thickness, surface area, and folding index: These measures capture the shape and complexity of the brain's outer layer (cortex).
  • Subcortical volume: This refers to the size of deeper brain structures.
  • Fractional anisotropy (FA): This measure quantifies the directionality of water diffusion in white matter tracts, providing insights into the integrity of neural connections.

To quantify variability, they used two primary metrics:

  • Variability Ratio (VR): This compares the variability of a specific brain measure in individuals with schizophrenia to that in healthy controls. A VR > 1 indicates greater variability in schizophrenia patients.
  • Coefficient of Variation Ratio (CVR): This metric also accounts for differences in the mean values between groups, offering a more nuanced comparison of variability.

Additionally, they used the Person-based Similarity Index (PBSI) to assess global similarity in brain structure across individuals within each group.

Datasets

The study utilized the ENIGMA dataset, which comprises MRI-based brain measures from 22 international sites. This dataset includes both individual-level data and group-level data, covering a substantial number of participants (up to 6139 for certain measures).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Frontotemporal Network as a Hotspot of Variability: The finding that frontotemporal regions show significantly higher variability in schizophrenia is a major insight. This suggests that the heterogeneity of schizophrenia might be rooted in the complex interactions within this network, potentially leading to different functional outcomes and symptom profiles.
  • Left Parahippocampal Region as a Consistent Feature: The observation of lower variability (higher homogeneity) in the left parahippocampal region is intriguing. This suggests that certain structural characteristics in this area might be a more consistent feature of schizophrenia, potentially shared across different subtypes. This could be a key area for identifying core neurobiological underpinnings of the disorder.
  • Multimodal Nature of Variability: The study's strength lies in its multimodal approach, examining various brain measures. This highlights that variability isn't confined to a single type of structural alteration but is a pervasive phenomenon across different aspects of brain anatomy.
  • Implications for Subtyping: The differential patterns of variability across brain regions strongly support the idea that schizophrenia is not a monolithic disorder but likely comprises distinct subtypes with different neuroanatomical profiles.

Key Results

  • Cortical Thickness: Individuals with schizophrenia showed greater variability in bilateral temporal and frontal regions, with the right middle temporal and left superior temporal areas showing the largest effect sizes.
  • Cortical Surface Area: Greater variability was observed in the right superior temporal regions, right supramarginal region, left postcentral region, and several other areas.
  • Cortical Folding Index: Higher heterogeneity was found in the right inferiortemporal region, while the left parahippocampal region showed lower heterogeneity (higher homogeneity).
  • Subcortical Volume: Lateral ventricles, particularly the left inferior lateral ventricle, showed distinctly higher variability in schizophrenia. Other subcortical regions like the pallidum, putamen, nucleus accumbens, and caudate also exhibited greater variability.
  • Fractional Anisotropy (FA): In contrast to gray matter measures, white matter tracts, specifically the superior fronto-occipital fasciculus, showed lower variability in schizophrenia compared to controls. However, some regions like the left uncinate fasciculus showed greater heterogeneity.
  • Global Similarity (PBSI): Globally, schizophrenia patients showed similar heterogeneity in cortical thickness compared to controls. However, they exhibited less heterogeneity (higher similarity) in cortical surface area, subcortical volume, and folding index, but more heterogeneity in fractional anisotropy.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Limitations: Not all data were individual-level, which could introduce bias. Additionally, the amount of fractional anisotropy data was lower than for other measures. The parcellation of gray and white matter networks was also described as coarse, suggesting that more fine-grained analyses in the future could yield more differentiated insights.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that further investigation into neuroanatomical features with regard to potential subgroups could be an interesting route for future studies. They also highlight the potential for these findings to guide precision medicine approaches in schizophrenia. The study underscores the critical role of variability in understanding complex disorders like schizophrenia, advocating for a more holistic approach to its neurobiology.

Summary updated

Abstract

Higher multimodal heterogeneity in frontotemporal regions potentially implies different subtypes of schizophrenia that converge on impaired frontotemporal interaction as a core feature of the disorder. Conversely, more homogeneous folding patterns in the left parahippocampal region might signify a consistent characteristic of schizophrenia shared across subtypes. These findings underscore the importance of structural brain variability in advancing our neurobiological understanding of schizophrenia, and aid in identifying illness subtypes as well as informative biomarkers.
BibTeX
@misc{omlor2023estimating,
  author = {Wolfgang Omlor and Finn Rabe and Simon Fuchs and Giacomo Cecere and Stephanie Homan and Werner Surbeck and Nils Kallen and Foivos Georgiadis and Tobias R. Spiller and Erich Seifritz and Thomas W. Weickert and Jason Bruggemann and Cynthia Shannon Weickert and Steven G. Potkin and Ryota Hashimoto and Kang Sim and Kelly Rootes-Murdy and Yann Quidé and Josselin Houenou and Nerisa Banaj and Daniela Vecchio and Fabrizio Piras and Fabrizio Piras and Gianfranco Spalletta and Raymond Salvador and Andriana Karuk and Edith Pomarol‐Clotet and Amanda Rodrigue and Godfrey D. Pearlson and David C. Glahn and David Tomeček and Filip Španiel and Antonín Škoch and Matthias Kirschner and Stefan Kaiser and Peter Kochunov and Fengmei Fan and Ole A. Andreassen and Lars T. Westlye and Pierre Berthet and Vince D. Calhoun and Fleur M. Howells and Anne Uhlmann and Freda Scheffler and Dan J. Stein and Felice Iasevoli and Murray J. Cairns and Vaughan J. Carr and Stanley V. Catts and Maria A. Di Biase and Assen Jablensky and Melissa J. Green and Frans Henskens and Paul Klauser and Carmel M. Loughland and Patricia T. Michie and Bryan Mowry and Christos Pantelis and Paul E. Rasser and Ulrich Schall and Rodney J. Scott and Andrew Zalesky and Andrea de Bartolomeis and Annarita Barone and Mariateresa Ciccarelli and Arturo Brunetti and Sirio Cocozza and Giuseppe Pontillo and Mario Tranfa and Annabella Di Giorgio and Sophia I. Thomopoulos and Neda Jahanshad and Paul M. Thompson and Theo G.M. van Erp and Jessica A. Turner and Philipp Homan},
  title = {{Estimating multimodal brain variability in schizophrenia spectrum disorders: A worldwide ENIGMA study}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1101/2023.09.22.559032},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure