Estimated disability weights for the severity of health outcomes: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Xiaoxue Liu, Yongbo Wang, Fang Wang, Haoyun Zhou, Qiuxia Zhang, Runtang Meng, Yong Yu, Yongchao Liu, Chuanhua YuPopulation 2025 · DOI

Abstract

The overall summary of disability weights obtained from this meta-analysis is reliable. This study indicates that respondents' sociodemographic characteristics may impact a population's preference for health states, which should be considered in future disability weight assessments.

Introduction

To quantify the global burden of disease, researchers utilize the Disability-Adjusted Life Year (DALY), where one DALY represents one lost year of "healthy" life. Central to this calculation are Disability Weights (DWs), a scale from 0 (perfect health) to 1 (equivalent to death). For instance, a condition with a DW of 0.5 implies that living with it for two years is equivalent to losing one year of life.

However, the perceived severity of a health state is subjective and can be influenced by cultural, economic, and social factors. While the Global Burden of Disease (GBD) 2013 study provides the current standard for these weights, there is a critical need to validate these metrics against diverse national surveys and understand how sociodemographic factors drive differences in perception. This study provides a comprehensive meta-analysis of disability weights for 235 health states, synthesizing data from over 610,000 respondents worldwide.

Methods

The researchers conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis following PRISMA guidelines to identify studies that utilized the Paired Comparison (PC) method. In this method, respondents choose the "healthier" individual between two hypothetical cases.

PRISMA flow diagram illustrating the systematic literature search and study selection process.

The study selection process, as shown in the PRISMA flow diagram, narrowed down thousands of initial database results to four primary studies that met the strict inclusion criteria. A random-effects meta-regression model was then used to estimate the summary effect of DW values across 235 unique health states. Additionally, univariate meta-regression was performed to analyze how demographic covariates—such as age, sex, education, and region—influenced the resulting weights.

Data Sources

The meta-analysis pooled data from four major sources, encompassing a total of 610,818 respondents:

  1. GBD 2013 Disability Weight Surveys: Data from 167 countries via web and regional surveys.
  2. Japanese Disability Weight Survey (2021): A national population-based study.
  3. Chinese Disability Weight Surveys (2022 & 2023): Two large-scale studies involving health professionals and the general public.

Key Findings

The study revealed a high degree of global consistency, with a Pearson’s correlation coefficient ($r > 0.9$) between the summarized weights and the original GBD 2013 values. This suggests a shared global hierarchy regarding the severity of various health conditions.

Sociodemographic Influences

Despite the general consensus, significant variations emerged based on demographics:

  • Age: As the proportion of older respondents (49+) increased, the DW for dementia rose, suggesting that those closer to the reality of cognitive decline perceive it as more severe.
  • Sex: A higher proportion of male respondents correlated with higher weights for traumatic brain injuries and amputations, potentially reflecting different social roles or physical labor risks.
  • Education: Higher education levels were associated with higher weights for symptomatic infectious diseases, possibly indicating a lower tolerance for preventable conditions.
  • Geography: GBD survey regions generally assigned higher weights to alcohol use disorders and lower weights to certain fractures compared to Asian regions (China and Japan).

Summary Metrics

The summarized DWs ranged from 0.008 (mild anemia) to 0.737 (moderate to severe heroin and opioid dependence), with a median value of 0.192. High-severity states, such as the terminal phase of cancer and severe spinal cord lesions, consistently ranked above 0.45. Notably, 73% of health states showed significant heterogeneity ($I^2 > 50\%$), indicating that while rankings are stable, exact values vary by population.

Discussion and Limitations

While the study benefits from a massive respondent pool, it is limited by the small number of studies (four) that met the strict PC method criteria. This constraint limits the feasibility of complex multi-variate analyses. Furthermore, the exclusion of "Population Health Equivalence" (PHE) methods and geographic gaps in data from Africa, Southeast Asia, and South America highlight areas for future research.

As global demographics shift, particularly with aging populations, disability weights should be updated periodically. This ensures that the metrics used to measure the global burden of disease remain reflective of contemporary societal values and perceptions.

Summary updated

Abstract

The overall summary of disability weights obtained from this meta-analysis is reliable. This study indicates that respondents' sociodemographic characteristics may impact a population's preference for health states, which should be considered in future disability weight assessments.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2025estimated,
  author = {Xiaoxue Liu and Yongbo Wang and Fang Wang and Haoyun Zhou and Qiuxia Zhang and Runtang Meng and Yong Yu and Yongchao Liu and Chuanhua Yu},
  title = {{Estimated disability weights for the severity of health outcomes: a systematic review and meta-analysis}},
  booktitle = {Population},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1186/s12963-025-00425-6},
}
Figure