Establishment of a clinically relevant beagle model for periprosthetic joint infection with 3D-printed prostheses and multimodal evaluation

Heng Liu, Tingting Fan, Rui Yuan, Shuai Lü, Daqiang Sun, Yong Huan, Maoqi Gong, Honghu Xiao, C. Wei, Hao Wang, Shijie Fan, Yilong He, Jialin Hu, Haoran Zhang, Hao Sun, Qi Gu, Yejun Zha, Xieyuan JiangJournal of Orthopaedic Translation 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a novel, clinically relevant beagle model for periprosthetic joint infection (PJI) by combining custom-designed 3D-printed prostheses with controlled bacterial inoculation. This model allows for a comprehensive, multimodal assessment of infection progression, offering a crucial preclinical platform for evaluating new therapies and understanding PJI pathogenesis.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Periprosthetic joint infection (PJI) is a severe complication following joint replacement surgery, leading to significant patient morbidity and healthcare costs. Developing effective treatments and preventative strategies hinges on having robust preclinical models that accurately mimic human PJI. While animal models are essential, existing ones often fall short due to:

  • Species Mismatch: Prostheses designed for humans don't fit animal anatomy well, leading to biomechanical issues like stress shielding and implant instability.
  • Lack of Standardization: Bacterial inoculation methods and quantities vary widely, making it difficult to compare results across studies.
  • Limited Evaluation: Many models rely on a single assessment method, failing to capture the multifaceted nature of PJI.

This paper aims to address these limitations by creating a more accurate and standardized beagle model for PJI.

Methods

The study employed a multi-pronged approach:

  1. 3D-Printed Prosthesis Design and Optimization:
    • CT-Based Design: Detailed CT scans of beagle hip anatomy were used to design two types of femoral prostheses: BFP-C (canine-optimized) and BFP-H (human-derived, scaled down).
  2. Mechanical and Biomechanical Analysis: Both prostheses underwent mechanical compression tests and finite element analysis (FEA) to evaluate stiffness, yield strength, and stress distribution under simulated physiological loading (postoperative and osseointegration phases). This was crucial for identifying potential stress shielding and implant stability issues.
  3. In Vivo Validation: The prostheses were implanted in beagles to assess their fit, stability, and biomechanical compatibility in a living system.
  4. Standardized PJI Model Establishment:
    • Species-Specific Prosthesis: The biomechanically superior BFP-C was selected for the PJI model.
  5. Hemi-Hip Arthroplasty (HHA): A surgical procedure was standardized for beagle hemi-hip arthroplasty.
  6. Quantitative Bacterial Inoculation: Staphylococcus aureus (S. aureus), a common pathogen in PJI, was inoculated in a controlled, dose-dependent manner (ranging from 250 to 10^8 colony-forming units (CFU)) directly into the femoral canal before prosthesis implantation.
  7. Multimodal Evaluation System:
    • Imaging: Radiography (X-ray and CT) was used to monitor bone quality, periosteal reactions, implant positioning, and soft tissue changes.
  8. Mechanical Testing: Pull-out tests were performed to quantify implant fixation strength and bone ingrowth.
  9. Histopathology: Hematoxylin-eosin (H&E), Masson's trichrome, and Giemsa staining were used to assess inflammation, bone destruction, collagen deposition, and bacterial presence/biofilm formation.
  10. Behavioral Assessment: Open-field tests (OFT) were conducted to quantitatively measure changes in animal mobility and activity levels.
  11. Physiological Monitoring: Body temperature and weight were tracked to monitor systemic responses to infection.
  12. Bacterial Cultures: Samples from peri-hip tissues and prosthesis surfaces were cultured to confirm bacterial load and identify the infecting agent.

Datasets

  • Beagle CT Scans: Used for designing the custom 3D-printed prostheses.
  • No new benchmark datasets were introduced. The study focused on developing and validating a new animal model.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Species-Specific Prosthesis Design is Paramount: The study strongly demonstrates that using a prosthesis designed for the specific anatomy of the animal (BFP-C) is critical. A human-derived prosthesis (BFP-H) led to significant biomechanical issues, including higher bone strain, potential damage, and even dislocation, highlighting the risks of anatomical mismatch.
  • Dose-Dependent PJI Progression: The model effectively shows a clear, non-linear relationship between the bacterial inoculum dose and the severity of PJI. Even low doses of S. aureus can establish infection, but higher doses lead to much more aggressive osteolysis, biofilm formation, and systemic effects.
  • Multimodal Evaluation is Essential: Combining imaging, biomechanical, histological, and behavioral assessments provides a comprehensive and sensitive picture of infection. This integrated approach is more powerful than any single method for understanding PJI dynamics and evaluating therapeutic interventions.
  • 3D Printing Enables Rapid Prototyping and Optimization: The study showcases the power of 3D printing for creating anatomically precise implants and rapidly iterating on designs based on biomechanical feedback.

Key Results

  • Biomechanical Superiority of BFP-C: The canine-optimized BFP-C exhibited significantly higher yield strength (12.3-fold) and structural stiffness compared to BFP-H. FEA showed BFP-C reduced peri-implant bone strain by 28-fold postoperatively, minimizing stress shielding.
  • Implant Stability: BFP-C demonstrated superior pull-out strength (2.2-fold higher at POD 0, 2.1-fold higher at POD 28) compared to BFP-H, indicating better osseointegration and stability.
  • Successful PJI Induction: All inoculated groups developed PJI.
  • Ultra-high-dose (10^8 CFU) groups: Exhibited severe osteolysis, significantly reduced pull-out strength (24 ± 8 N vs. 924 ± 45 N in controls), extensive biofilm, and a 74% reduction in distance traveled.
  • Low-dose (250 CFU) groups: Showed milder manifestations, including sinus tract formation and a 55.1% reduction in pull-out strength.
  • Dose-Dependent Systemic Effects: Higher bacterial doses led to increased body temperature, weight loss, and reduced mobility, mirroring clinical PJI symptoms.
  • Imaging Sensitivity: CT scans detected infection markers earlier than X-rays.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Pathogen Spectrum: The model primarily used S. aureus. Future work should incorporate other common pathogens (e.g., Gram-negative bacteria like Pseudomonas aeruginosa, E. coli) and investigate polymicrobial infections, which are prevalent in clinical PJI.
  • Observation Period: The study's observation period was limited to 28 days. Longer-term studies are needed to evaluate chronic inflammation, delayed immune responses, and tissue regeneration.
  • Sample Size: The relatively small number of animals per group might limit statistical robustness.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest leveraging this model to:
  • Investigate key pathogenic mechanisms (biofilm formation, immune evasion, osteolysis).
  • Assess the in vivo efficacy and safety of novel antimicrobial materials, antibiotic delivery systems, and immunomodulatory strategies.
  • Explore the use of 3D printing for patient-specific implants in revision surgeries.
  • Further optimize prosthesis design to mitigate stress shielding.

Summary updated

Abstract

Beyond serving as a preclinical platform for anti-infective therapies, the model provides actionable insights into optimizing human prosthetic biomechanics, such as reducing stress shielding through FEA-informed design principles. The 3D printing workflow further demonstrates rapid prototyping capabilities for patient-specific orthopaedic implants.
BibTeX
@article{liu2025establishment,
  author = {Heng Liu and Tingting Fan and Rui Yuan and Shuai Lü and Daqiang Sun and Yong Huan and Maoqi Gong and Honghu Xiao and C. Wei and Hao Wang and Shijie Fan and Yilong He and Jialin Hu and Haoran Zhang and Hao Sun and Qi Gu and Yejun Zha and Xieyuan Jiang},
  title = {{Establishment of a clinically relevant beagle model for periprosthetic joint infection with 3D-printed prostheses and multimodal evaluation}},
  journal = {Journal of Orthopaedic Translation},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1016/j.jot.2025.05.007},
}
Figure