Establishment and Resilience of Transplanted Gut Microbiota in Aged Mice

Ying Wang, Jinhui Tang, Qingqing Lv, Yuxiang Tan, Xiaoxiao Dong, Hongbin Liu, Nannan Zhao, Zhen He, Yan Kou, Yan Tan, Xinan Liu, Yang‐Yu Liu, Lei DaiSSRN 2021 · DOI

Abstract

As the gut microbiome ages, it often enters a state of dysbiosis characterized by reduced diversity and increased vulnerability to disease. Fecal microbiota transplantation (FMT) is a promising intervention to restore microbial health, yet the impact of donor age on long-term stability in aged recipients remains poorly understood. This study investigates whether "young" donor microbiota is superior to age-matched donor microbiota for treating aged hosts. Using a mouse model, we demonstrate that while both young and aged donor microbes can successfully colonize an antibiotic-depleted aged gut, only age-matched microbiota provides the resilience necessary to withstand subsequent inflammatory challenges. These findings suggest that biological compatibility and ecological co-evolution play critical roles in the success of microbiome-based therapies for the elderly.

Introduction

The gut microbiome undergoes significant structural and functional shifts during the aging process. This transition often leads to "dysbiosis"—a state of microbial imbalance linked to gastrointestinal disorders and systemic inflammation. While fecal microbiota transplantation (FMT) has proven effective in resetting microbial ecosystems in younger populations, its efficacy in the elderly is inconsistent, often marked by higher relapse rates.

A central question in clinical FMT is donor selection: is a "young, healthy" donor always the optimal choice, or does biological compatibility—specifically age-matching—facilitate better integration and persistence? This study explores how donor age influences the establishment, functional restoration, and long-term resilience of transplanted microbiota in an aged host environment.

Methods

The researchers utilized naturally aged female mice (20 months old, approximately equivalent to 60–70 human years) as recipients. The experimental protocol followed four distinct phases:

  1. Microbiota Depletion: Recipients were treated with a broad-spectrum antibiotic cocktail (ABH) to clear the existing gut flora, creating a niche for the transplant.
  2. Transplantation: Aged recipients were divided into groups receiving FMT from either age-matched (20-month-old) or age-unmatched (2-month-old) donors. A control group was allowed to undergo spontaneous recovery (SR) without intervention.
  3. Multi-omics Monitoring: The team employed 16S rRNA sequencing for taxonomic profiling, shotgun metagenomics to assess functional gene pathways (via the MetaCyc database), and RNA-seq to monitor colonic gene expression in the host over an eight-week period.
  4. Resilience Challenge: To test the stability of the new microbial communities, researchers induced temporary colonic inflammation using Dextran Sulfate Sodium (DSS) starting at Day 26, observing how each group responded to the perturbation.

Key Results

The Failure of Spontaneous Recovery

A critical finding was the "no-return" point of aging. Unlike younger mice, which often recover their gut diversity after antibiotic stress, the aged mice in the SR group showed a striking inability to restore their microbiota. This suggests that the "ecological memory" or the reservoir of commensal bacteria in the aged gut is severely diminished, making external intervention like FMT essential.

Initial Establishment vs. Long-term Resilience

Both young and aged donor microbes established themselves effectively in the short term. By Day 21, alpha diversity was fully restored in both FMT groups. However, the true difference emerged during the DSS stress test. The microbiota in mice that received age-matched FMT remained stable despite the inflammatory challenge. In contrast, the microbiota from young donors (FMT-UM) shifted significantly away from the donor profile, reverting toward a disturbed state. This indicates that while young microbes can colonize an aged gut, they lack the resilience to maintain that state under stress.

Functional and Transcriptomic Restoration

Metagenomic analysis revealed that 35 functional pathways failed to recover spontaneously in aged mice. Age-matched FMT successfully restored the majority of these pathways. Interestingly, while age-unmatched FMT was less effective at functional restoration, it had a more pronounced effect on reverting antibiotic-induced host gene changes. Specifically, FMT-M (matched) resulted in 174 differentially expressed genes (DEGs) compared to baseline, suggesting a more profound and compatible "reset" of the host tissue compared to the 98 DEGs observed in the unmatched group.

Discussion

The study introduces the concept of ecological compatibility. The authors hypothesize that an aged host and its native microbiota have co-evolved a specific state of homeostasis over time. Introducing a "young" microbiome into an aged environment creates a metastable state—one that looks healthy on the surface but is easily tipped back toward dysbiosis during inflammation.

Limitations and Future Directions

This research primarily utilized female mice; given that sex-based differences in microbiome resilience are well-documented, future studies should include male cohorts. Furthermore, while the study identifies the importance of age-matching, the specific molecular mechanisms—such as the role of the innate immune system or specific metabolites—remain to be elucidated.

Future clinical strategies might focus on "tuning" young donor microbiomes—perhaps through specific prebiotics—to simulate the resilience of age-matched donors. This could potentially offer a hybrid therapeutic benefit: the metabolic vigor of young microbes combined with the ecological stability of age-compatible ones.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{wang2021establishment,
  author = {Ying Wang and Jinhui Tang and Qingqing Lv and Yuxiang Tan and Xiaoxiao Dong and Hongbin Liu and Nannan Zhao and Zhen He and Yan Kou and Yan Tan and Xinan Liu and Yang‐Yu Liu and Lei Dai},
  title = {{Establishment and Resilience of Transplanted Gut Microbiota in Aged Mice}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.2139/ssrn.3848898},
  howpublished = {SSRN},
}

Loading related content...

Figure