Establishment and Biological Characteristics Analysis of a Hybrid Culter Lineage from Megalobrama amblycephala (♀) and Culter alburnus (♂)

Jinhui Huang, Yingying Yang, Jiawang Huang, Xiaoyu Huang, Jiaxuan Zhu, Yan-Yun Xiong, Lang Qin, Liang Hong, Ming Wen, Yuxiang Wang, Xu Huang, Fangzhou Hu, Wang Shi, Chang Wu, Shaojun LiuAnimals 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have successfully established a new, stable hybrid fish lineage (BTBTF₂-F₂) by self-crossing a previously developed hybrid between the blunt snout bream and topmouth culter. This new lineage exhibits stable genetic traits, intermediate morphology, and a unique epigenetic profile, offering a promising resource for aquaculture and a model for studying genetic inheritance in hybrids.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Aquaculture relies on developing fish varieties with improved traits like faster growth, disease resistance, and better meat quality. Intergeneric hybridization, crossing different species, is a powerful tool to achieve this, often leading to "hybrid vigor" or heterosis. However, creating stable, fertile hybrid lineages that consistently pass on desirable traits across generations is challenging. Previous work had created a fertile hybrid (BTBTF₁) between Megalobrama amblycephala (blunt snout bream, BSB) and Culter alburnus (topmouth culter, TC). This study aimed to establish and characterize a subsequent generation (BTBTF₂-F₂) from the self-crossing of BTBTF₁, to assess its genetic stability, biological characteristics, and potential for aquaculture.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach to characterize the new hybrid lineage:

  • Cytology: DNA content analysis using flow cytometry and chromosome preparation and observation were used to confirm the ploidy level and chromosome number of the hybrid lineage, ensuring it remained diploid with 48 chromosomes, consistent with its parents.
  • Morphological Traits: A comprehensive set of measurable and countable traits (e.g., body length ratios, fin ray counts) were analyzed to compare the hybrid to its parental species.
  • Genetic Analysis:
    • ITS Sequencing: The internal transcribed spacer (ITS) region of 45S rDNA was sequenced. This region is known for its rapid evolution and is useful for identifying species and hybrid origins.
  • Methylation-Sensitive Amplification Polymorphism (MSAP): This technique was used to assess DNA methylation patterns, an epigenetic modification that can influence gene expression and phenotypic variation.
  • RNA Sequencing (Transcriptomics): High-throughput sequencing of liver tissue RNA was performed to identify differentially expressed genes (DEGs) and understand gene expression patterns in the hybrid compared to its parents.
  • Statistical Analysis: Standard statistical methods, including ANOVA and pairwise comparisons, were used to analyze morphological data. For genetic data, specialized software and statistical criteria (e.g., FDR, |log2(Fold change)|) were applied.

Datasets

The study utilized samples from three distinct fish groups:

  • Megalobrama amblycephala (Blunt Snout Bream, BSB) - Parental species
  • Culter alburnus (Topmouth Culter, TC) - Parental species
  • BTBTF₁ - The first-generation hybrid (BSB ♀ × TC ♂)
  • BTBTF₂-F₂ - The second-generation hybrid lineage established by self-crossing BTBTF₁

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; the study focused on analyzing the biological characteristics of the established hybrid lineage using its parental species as controls.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Stable Allodiploid Lineage: The BTBTF₂-F₂ lineage consistently maintained a diploid chromosome number (2n=48) and showed remarkable intergenerational similarity in both phenotypic and molecular profiles, confirming its genetic stability.
  • Bidirectional Inheritance: The hybrid inherited genetic material from both parents, exhibiting a mix of traits. This bidirectional inheritance is crucial for maintaining hybrid vigor across generations.
  • Unique Epigenetic Signature: The hybrid lineage displayed a significantly reduced global DNA methylation level compared to its parents, with an increase in fully methylated states and a decrease in hemimethylated states. This epigenetic shift could be a key factor in its unique biological characteristics.
  • Paternal Bias in Gene Expression: Despite the maternal contribution from BSB (♀), the gene expression analysis revealed a significant bias towards the paternal parent (TC, ♂). This suggests that genomic elements, not just cytoplasmic inheritance, play a crucial role in shaping gene expression in hybrid progeny.
  • TC-Oriented Morphological Bias: While many traits were intermediate, certain morphological features, like the full-length-to-body length (FL/BL) and body length-to-head length (BL/HL) ratios, showed a significant bias towards the paternal TC lineage.

Key Results

  • Cytology: BTBTF₂-F₂ was confirmed as a diploid lineage with 48 chromosomes, similar to its parents. DNA content was also comparable across all tested groups.
  • Morphology: Most morphological traits were intermediate between BSB and TC. However, FL/BL and BL/HL ratios were significantly biased towards TC.
  • Genetics:
    • ITS: The hybrid inherited ITS1 sequences from both BSB and TC, confirming its hybrid origin and stable inheritance of these regions.
  • MSAP: BTBTF₂-F₂ showed a lower overall methylation level than its parents, with a distinct pattern of fully and hemimethylated sites, indicating a unique epigenetic profile.
  • Transcriptomics: 7877 differentially expressed genes (DEGs) were identified. Gene expression patterns showed a significant bias towards the paternal TC lineage, with a notable proportion of genes exhibiting additive expression.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Hybrid Vigor Correlation: While the study established a stable hybrid lineage with unique characteristics, it did not definitively quantify "hybrid vigor" or directly correlate it with the observed reduced methylation levels. Further research is needed to explore this relationship.
  • Mechanisms of Paternal Bias: The study identified a paternal bias in gene expression but suggests further investigation is needed to fully understand the underlying genomic mechanisms.
  • Aquaculture Potential: While the lineage is stable and fertile, its specific economic value and performance in aquaculture settings require more extensive testing and evaluation.

The authors suggest that this stable hybrid culter lineage provides a valuable resource for future genetic and breeding research in Culter, offering insights into the complex processes of genetic inheritance and stabilization in intergeneric hybrids.

Summary updated

Abstract

<i>Culter alburnus</i> (topmouth culter, TC) is extensively distributed in various rivers and lakes in China. As a widely adaptive fish species, they have significant economic value and special ecological roles. Intergeneric hybridization is a pivotal strategy for generating novel hybrid lineages and species. In a previous study, we obtained an improved bisexual hybrid culter, BTBTF<sub>1</sub>, derived from the hybrid lineage of <i>Megalobrama amblycephala</i> (blunt snout bream, BSB, 2n = 48, ♀) × <i>Culter alburnus</i> (2n = 48, ♂). In this study, we established an improved hybrid culter lineage by the self-crossing of BTBTF<sub>1</sub> and evaluated the biological characteristics regarding cytology, morphology, and genetics. DNA content and chromosome analyses confirmed that BTBTF<sub>1</sub>-F<sub>2</sub> was a diploid lineage (2n = 48), with morphological traits exhibiting intermediate values between parental species, except for significantly TC-biased full-length-to-body length (FL/BL) and body length-to-head length (BL/HL) ratios (<i>p</i> < 0.05). ITS sequencing analysis revealed that BTBTF<sub>1</sub>-F<sub>2</sub> inherited ITS1 sequences from BSB and TC. The global methylation level in BTBTF<sub>1</sub>-F<sub>2</sub> was substantially reduced compared to progenitors, characterized by elevated full and diminished hemimethylation states. Transcriptomic analysis identified 7877 differentially expressed genes (DEGs), displaying 9.05%/8.30% maternal (BSB)-dominant and 17.01%/18.95% paternal (TC)-dominant expression patterns in BTBTF<sub>1</sub> and F<sub>2</sub>. Remarkable intergenerational similarity in phenotypic and molecular profiles, coupled with bidirectional inheritance of progenitor characteristics, confirmed BTBTF<sub>1</sub>-F<sub>2</sub> as a genetically stable allodiploid lineage. Remarkably, methylation patterns, and DEG expression collectively demonstrated significant TC-oriented bias (<i>p</i> < 0.05). This study reports a novel stabilized allodiploid culter lineage after a comprehensive assessment at cytology, morphology, and genetic levels, and provides new insights into genetic bias in hybrid progeny.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{huang2025establishment,
  author = {Jinhui Huang and Yingying Yang and Jiawang Huang and Xiaoyu Huang and Jiaxuan Zhu and Yan-Yun Xiong and Lang Qin and Liang Hong and Ming Wen and Yuxiang Wang and Xu Huang and Fangzhou Hu and Wang Shi and Chang Wu and Shaojun Liu},
  title = {{Establishment and Biological Characteristics Analysis of a Hybrid Culter Lineage from Megalobrama amblycephala (♀) and Culter alburnus (♂)}},
  booktitle = {Animals},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/ani15243555},
}
Figure