Establishing an MSU service in a medium-sized German urban area—clinical and economic considerations

Johann S. Rink, Fabian Tollens, Andrej Tschalzev, Christian Bartelt, Armin Heinzl, Jens Hoffmann, Stefan O. Schoenberg, Annika Marzina, Vesile Sandikci, Carla Wiegand, Carolin Hoyer, Kristina SzaboFrontiers in Neurology 2024 · DOI

Abstract: This analysis provides a framework of determinants and considerations to be addressed during the design process of a novel Mobile Stroke Unit (MSU) program in order to balance stroke care improvements with the sustainable use of scarce resources.

Introduction

In stroke care, "time is brain." Mobile Stroke Units (MSUs)—ambulances equipped with CT scanners and specialized teams—allow clinicians to diagnose and treat strokes via intravenous thrombolysis (IVT) before the patient reaches the hospital. While MSUs are proven to improve outcomes in large metropolises and sparsely populated rural areas, their feasibility in medium-sized urban environments is less clear.

These units are expensive to operate, often costing over €1 million annually, and are rarely fully reimbursed by insurance. This study addresses the challenge of "right-sizing" an MSU service for a city like Mannheim, Germany (population ~310,000), where existing hospital-based stroke care is already high-performing, to ensure the investment yields meaningful improvements without wasting resources.

Methods and Datasets

The researchers employed a retrospective analysis combined with economic modeling using local stroke statistics from 2015 to 2021. The primary datasets included:

  • University Hospital Mannheim: Data from 5,221 patients with acute ischemic stroke (AIS).
  • Second Local Stroke Unit: Aggregated case statistics to estimate total city-wide incidence.

The team modeled various operating windows (8, 10, 16, and 24-hour shifts) and staffing configurations. They compared three models: a full on-board team, a resource-sharing model, and a teleneurology model. Additionally, they used "Openrouteservice" to simulate how expanding the driving radius would impact patient volume.

Key Insights and Discussion

The Noon Peak

Stroke onset is not distributed randomly throughout the day; data shows a significant peak around 1:00 PM. Consequently, a 10-hour daytime shift (9 AM – 7 PM) can capture 65.4% of all thrombolyzed patients. This suggests that limited daytime operations offer a much higher return on investment compared to 24/7 coverage.

Figure 1: Analysis of average time of day of thrombolysis initiation in a series of 1,775 patients.

Staffing and Teleneurology

Personnel costs are the primary economic burden, accounting for 58% of the total budget. The "standard" model of having a neurologist on-board is difficult to sustain in smaller cities. Moving to a teleneurology model—where the neurologist assesses the patient remotely—could reduce overall costs by 11.7%. However, current German regulations often require a physician on-scene, highlighting a gap between technological potential and legal frameworks.

Catchment Area Expansion

The simulation demonstrated that increasing the driving distance by just 5 minutes (from 15 to 20 minutes) could increase patient numbers by 30–40%. This indicates that for an MSU to be viable in a medium-sized city, it should likely serve surrounding areas outside the immediate city borders.

Figure 2: Simulated expansion of catchment zone showing the association between driving distance and patient numbers.

Key Results

  • Patient Volume: In a 10-hour weekday shift, the MSU would expect to admit 0.64 ischemic stroke patients per day, with 0.13 IVT treatments performed daily.
  • Annual Cost: The standard 10-hour/5-day model was estimated to cost €815,087 per year.
  • Cost per Patient: The cost per ischemic stroke patient treated ranged from €7,739 to €9,273, depending on the shift length.
  • Baseline Performance: Mannheim already has a high IVT rate of 22.5%, meaning the MSU must achieve high efficiency to demonstrate incremental clinical improvement.

Limitations and Future Work

The study relies on retrospective data and assumes a 50% rate of missed cases (due to simultaneous calls or dispatcher errors), which requires prospective validation. Furthermore, the economic benefits of teleneurology are currently constrained by legal requirements for on-site staff.

Future research should investigate the impact of newer thrombolytics like tenecteplase and focus on refining dispatcher protocols to improve the sensitivity of identifying stroke calls, ensuring the MSU reaches the right patients at the right time.

Summary updated

Abstract

This analysis provides a framework of determinants and considerations to be addressed during the design process of a novel MSU program in order to balance stroke care improvements with the sustainable use of scarce resources.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{rink2024establishing,
  author = {Johann S. Rink and Fabian Tollens and Andrej Tschalzev and Christian Bartelt and Armin Heinzl and Jens Hoffmann and Stefan O. Schoenberg and Annika Marzina and Vesile Sandikci and Carla Wiegand and Carolin Hoyer and Kristina Szabo},
  title = {{Establishing an MSU service in a medium-sized German urban area—clinical and economic considerations}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Neurology},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3389/fneur.2024.1358145},
}
Figure