Estabilidade e Resistência de Colunas em Perfis U Pultrudados Reforçados com Fibra de Vidro sob Falha Global

Mariana Brand, Alexandre Landesmann, André F. T. Martins, Dinar CamotimRevista 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the stability and resistance of U-shaped columns made from glass fiber reinforced polymer (GFRP) under global buckling (flexure or flexural-torsional). Using a combination of the Generalized Beam Theory (GBT) and the Finite Element Method (FEM), the study provides crucial insights into the post-buckling behavior and ultimate strength of these composite columns, essential for their safe and efficient design in civil construction.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The construction industry is increasingly adopting composite materials like Glass Fiber Reinforced Polymers (GFRPs) due to their advantageous properties such as structural efficiency, durability, and versatility in cross-sectional shapes. However, unlike traditional materials like steel, GFRPs exhibit anisotropic mechanical properties that vary with fiber content, resin type, and manufacturing processes, making their structural behavior more complex to predict. Specifically, slender GFRP profiles are prone to instability issues like buckling. While previous research has often focused on symmetrical profiles and local or simple flexural buckling, this study addresses the need for a comprehensive understanding of the global flexural and flexural-torsional buckling behavior of U-shaped GFRP columns, which are commonly used in construction. Accurately predicting their ultimate resistance is critical for ensuring structural integrity.

Methods

The research employs a two-stage numerical approach:

  1. Column Selection (GBTul): The Generalized Beam Theory (GBT) program, GBTul, was used to select appropriate column geometries and lengths that would exhibit global buckling modes (flexure or flexural-torsional). This involved analyzing various U-shaped cross-sections and their corresponding lengths to ensure the critical failure mode was global.
  2. Non-linear Analysis (FEM with ANSYS): The Finite Element Method (FEM) was applied using the commercial software ANSYS. This stage involved a non-linear physical and geometric analysis using shell elements (Shell 181) to simulate the buckling, post-buckling, and ultimate resistance behavior of the selected columns. Imperfections were introduced automatically based on the critical buckling mode shape, scaled by L/1000. The analysis utilized an incremental-iterative solution technique combining Newton-Raphson with an arc-length control strategy. The Tsai-Wu criterion was employed to identify the initial failure point.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on material properties and geometric parameters of GFRP U-profiles, drawing from existing literature and industry standards.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Anisotropy Matters: The inherent anisotropy of GFRP significantly influences buckling behavior, making it distinct from isotropic materials.
  • Flexural vs. Flexural-Torsional Buckling: The study clearly differentiates the post-buckling performance based on the dominant buckling mode. Columns failing by flexure (Fm) behave differently than those failing by flexural-torsional buckling (FMT).
  • Post-Buckling Reserve: Columns subjected to flexural-torsional buckling (FMT) demonstrate a notable energy reserve and can sustain loads beyond the critical buckling load (f/fcr > 1), indicating stable post-buckling behavior.
  • Limited Reserve for Flexural Buckling: In contrast, columns failing by pure flexure (Fm) do not exhibit significant post-buckling resistance and do not typically reach loads beyond the critical buckling load (f/fcr ≤ 1).
  • Influence of Length: For Fm-dominated buckling, longer columns tend to have trajectories that remain closer to a constant value after reaching their peak load. For FMT, shorter columns reach higher energy reserves more quickly.
  • Initial Failure Proximity to Critical Load: Initial failure (If=1) generally occurs close to the critical buckling load (fcr), with a slight variation depending on the buckling mode.

Key Results

  • Column Selection: Ten distinct U-shaped cross-sections were selected, leading to a total of forty-eight columns analyzed based on varying lengths.
  • Post-Buckling Behavior:
    • Columns subjected to flexural buckling (Fm) did not show post-buckling resistance and generally did not exceed the critical buckling load (f/fcr ≤ 1).
  • Columns subjected to flexural-torsional buckling (FMT) exhibited stable post-buckling behavior with a notable energy reserve, reaching values up to 1.856 fcr in some cases.
  • Initial Failure: Initial failure (If=1) occurred close to the critical buckling load (fcr), with an average variation of 5.07%. For Fm cases, the load at initial failure was less than fcr, while for FMT cases, it was sometimes higher and sometimes lower.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The study focuses on fixed-ended columns. The behavior of columns with different boundary conditions might vary.
  • The analysis is numerical; experimental validation would strengthen the findings.
  • The study considers specific GFRP material properties; variations in material composition could influence results.
  • Future Work:
    • The authors suggest that a more detailed investigation into the complete results and analysis can be found in the master's dissertation by Brand (2021).
  • Further research could explore the influence of different boundary conditions, material variations, and the impact of local buckling modes in conjunction with global buckling. Experimental validation would be a valuable next step.

Summary updated

Abstract

As diversas vantagens dos polímeros reforçados com fibras de vidro (PRFV), citando-se eficiência estrutural, durabilidade em ambientes agressivos, diversidade de seções transversais, leveza, alta resistência, fácil e rápida instalação, entre outros, têm estimulado o emprego deste sistema construtivo em distintos setores da construção civil. Neste contexto, o presente trabalho apresenta um estudo numérico-computacional sobre o desempenho de colunas engastadas constituídas de perfis U formadas a partir de PRFV sob modo de falha global por flexão ou flexo-torção. A primeira etapa consiste na cuidadosa seleção de colunas (geometria e comprimentos) a serem avaliadas, utilizando o programa GBTul (segundo a Teoria Generannlizada de Vigas). Em seguida, aplica-se o MEF (Método de Elementos Finitos) via código computacional/comercial Ansys para análise não-linear física e geométrica, com emprego de elementos de casca, para simulação do comportamento estrutural de flambagem, pós-flambagem e resistência última. Os resultados obtidos, nomeadamente trajetórias de equilíbrio, modos de flambagem e a resistência definida por um critério de colapso, são analisados para uma melhor compreensão da performance deste tipo de compósito.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{brand2022estabilidade,
  author = {Mariana Brand and Alexandre Landesmann and André F. T. Martins and Dinar Camotim},
  title = {{Estabilidade e Resistência de Colunas em Perfis U Pultrudados Reforçados com Fibra de Vidro sob Falha Global}},
  booktitle = {Revista},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.5335/rsaee.v19i2.13410},
}

Loading related content...

Figure