Erosion-Transportation Processes Influenced by Spatial Distribution of Terraces in Watershed in the Loess Hilly–Gully Region (LHGR), China

Zhe Gao, Genguang Zhang, Henghui Fan, Qianqian Ji, Anbin Li, Yuanyuan Zhang, Boyan Feng, Yuanhao Yu, Lin Ma, Jianen GaoWater 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses a novel 3D physical watershed model to investigate how the spatial arrangement of terraces impacts runoff and sediment transport in the Loess Hilly-Gully Region. The findings reveal that terrace placement significantly influences these processes, with upper and middle watershed locations offering the greatest erosion reduction benefits.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Soil erosion is a critical issue in the Loess Plateau, and terracing is a widely adopted measure to combat it. However, optimizing the spatial distribution of these terraces within a watershed remains a complex challenge. While previous research has explored various aspects of terrace effectiveness, accurately modeling and understanding the intricate, three-dimensional interactions between terrace layout, rainfall, runoff, and sediment transport in a real-world watershed context has been difficult. This paper aims to bridge this gap by providing a more nuanced understanding of how different terrace arrangements affect erosion and sediment yield, offering practical guidance for watershed management.

Methods

The core of this research lies in the development and application of a watershed-entity scale physical model. This model is a 1:100 scale, 3D reconstruction of the Kangjiagelao watershed, built to mimic its topographic and geomorphological features. The model allows for controlled rainfall experiments to simulate erosion and transport processes. A key innovation is the use of a spatial-coordinate system with the watershed outlet as the origin, enabling precise measurement of terrace positions (both longitudinal and vertical) and their relative distances. The study also introduces the concept of terrace-erosion-reduction benefit (Rt), defined as the reduction in the watershed-erosion modulus per unit of terrace area, to quantitatively assess the effectiveness of different terrace layouts.

Datasets

The study utilized data from the Kangjiagelao watershed, located in the Loess Hilly-Gully Region of China. This included topographic information and existing data on terraced fields and vegetation coverage. The physical model was constructed based on the watershed's prototype conditions from 2003 and 2018. The research also incorporated data from previous studies (cited in Table 8) to compare and validate their findings on terrace-erosion-reduction benefits across various watershed scales and conditions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Location Matters Most: The placement of terraces is not a minor detail; it has a profound impact on how water and sediment move through a watershed.
  • Upper is Often Better: Terraces located in the upper and middle parts of a watershed generally provide greater erosion reduction benefits compared to those in lower areas.
  • A Sweet Spot for Optimization: There appears to be an optimal "relative distance" (r) for terraces from the watershed outlet (around 0.35) where their erosion-reduction benefit is maximized. Beyond this point, the benefit plateaus or increases more slowly.
  • 3D Modeling is Powerful: The 3D physical model approach offers a more realistic and comprehensive way to study complex watershed processes than purely mathematical models, especially for understanding spatial interactions.
  • Terrace Area Threshold: The study suggests that the proportion of terraced area in a watershed should not exceed 40% to achieve optimal sediment reduction.

Key Results

  • Spatial Distribution Impacts: Changes in terrace spatial patterns significantly affected runoff and sediment production.
  • Quadratic Relationships: Approximate quadratic-function relationships were observed between terrace spatial location and parameters like runoff and confluence time.
  • Longitudinal and Vertical Benefits: The terrace-erosion-reduction benefit (Rt) was higher in the upper and middle watershed sections compared to the lower sections. Vertically, higher terrace placements yielded greater benefits.
  • Significant Erosion Reduction: Terraces in the middle and upper parts of the watershed, occupying 33% of the area, achieved a remarkable 77.67% erosion reduction.
  • Logarithmic Relationship with Distance: The terrace-erosion-reduction benefit (Rt) showed a logarithmic relationship with the relative distance (r) from the terrace's center to the watershed outlet. An inflection point for Rt growth was observed around r = 0.35.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Vegetation Restoration Time: The need to eradicate and then restore vegetation for model similarity significantly prolonged the experimental period and might have affected the accuracy of vegetation's role in the results.
  • Data Scatter: Verification data from other scholars showed considerable scatter, potentially due to variations in watershed area, terrace area, vegetation coverage, and the simplified methods used to define terrace positions in previous studies.
  • Landscape Pattern: The influence of the broader landscape pattern of terraces on results was not fully explored and is suggested as an area for future research.

Future work should focus on:

  • Simulating Vegetation: Developing methods for artificially simulating vegetation to reduce experimental time.
  • Broader Conditions: Investigating the influence of different rainfall intensities, vegetation coverages, land-use types, and operating times on terrace effectiveness.
  • Multi-Scale and Multi-Ecosystem Studies: Expanding research to different study areas and ecosystems, and conducting experiments at various scales to calibrate and verify findings.
  • Theoretical and Experimental Integration: Further exploring theoretical and experimental methods for a more complete understanding of terrace impacts.

Summary updated

Abstract

How to optimize the spatial distribution of terraces in the watershed is an important scientific problem. It was researched through a watershed solid-scale physical model based on the 3D reappearance of a scene under the Cartesian coordinate system, with the lowest point of the watershed as the origin. The results showed that the change of the spatial pattern of terraced fields in the basin had an important impact on the production of runoff and sediment. There was an approximate quadratic-function relationship between the spatial location and the parameters of runoff and confluence. If Rt was terrace-erosion-reduction benefit, it could be defined as the reduction in the watershed-erosion modulus per unit of terrace area. The longitudinal distribution of Rt was upper and middle > lower parts, and the vertical distribution of Rt was high > low place. The erosion reduction was 77.67% of the terraces of the middle and upper, occupying 33% of the watershed area. The change of the Rt was logarithmically related to the relative distance (r) from the center of the terrace. When r was around 0.35, there was an inflection point in Rt growth. The results of this study have important practical significance for the planning and construction of terraces in the watershed.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gao2022erosion,
  author = {Zhe Gao and Genguang Zhang and Henghui Fan and Qianqian Ji and Anbin Li and Yuanyuan Zhang and Boyan Feng and Yuanhao Yu and Lin Ma and Jianen Gao},
  title = {{Erosion-Transportation Processes Influenced by Spatial Distribution of Terraces in Watershed in the Loess Hilly–Gully Region (LHGR), China}},
  booktitle = {Water},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/w14121875},
}
Figure