Equity, diversity, and inclusion in sports analytics

Craig Fernandes, Jason D. Vescovi, Richard Norman, Cheri L. Bradish, Nathan Taback, Timothy C. Y. ChanJournal of Quantitative Analysis in Sports 2022 · arXiv

TL;DR

This paper presents the first formal evaluation of equity, diversity, and inclusion (EDI) within the sports analytics industry. The findings reveal a field dominated by young, White, heterosexual males, characterized by significant pay gaps and a disproportionately negative workplace experience for female professionals.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The field of sports analytics sits at a unique intersection of two worlds: professional sports and STEM (Science, Technology, Engineering, and Math). Both sectors have historically struggled with diversity and systemic exclusion. While individual anecdotes of discrimination in sports analytics have surfaced, there has been a lack of empirical, cross-industry data to quantify the state of EDI.

The authors set out to move beyond anecdotes by measuring personal demographics, job-related variables (like salary and tenure), and individual perceptions of workplace culture across the entire sports analytics ecosystem—from major leagues like the NBA and MLB to academic research groups and sports-tech startups.

Methods

The researchers conducted a cross-sectional study using an anonymous 27-question survey developed according to established EDI data-collection best practices.

  • Survey Design: The instrument utilized multiple-choice questions for demographics and Likert scales to measure perceptions of inclusion, support, and workplace climate.
  • Distribution: The team used a multi-pronged recruitment strategy, sending direct emails to 420 individuals across 27 professional sport organizations, 90 National Sport Organizations (NSOs), 264 NCAA universities, and various tech companies. They also leveraged the MIT Sloan Sports Analytics Conference (SSAC) Twitter account to reach a broader audience.
  • Analysis: The study employed univariate and cross-tabulated analysis. To compare salaries, they calculated means and standard deviations based on salary bucket midpoints and performed non-parametric statistical tests (Mann-Whitney U and permutation tests) to check for significance.

Datasets

The primary dataset consists of 233 eligible survey responses from professionals actively involved in sports analytics.

  • Organizational Breakdown: 54.1% worked in professional sports, 14.2% in academia/research, and 12.4% in sports tech companies.
  • Comparison Benchmarks: The authors compared their findings against broader STEM workforce data (e.g., Pew Research Center) to contextualize the lack of diversity in sports analytics relative to other technical fields.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Dominant Group" Profile: The data confirms a stark lack of diversity. A single cohort—young, White, heterosexual, and male—represents the overwhelming majority of the workforce. Specifically, 33% of all respondents fit every single one of these four criteria.
  • The "Work Harder" Paradox: One of the most striking "aha" moments involves the perception of effort. 36.3% of females "strongly agreed" that they must work harder than others to be valued equally, compared to only 9.8% of males.
  • Hidden Nuance in Racial Data: Initially, non-White respondents appeared to report more positive EDI experiences than White respondents. However, further stratification revealed this was a result of gender imbalance: 89.1% of non-White respondents were male. The high satisfaction of non-White males masked the significantly lower satisfaction of females across all racial groups.
  • The Education Gap: Interestingly, sports analytics professionals are more likely to hold advanced degrees (57.5% hold a postgraduate degree) compared to the general STEM workforce (29%). This suggests that the "barrier to entry" in sports analytics may be higher, potentially exacerbating existing inequities in access to elite education.

Key Results

  • Demographic Skew: The workforce is 82.0% male, 69.5% White, 89.7% heterosexual, and 72.0% under the age of 35.
  • The Pay Gap: In professional sports management, **males earned approximately $30,000 (27%) more** on average than females. A racial pay gap of $17,000 (14%) was also found between White and non-White management personnel.
  • Discrimination Frequency: Females were nearly five times more likely to experience discrimination in the workplace than their male counterparts (38.2% vs. 8.1%).
  • Retention Risks: Females were twice as likely as males to have considered leaving their jobs due to feeling isolated or unwelcome.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several constraints:

  • Sample Size: While "landmark" in scope, the sample size for specific subgroups (e.g., non-White females or senior executives) was small, which limited the statistical power of certain comparisons.
  • Voluntary Response Bias: The survey may have attracted individuals who already felt strongly about EDI issues, potentially skewing the results.
  • Categorical Breadth: The "non-White" category is highly heterogeneous; the authors suggest that future research needs more granular data to understand the unique experiences of Black, Latinx, and Indigenous professionals in the field.
  • Qualitative Depth: The study relied on quantitative scales. Future work should incorporate long-format interviews to capture the nuanced, lived experiences that numbers alone cannot fully describe.

The paper concludes with a call for salary transparency, targeted scholarships, and the establishment of dedicated EDI offices within sports organizations to move the needle toward a more inclusive industry.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper presents a landmark study of equity, diversity and inclusion (EDI) in the field of sports analytics. We developed a survey that examined personal and job-related demographics, as well as individual perceptions and experiences about EDI in the workplace. We sent the survey to individuals in the five major North American professional leagues, representatives from the Olympic and Paralympic Committees in Canada and the U.S., the NCAA Division I programs, companies in sports tech/analytics, and university research groups. Our findings indicate the presence of a clear dominant group in sports analytics identifying as: young (72.0%), White (69.5%), heterosexual (89.7%) and male (82.0%). Within professional sports, males in management positions earned roughly 30,000 USD (27%) more on average compared to females. A smaller but equally alarming pay gap of 17,000 USD (14%) was found between White and non-White management personnel. Of concern, females were nearly five times as likely to experience discrimination and twice as likely to have considered leaving their job due to isolation or feeling unwelcome. While they had similar levels of agreement regarding fair processes for rewards and compensation, females "strongly agreed" less often than males regarding equitable support, equitable workload, having a voice, and being taken seriously. Over one third (36.3%) of females indicated that they "strongly agreed" that they must work harder than others to be valued equally, compared to 9.8% of males. We conclude the paper with concrete recommendations that could be considered to create a more equitable, diverse and inclusive environment for individuals working within the sports analytics sector.
BibTeX
@article{fernandes2022equity,
  author = {Craig Fernandes and Jason D. Vescovi and Richard Norman and Cheri L. Bradish and Nathan Taback and Timothy C. Y. Chan},
  title = {{Equity, diversity, and inclusion in sports analytics}},
  journal = {Journal of Quantitative Analysis in Sports},
  year = {2022},
}
Figure