Equilibrium selection via current sheet relaxation and guide field amplification

Young Dae Yoon, Deirdre Wendel, Gunsu S YunOpenReview 2023 · OpenReview

Abstract

Although there is a continuous spectrum of current sheet equilibria, how a particular equilibrium is selected by a given system remains a mystery. Yet, only a limited number of equilibrium solutions are used for analyses of magnetized plasma phenomena. Here we present the exact process of equilibrium selection, by analyzing the relaxation process of a disequilibrated current sheet under a finite guide field. It is shown via phase-space analyses and particle-in-cell simulations that the current sheet relaxes in such a way that the guide field is locally amplified, yielding a mixed equilibrium from the spectrum. Comparisons to spacecraft observations and solar wind current sheet statistics demonstrate that such mixed equilibria are ubiquitous and exist as underlying local structures in various physical environments.

Introduction

Current sheets are fundamental structures in space and laboratory plasmas, acting as reservoirs of magnetic energy. When these sheets undergo processes like magnetic reconnection, they release energy that powers phenomena such as solar flares and the aurora borealis. While mathematical models provide a spectrum of stable "equilibrium" states—such as the Harris or force-free models—it has remained unclear why nature prefers specific "mixed" states. In real-world environments, these structures almost always contain a "guide field" (a magnetic component parallel to the current), which significantly alters plasma behavior. This study investigates the relaxation process that leads a disequilibrated plasma into a stable, mixed equilibrium under the influence of such fields.

Methodology

The researchers employed a dual approach combining theoretical modeling and numerical simulation. They first established a framework to classify particle orbits in a magnetic field reversal with a guide field, identifying three distinct classes: non-crossing (NC), double-well (DW), and single-well (SW).

These theoretical insights were tested using 1D particle-in-cell (PIC) simulations with the SMILEI code. Starting with an "under-heated" plasma sheet—where internal pressure is insufficient to balance external magnetic forces—the team observed the system's relaxation. The simulation results were directly compared with high-resolution in-situ data from NASA’s Magnetospheric Multiscale (MMS) mission and large-scale statistical surveys of over 10,000 current sheets in the solar wind.

The Mechanism of Equilibrium Selection

The study demonstrates that the "mixed" equilibrium state is the natural outcome of a relaxation process driven by local guide field amplification. As the current sheet pinches to find stability, it does not merely thin out; it actively amplifies the guide field at its center.

Figure 1: Comparison of Harris (a), force-free (b), and mixed (c) equilibria, alongside the proposed relaxation process (d) showing guide field amplification.

This macroscopic evolution is driven by microscopic "orbit class transitions." Ions primarily provide heating by moving into double-well orbits, while electrons drive the pinching and field amplification by transitioning into single-well orbits. This self-amplification mechanism is what ultimately selects the mixed equilibrium from the theoretical spectrum.

Results and Observational Validation

The simulations showed that an initially unstable sheet relaxes rapidly, within tens of ion cyclotron periods. The resulting profiles matched the complex magnetic and temperature structures observed by the MMS spacecraft, including the characteristic "double-peak" in parallel temperature and "single-peak" in perpendicular temperature.

Figure 2: Detailed view of a mixed equilibrium state, showing the spatial profiles of the magnetic field (black), plasma pressure (purple), and amplified guide field (dotted).

Furthermore, the model provides a theoretical basis for the observed scaling in solar wind data, where thinner sheets exhibit stronger currents. This relationship is a direct consequence of the more intense pinching and guide field amplification required for stability in thinner structures.

Conclusion and Future Work

This research clarifies how plasma current sheets select their stable configurations through a process of relaxation and guide field amplification. These mixed equilibria appear to be universal underlying structures in diverse physical environments. While the current 1D model captures the core physics, future 3D studies will be necessary to fully disentangle the effects of pure relaxation from the dynamics of active magnetic reconnection in complex astrophysical systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

Although there is a continuous spectrum of current sheet equilibria, how a particular equilibrium is selected by a given system remains a mystery. Yet, only a limited number of equilibrium solutions are used for analyses of magnetized plasma phenomena. Here we present the exact process of equilibrium selection, by analyzing the relaxation process of a disequilibrated current sheet under a finite guide field. It is shown via phase-space analyses and particle-in-cell simulations that the current sheet relaxes in such a way that the guide field is locally amplified, yielding a mixed equilibrium from the spectrum. Comparisons to spacecraft observations and solar wind current sheet statistics demonstrate that such mixed equilibria are ubiquitous and exist as underlying local structures in various physical environments.
BibTeX
@misc{yoon2023equilibrium,
  author = {Young Dae Yoon and Deirdre Wendel and Gunsu S YUN},
  title = {{Equilibrium selection via current sheet relaxation and guide field amplification}},
  year = {2023},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=hewqW4AZbo},
  howpublished = {OpenReview},
}

Loading related content...

Figure