Equation of state for helium-4 from microphysics

Tim Gollisch, C. WetterichPhysical 2002 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We compute the free energy of helium-4 near the lambda transition based on an exact renormalization-group equation. An approximate solution permits the determination of universal and nonuniversal thermodynamic properties starting from the microphysics of the two-particle interactions. The method does not suffer from infrared divergences. The critical chemical potential agrees with experiment. This supports a specific formulation of the functional integral that we have proposed recently. Our results for the equation of state reproduce the observed qualitative behavior. Despite certain quantitative shortcomings of our approximation, this demonstrates that ab initio calculations for collective phenomena become possible by modern renormalization-group methods.

Introduction: Bridging the Micro-Macro Divide

In condensed matter physics, a significant challenge lies in connecting microscopic atomic interactions to macroscopic thermodynamic behavior. Helium-4 serves as a quintessential test case; at low temperatures, it undergoes the "lambda transition" into a superfluid state. Mathematically, this transition is difficult to model due to infrared divergences—singularities arising from long-range fluctuations that break standard perturbative methods. While universal scaling laws are well-understood, calculating non-universal properties like absolute density or pressure directly from first principles (ab initio) has remained elusive.

Methodology: Functional Renormalization Group

The researchers utilized a Functional Renormalization Group (FRG) approach to bridge this gap. Rather than solving the many-body problem in one step, the FRG method systematically "integrates out" fluctuations across scales, moving from high-energy atomic interactions (defined by a Lennard-Jones potential) to low-energy thermodynamic scales.

A critical component of this work is the "$\Omega$ shift"—a mathematical adjustment to the chemical potential previously proposed by the authors. This shift ensures the functional integral formulation aligns correctly with the physical Hamiltonian. To maintain tractability, the effective average action was truncated using a derivative expansion, allowing for a flexible potential shape while keeping the mathematics manageable.

Key Results and Thermodynamic Properties

The model's predictions show remarkable agreement with experimental benchmarks. The calculated critical chemical potential ($\mu_c$) was found to be approximately -6.7 K, closely matching the experimental value of roughly -7.4 K. This validation underscores the necessity of the $\Omega$ shift in the theoretical framework.

Pressure as a function of temperature for different chemical potentials $\mu$ near the lambda transition.

Furthermore, the model successfully captured the "universal" critical exponents associated with the $O(2)$ universality class (e.g., $\nu \approx 0.675$), which define the fundamental shape of the phase transition.

Regarding the equation of state, the FRG approach qualitatively reproduced the observed behavior of helium-4's density. This includes the characteristic "peak" or cusp at the lambda point and the negative thermal expansion coefficient observed in the superfluid phase.

Calculated density of helium-4 near the lambda transition, illustrating the qualitative reproduction of the experimental density cusp.

Limitations and Future Outlook

While the qualitative success is clear, quantitative discrepancies remain. The absolute values for pressure and density exhibit sensitivity to the ultraviolet (UV) momentum cutoff, suggesting that higher-order effects—such as three-particle interactions or a more sophisticated treatment of high-frequency Matsubara modes—are required for full precision. Additionally, the current approximation uses a constant wave-function renormalization ($Z$), whereas a temperature- and momentum-dependent $Z$ would likely improve the accuracy of the density curves.

Despite these areas for refinement, this work demonstrates that modern renormalization-group methods can successfully navigate the transition from microphysics to the complex collective phenomena of superfluids.

Summary updated

Abstract

We compute the free energy of helium-4 near the lambda transition based on an exact renormalization-group equation. An approximate solution permits the determination of universal and nonuniversal thermodynamic properties starting from the microphysics of the two-particle interactions. The method does not suffer from infrared divergences. The critical chemical potential agrees with experiment. This supports a specific formulation of the functional integral that we have proposed recently. Our results for the equation of state reproduce the observed qualitative behavior. Despite certain quantitative shortcomings of our approximation, this demonstrates that ab initio calculations for collective phenomena become possible by modern renormalization-group methods.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gollisch2002equation,
  author = {Tim Gollisch and C. Wetterich},
  title = {{Equation of state for helium-4 from microphysics}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2002},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevb.65.134506},
}
Figure