Abstract
We consider two sharp next-order asymptotics problems, namely the asymptotics for the minimum energy for optimal point configurations and the asymptotics for the many-marginals Optimal Transport, in both cases with Riesz costs with inverse power-law long range interactions. The first problem describes the ground state of a Coulomb or Riesz gas, while the second appears as a semiclassical limit of the Density Functional Theory energy modelling a quantum version of the same system. Recently the second-order term in these expansions was precisely described, and corresponds respectively to a Jellium and to a Uniform Electron Gas model. The present work shows that for inverse-power-law interactions with power $s\in [d-2,d)$ in $d$ dimensions, the two problems have the same minimum value asymptotically. For the Coulomb case in $d=3$, our result verifies the physicists' long-standing conjecture regarding the equality of the second-order terms for these two problems. Furthermore, our work implies that, whereas minimum values are equal, the minimizers may be different. Moreover, provided that the crystallization hypothesis in $d=3$ holds, which is analogous to Abrikosov's conjecture in $d=2$, then our result verifies the physicists' conjectured $\approx 1.4442$ lower bound on the famous Lieb-Oxford constant. Our work also rigorously confirms some of the predictions formulated by physicists, regarding the optimal value of the Uniform Electron Gas second-order asymptotic term. We also show that on the whole range $s\in(0,d)$, the Uniform Electron Gas second-order constant is continuous in $s$.
Introduction
In the study of large systems of interacting particles, such as electrons in a solid-state lattice, determining the ground state energy—the lowest energy state of the system—is a fundamental challenge. For a system of $N$ particles, the total energy is dominated by a mean-field term proportional to $N^2$ as $N$ becomes large. However, the physical nuances of the system, including correlation and exchange effects, are contained within the "next-order" asymptotic term, typically scaling as $N^{1+s/d}$.
Historically, two distinct mathematical frameworks have been used to model this behavior. The Jellium model describes the ground state of a classical gas of points interacting via Riesz (power-law) potentials within a neutralizing background. Conversely, the Uniform Electron Gas (UEG) model emerges from the semiclassical limit of many-marginal Optimal Transport, a cornerstone of Density Functional Theory (DFT) for quantum systems. While physicists have long conjectured that these two models should yield identical energy constants in the limit, a rigorous mathematical proof has remained elusive—until now.
Bridging Classical and Semiclassical Models
This research provides a rigorous proof that the Jellium and UEG models share the same second-order asymptotic energy term for Riesz interactions with power $s \in [d-2, d)$ in $d$ dimensions. This range includes the critical 3D Coulomb case ($d=3, s=1$), thereby settling a long-standing conjecture in the physics community.
The core of the difficulty in previous attempts lay in the different ways these models handle particle constraints and boundary conditions. The Jellium model is often framed in terms of point configurations, while the UEG model is framed in terms of probability measures (marginals). By employing advanced tools from mathematical analysis, the authors demonstrate that the microscopic correlation energy is fundamentally identical regardless of whether the system is viewed through a classical or semiclassical lens.
Methodological Framework
The proof relies on several sophisticated analytical techniques to bridge the gap between the two minimization problems:
- Fefferman-Gregg Decomposition: Often called the "Swiss cheese lemma," this allows for the decomposition of space into disjoint balls of varying scales, facilitating the management of multi-scale interactions.
- Screening Properties: The authors use screening to modify particle configurations near boundaries. This ensures that local configurations can be "glued" together without incurring massive energy penalties, proving that boundary effects do not alter the bulk energy constant.
- Dimension Extension: For specific interaction powers, the problem is extended from $d$ dimensions to $d+1$ dimensions. This transformation converts non-local operators into local ones, making the underlying equations more tractable.
- Subadditivity Arguments: The existence of the limits is established by showing that the energy of a large system is approximately the sum of its parts, with the error term vanishing in the limit.
Key Insights and Physical Implications
The Lieb-Oxford Bound
One of the most significant outcomes of this work is the verification of the lower bound for the Lieb-Oxford constant. In DFT, the Lieb-Oxford inequality provides a bound on the exchange-correlation energy. This research confirms the conjectured value of $\approx 1.4442$ (assuming the crystallization hypothesis holds), providing a solid theoretical foundation for the functionals used in quantum chemistry calculations.
Energy vs. Geometry
A subtle but vital distinction highlighted by the paper is that while the minimum energy values of the Jellium and UEG models are equal, their minimizing configurations may differ. The Jellium model is expected to form a rigid crystal lattice (the Abrikosov conjecture). In contrast, the UEG minimizer, arising from optimal transport, might exhibit more fluid-like or non-crystalline characteristics. This suggests that the energy constant is a universal feature that is less sensitive to the specific geometric arrangement than previously thought.
Continuity and Universality
The study also establishes that the UEG second-order constant is continuous with respect to the power $s$ across the entire range $(0, d)$. This continuity reinforces the idea that these constants are fundamental properties of the interaction potential and the dimensionality of the space.
Conclusion and Future Directions
By proving the equality $C_{Jel}(s, d) = C_{UEG}(s, d)$, this work harmonizes classical and semiclassical approaches to many-body systems. While it settles the 3D Coulomb case, several questions remain. The behavior for very short-range interactions ($s < d-2$) in non-periodic settings is still an open problem for the Jellium model. Additionally, while the energies are now linked, the exact geometric nature of the UEG minimizers remains a subject for future investigation. Finally, the $s=0$ (logarithmic) case requires separate treatment due to its unique scaling behavior.
Summary updated