Epigenome-wide meta-analysis of blood DNA methylation and its association with subcortical volumes: findings from the ENIGMA Epigenetics Working Group

Tianye Jia, Congying Chu, Yun Liu, Jenny van Dongen, Nicola J. Armstrong, Mark E. Bastin, Tania Carrillo‐Roa, Anouk den Braber, Mathew A. Harris, Rick Jansen, Jingyu Liu, Michelle Luciano, Anil P. S. Ori, Roberto Roiz Santiañez, Barbara Ruggeri, Daniil Sarkisyan, Jean Shin, Kim Sungeun, Diana Tordesillas Gutiérrez, Dennis van ‘t Ent, David Ames, Éric Artiges, Georgy Bakalkin, Tobias Banaschewski, Arun L.w. Bokde, Henry Brodaty, Uli Bromberg, Rachel M. Brouwer, Christian Büchel, Erin Burke Quinlan, Wiepke Cahn, Greig I. de Zubicaray, Tomas J. Ekström, Herta Flor, Juliane H. Fröhner, Vincent Frouin, Hugh Garavan, Penny Gowland, Andreas Heinz, Bernd Ittermann, Neda Jahanshad, Jiyang Jiang, John B. Kwok, Nicholas G. Martin, Jean‐Luc Martinot, Karen A. Mather, Katie L. McMahon, Allan F. McRae, Frauke Nees, Dimitri Papadopoulos Orfanos, Tomáš Paus, Luise Poustka, Philipp G. Sämann, Peter R. Schofield, Michael N. Smolka, Lachlan T. Strike, Jalmar Teeuw, Anbupalam Thalamuthu, Julian N. Trollor, Henrik Walter, Joanna M. Wardlaw, Wei Wen, Robert Whelan, Liana G. Apostolova, Elisabeth B. Binder, Dorret I. Boomsma, Vince D. Calhoun, Benedicto Crespo‐Facorro, Ian J. Deary, Hilleke E. Hulshoff Pol, Roel A. Ophoff, Zdenka Pausová, Perminder S. Sachdev, Andrew J. Saykin, Margaret J. Wright, Paul M. Thompson, Günter Schumann, Sylvane DesrivièresbioRxiv 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This study leverages a large-scale epigenome-wide meta-analysis of blood DNA methylation to identify associations with subcortical brain volumes, specifically the hippocampus. The findings reveal that DNA methylation patterns in blood can serve as a peripheral biomarker for brain structure, offering new insights into the biological mechanisms underlying neurodegenerative and neuropsychiatric conditions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the biological underpinnings of brain structure and its relationship to cognitive function and disease is a major challenge. While genetic factors are well-studied, the role of epigenetics, particularly DNA methylation, is less understood, especially as a potential biomarker accessible through peripheral tissues like blood. Previous studies have been limited by small sample sizes, making it difficult to draw robust conclusions. This paper aims to address this gap by conducting a large-scale, multi-cohort epigenome-wide association study (EWAS) to investigate the association between blood DNA methylation and the volumes of key subcortical brain regions (hippocampus, thalamus, and nucleus accumbens), which are implicated in various neurological and psychiatric disorders.

Methods

The study employed a meta-analysis approach, combining data from eleven international cohorts to maximize statistical power. They performed epigenome-wide association studies (EWAS) to identify associations between individual CpG sites in blood DNA methylation and the volumes of the hippocampus, thalamus, and nucleus accumbens. Standard quality control and normalization procedures were applied to the DNA methylation data. For association analyses, linear regression models were used, controlling for relevant covariates such as sex, age, intracranial volume, and cell-type composition. To identify regions of coordinated methylation changes, cluster-based analyses were performed. Furthermore, the study investigated the functional implications of these methylation patterns by examining their effects on gene expression and their overlap with genetic associations for brain volume.

Datasets

The study utilized data from eleven international cohorts, totaling 3,337 individuals. Specific datasets mentioned include:

  • IMAGEN: A large European adolescent brain imaging study.
  • ARIES: A dataset for methylation quantitative trait loci (mQTL) analysis.
  • Lothian Birth Cohorts (1921 and 1936): Cohorts used for mQTL analysis.
  • Brisbane Systems Genetics Study: Another dataset used for mQTL analysis.
  • Genotype-Tissue Expression (GTEx) database: Used for expression quantitative trait loci (eQTL) analysis.
  • Blood-brain DNA methylation comparison tool: Used for correlating blood and brain methylation.
  • BECon: Another tool used for blood and brain methylation comparisons.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Blood as a Window to the Brain: The most significant finding is that DNA methylation patterns in blood can reflect variations in subcortical brain volumes, particularly the hippocampus. This validates the use of blood as a surrogate tissue for studying brain-related epigenetic mechanisms.
  • Hippocampus is Key: The hippocampus emerged as the primary region showing significant associations, highlighting its unique role in brain development and its susceptibility to epigenetic influences.
  • Cancer and Developmental Gene Links: CpG sites associated with hippocampal volume were enriched in genes related to cancer and developmental processes involving the H3K27 tri-methylation mark, suggesting a link between epigenetic regulation of stem cell fate and brain structure.
  • Metabolic Pathways Implicated: Differentially methylated regions (DMRs) associated with hippocampal volume affected genes involved in learning and memory, stem cell maintenance, and importantly, fatty acid metabolism and type-2 diabetes. This points to metabolic pathways as potential mediators of brain structure variation.

Key Results

  • Two significant CpG sites were identified that are associated with hippocampal volume at an experiment-wide false discovery rate (FDR) < 0.05.
  • No significant associations were found for thalamus and nucleus accumbens volumes.
  • The identified CpGs were annotated to the BAIAP2 (involved in learning and memory) and ECH1 (involved in fatty acid metabolism) genes.
  • Cluster-based analyses revealed differentially methylated regions (DMRs) associated with hippocampal volume, affecting genes involved in learning, memory, stem cell maintenance, fatty acid metabolism, and type-2 diabetes.
  • DNA methylation at these loci showed cis-effects on gene expression, influencing neighboring genes.
  • Correlations between blood and brain methylation were observed for some DMRs, suggesting that blood methylation patterns can mirror brain methylation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Thalamus and NAcc: The lack of significant findings for thalamus and nucleus accumbens volumes suggests that the observed blood-brain methylation associations might be more specific to certain brain regions or require larger sample sizes for these regions.
  • Cohort Size: A limitation acknowledged is the relatively small number of cohorts with available data for both MRI and DNA methylation, which restricts the power for certain analyses.
  • Causality: While associations are identified, the study design does not establish causality. Future work could involve longitudinal studies to track changes in methylation and brain volume over time.
  • Functional Validation: Further experimental validation is needed to fully elucidate the functional impact of the identified methylation marks on gene expression and brain function.
  • Modifiable Factors: The authors suggest that the identified links to metabolic pathways and cancer-related genes provide a basis for generating hypotheses about how modifiable factors like diet and lifestyle might influence brain structure and contribute to neurodegenerative diseases. Future research could explore these connections more directly.

Summary updated

Abstract

ABSTRACT DNA methylation, which is modulated by both genetic factors and environmental exposures, may offer a unique opportunity to discover novel biomarkers of disease-related brain phenotypes, even when measured in other tissues than brain, such as blood. A few studies of small sample sizes have revealed associations between blood DNA methylation and neuropsychopathology, however, large-scale epigenome-wide association studies (EWAS) are needed to investigate the utility of DNA methylation profiling as a peripheral marker for the brain. Here, in an analysis of eleven international cohorts, totalling 3,337 individuals, we report epigenome-wide meta-analyses of blood DNA methylation with volumes of the hippocampus, thalamus and nucleus accumbens (NAcc) –three subcortical regions selected for their associations with disease and heritability and volumetric variability. Analyses of individual CpGs revealed genome-wide significant associations with hippocampal volume at two loci. No significant associations were found for analyses of thalamus and nucleus accumbens volumes. CpG sites associated with hippocampus volume were significantly enriched within cancer-related genes and within regulatory elements containing the transcriptionally repressive histone H3K27 tri-methylation mark that is vital for stem cell fate specification. Cluster-based analyses revealed additional differentially methylated regions (DMRs) associated with hippocampal volume. DNA methylation at these loci affected expression of proximal genes involved in in learning and memory, stem cell maintenance and differentiation, fatty acid metabolism and type-2 diabetes. These DNA methylation marks, their interaction with genetic variants and their impact on gene expression offer new insights into the relationship between epigenetic variation and brain structure and may provide the basis for biomarker discovery in neurodegeneration and neuropsychiatric conditions.
BibTeX
@misc{jia2018epigenome,
  author = {Tianye Jia and Congying Chu and Yun Liu and Jenny van Dongen and Nicola J. Armstrong and Mark E. Bastin and Tania Carrillo‐Roa and Anouk den Braber and Mathew A. Harris and Rick Jansen and Jingyu Liu and Michelle Luciano and Anil P. S. Ori and Roberto Roiz Santiañez and Barbara Ruggeri and Daniil Sarkisyan and Jean Shin and Kim Sungeun and Diana Tordesillas Gutiérrez and Dennis van ‘t Ent and David Ames and Éric Artiges and Georgy Bakalkin and Tobias Banaschewski and Arun L.W. Bokde and Henry Brodaty and Uli Bromberg and Rachel M. Brouwer and Christian Büchel and Erin Burke Quinlan and Wiepke Cahn and Greig I. de Zubicaray and Tomas J. Ekström and Herta Flor and Juliane H. Fröhner and Vincent Frouin and Hugh Garavan and Penny Gowland and Andreas Heinz and Bernd Ittermann and Neda Jahanshad and Jiyang Jiang and John B. Kwok and Nicholas G. Martin and Jean‐Luc Martinot and Karen A. Mather and Katie L. McMahon and Allan F. McRae and Frauke Nees and Dimitri Papadopoulos Orfanos and Tomáš Paus and Luise Poustka and Philipp G. Sämann and Peter R. Schofield and Michael N. Smolka and Lachlan T. Strike and Jalmar Teeuw and Anbupalam Thalamuthu and Julian N. Trollor and Henrik Walter and Joanna M. Wardlaw and Wei Wen and Robert Whelan and Liana G. Apostolova and Elisabeth B. Binder and Dorret I. Boomsma and Vince D. Calhoun and Benedicto Crespo‐Facorro and Ian J. Deary and Hilleke E. Hulshoff Pol and Roel A. Ophoff and Zdenka Pausová and Perminder S. Sachdev and Andrew J. Saykin and Margaret J. Wright and Paul M. Thompson and Günter Schumann and Sylvane Desrivières},
  title = {{Epigenome-wide meta-analysis of blood DNA methylation and its association with subcortical volumes: findings from the ENIGMA Epigenetics Working Group}},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1101/460444},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure