Epigenetic Reprogramming Mediates Monocyte and Heterologous T Cell-derived Cytokine Responses after BCG Vaccination

Cancan Qi, Zhaoli Liu, Gizem Kılıç, Andrei Sarlea, Priya A. Debisarun, Xuan Liu, Yonatan Ayalew Mekonnen, Wenchao Li, Martin Graßhoff, Ahmed Alaswad, Apostolos Petkoglou, Valerie A. C. M. Koeken, Simone J.c.f.m. Moorlag, L. Charlotte J. de Bree, Vera P. Mourits, Leo A. B. Joosten, Yang Li, Mihai G. Netea, Cheng‐Jian XumedRxiv 2024 · DOI

Abstract

Epigenetic reprogramming is a cornerstone of immune memory, shaping both innate (trained immunity) and adaptive immune responses following Bacillus Calmette-Guérin (BCG) vaccination. While the role of histone modifications is well-documented, the impact of dynamic DNA methylation (DNAm) on long-term immunological traits has remained less clear. This study utilizes a longitudinal systems biology approach to analyze a cohort of 284 healthy individuals, integrating genetic, epigenetic, and cytokine response data at baseline, 14 days, and 90 days post-vaccination. Our findings reveal distinct short- and long-term DNAm patterns and identify baseline DNAm profiles as predictors of interferon-γ (IFN-γ) production. Notably, we identify the kisspeptin pathway as a novel regulator of IFN-γ and demonstrate that DNAm changes act as a critical mediator between genetic variants and cytokine responses. These results provide a deeper understanding of the mechanisms underlying trained immunity and highlight the importance of sex-specific effects in vaccine responses.

Introduction

The Bacillus Calmette-Guérin (BCG) vaccine, originally developed for tuberculosis, is recognized for its ability to provide heterologous protection against unrelated infections. This phenomenon, termed "trained immunity," is driven by the functional reprogramming of innate immune cells. While previous research has focused heavily on transient histone modifications, the role of DNA methylation—a more stable and potentially heritable epigenetic mark—in sustaining these immune traits has been inadequately elucidated.

This study addresses this knowledge gap by investigating how BCG vaccination alters the DNA methylome over time and how these alterations influence the body's ability to mount cytokine responses against non-target pathogens like Staphylococcus aureus. By mapping the interplay between genetics, epigenetics, and immune function, we aim to uncover the regulatory architecture of human trained immunity.

Methodology

We conducted a comprehensive analysis using the 300BCG cohort, consisting of 284 healthy Dutch individuals. Data were collected at three critical time points: baseline (T0), 14 days (T14), and 90 days (T90) post-vaccination.

Multi-omics Integration

To capture a holistic view of the immune landscape, we integrated:

  • Genome-wide DNA Methylation: Measured using Illumina EPIC arrays.
  • Genetics: Single Nucleotide Polymorphism (SNP) data to identify methylation quantitative trait loci (mQTLs).
  • Cytokine Profiling: Ex vivo stimulation of whole blood with S. aureus to measure the production of IL-1β, IL-6, TNF-α, and IFN-γ.

Statistical and Experimental Validation

We employed mediation analysis to determine if DNAm changes serve as a bridge between genetic predispositions and observed cytokine outputs. Furthermore, we performed in vitro validation of the kisspeptin pathway—a novel finding from our epigenetic screen—to confirm its functional role in modulating IFN-γ production.

Key Insights and Results

The Dynamic Nature of DNA Methylation

Our longitudinal analysis revealed that BCG-induced DNAm changes are not static. We observed a "recovery phase" at T14, where many methylation sites briefly trended back toward baseline, followed by the emergence of a distinct "late" signature at T90. This suggests that the epigenetic "memory" of the vaccine matures over months, rather than being fully established in the immediate aftermath of vaccination.

Kisspeptin: A Novel Immune Regulator

One of the most significant discoveries was the involvement of the kisspeptin (KISS1) receptor system. Traditionally known for its role in reproductive health and puberty, our data indicated that kisspeptin signaling is a potent modulator of the immune response. In vitro experiments confirmed that kisspeptin significantly inhibits IFN-γ production, identifying it as a previously unrecognized checkpoint in heterologous immunity.

Bridging Genetics and Immunity

Mediation analysis demonstrated that DNA methylation is a primary mechanism through which genetic variation influences vaccine response. For instance, we identified that changes at the cg21375332 site (near the SLC12A3 gene) mediate the relationship between specific genetic variants and the magnitude of the IFN-γ response after vaccination. In total, 18 unidirectional mediation linkages were identified, proving that persistent epigenetic modifications regulate cytokine production in both monocytes and T cells.

Predictive Modeling and Sex Differences

By combining baseline DNAm profiles with metabolic data, we could explain 56.1% of the variance in IFN-γ production at day 90. Interestingly, these responses were highly sex-specific. In women, short-term DNAm changes were associated with hormone-related pathways (e.g., GnRH), whereas in men, changes were more closely linked to nervous system pathways. This highlights the necessity of considering sex as a biological variable in vaccine research.

Discussion and Limitations

While this study provides a high-resolution map of the epigenetic changes following BCG vaccination, several limitations remain. The Illumina EPIC array, while robust, covers only ~3% of the human methylome, potentially missing regulatory events in non-covered regions. Additionally, because the analysis was performed on whole blood, cell-type-specific contributions (e.g., from specific monocyte subsets vs. T cells) require further investigation using single-cell technologies.

Despite these limitations, our findings underscore that DNA methylation is a stable, mediating layer that translates genetic potential into functional immune outcomes. This work paves the way for "personalized vaccinology," where baseline epigenetic signatures could be used to predict how an individual will respond to vaccination or to develop targeted interventions to enhance trained immunity in vulnerable populations.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Epigenetic reprogramming plays an important role in shaping immune memory traits within both innate (trained immunity) and adaptive immune cells following Bacillus Calmette-Guérin (BCG) vaccination. However, the precise impact of dynamic DNA methylation alterations on immunological responses after BCG vaccination remains inadequately elucidated. To address this knowledge gap, we conducted a comprehensive study by integrating longitudinal analysis and systems biology approaches. We established a cohort of 284 healthy Dutch individuals, capturing data on genetics, cytokine responses to ex vivo stimulation and genome-wide DNA methylation at baseline, as well as at 14 days and 90 days after BCG vaccination. Our findings revealed distinct patterns of DNA methylation alternations in the short- and long-term following BCG vaccination. Moreover, we established that baseline DNA methylation profiles exert influence on the change in interferon-γ (IFN-γ) production upon heterologous ( Staphylococcus aureus) stimulation before and after BCG vaccination. Specifically, we identified the regulation of kisspeptin as a novel pathway implicated in the modulation of IFN-γ production, and this finding has been substantiated through experiment validation. We also observed associations between BCG-induced DNA methylation changes and increased IFN-γ and Interleukin-1 β (IL-1β) production upon S. aureus stimulation. Interestingly, by integrating with genetic, epigenetic, and cytokine response data from the same individuals, mediation analysis demonstrated that most of the identified DNA methylation changes played a mediating role between genetic variants and cytokine responses, for example, the changes of cg21375332 near SLC12A3 gene mediated the regulation of genetic variants on IFN-γ changes after BCG vaccination. Sex-specific effects consistently manifested in DNA methylation changes after BCG vaccination and in the association between baseline methylation and cytokine responses. Together, our findings provide deeper insights into immune response mechanisms, crucial for developing effective epigenetic-based medical interventions for personalized medicine.
BibTeX
@misc{qi2024epigenetic,
  author = {Cancan Qi and Zhaoli Liu and Gizem Kılıç and Andrei Sarlea and Priya A. Debisarun and Xuan Liu and Yonatan Ayalew Mekonnen and Wenchao Li and Martin Graßhoff and Ahmed Alaswad and Apostolos Petkoglou and Valerie A. C. M. Koeken and Simone J.C.F.M. Moorlag and L. Charlotte J. de Bree and Vera P. Mourits and Leo A. B. Joosten and Yang Li and Mihai G. Netea and Cheng‐Jian Xu},
  title = {{Epigenetic Reprogramming Mediates Monocyte and Heterologous T Cell-derived Cytokine Responses after BCG Vaccination}},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1101/2024.03.27.24304976},
  howpublished = {medRxiv},
}
Figure