Epidemiology of traumatic spinal cord injury in Asia: A systematic review

Guangzhi Ning, Qiang Wu, Yulin Li, Shiqing FengJournal of Spinal Cord Medicine 2012 · DOI

TL;DR

This systematic review compiles existing epidemiological data on traumatic spinal cord injuries (TSCI) across Asia, highlighting significant variations in incidence, causes, and demographics compared to Western regions. The findings underscore the need for region-specific prevention strategies and improved data collection methods to address TSCI as a critical public health issue in Asia.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traumatic Spinal Cord Injury (TSCI) is a devastating condition leading to paralysis and significant lifelong disability, posing a substantial burden on individuals, families, and healthcare systems. While extensive research on TSCI epidemiology exists for North America, Europe, and Australia, there's a notable lack of comprehensive, systematic reviews for Asia. This gap is partly due to the absence of standardized TSCI registries in many Asian countries, making it challenging to accurately assess the scope and characteristics of TSCI in this diverse continent. Understanding these regional differences is crucial for developing effective, targeted preventative measures and clinical management strategies.

Methods

The authors conducted a systematic review of published literature on TSCI epidemiology in Asia. They searched multiple databases (PubMed, EBSCO, MEDLINE, EMBASE, Google Scholar) using keywords like "spinal cord injury," "traumatic spinal cord injury," "epidemiology," and "Asia," with no language restrictions. The review period spanned from January 1980 to December 2011. Two independent reviewers assessed the titles and abstracts of retrieved articles for eligibility, focusing on original studies reporting Asian TSCI epidemiological data. Data extraction included country, number of patients, source population, case criteria, incidence period, gender ratio, incidence, causes of injury, mean age, study design (prospective/retrospective), neurological level of injury, injury extent, and AIS/Frankel grade. Where information was incomplete, authors attempted to contact the original researchers.

Datasets

This paper is a systematic review and does not introduce new datasets or benchmarks. Instead, it synthesizes data from 39 previously published studies conducted across various Asian regions, including East Asia (China, Japan, Korea, Taiwan), Southeast Asia (Thailand), South Asia (Pakistan, India, Bangladesh, Nepal), and West Asia (Afghanistan, Iran, Turkey, Jordan, Saudi Arabia, Qatar, Israel).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Asia's Unique Epidemiological Landscape: TSCI epidemiology in Asia differs significantly from Western countries, necessitating tailored interventions.
  • Data Scarcity and Heterogeneity: A major challenge is the lack of standardized registries and consistent case definitions across Asian countries, leading to considerable variation in reported data.
  • Incidence Variation: While precise incidence is hard to pinpoint due to data limitations, reported ranges (12.06 to 61.6 per million) show substantial differences within Asia and compared to global figures (lower than North America, comparable to Europe).
  • Age and Gender Trends: TSCI predominantly affects adults, with men being at higher risk than women, though this ratio is shifting in some regions.
  • Dominant Causes: Motor vehicle collisions (MVCs) and falls are the leading causes of TSCI across Asia, with war wounds being a significant factor in specific conflict-affected regions.
  • Severity Patterns: While paraplegia is more common globally, some Asian countries (China, Japan, Thailand) show a higher proportion of tetraplegia, potentially linked to an aging population and degenerative spine conditions. The majority of injuries are classified as complete (AIS/Frankel grade A).

Key Results

  • 39 studies were included in the review, covering 16 Asian regions.
  • Incidence rates varied widely, ranging from 12.06 to 61.6 per million.
  • The average age of TSCI patients ranged from 26.8 to 56.6 years.
  • Men were at higher risk than women, with gender ratios varying from 0.99:1 to 13.5:1.
  • Motor vehicle collisions (MVCs) accounted for 59.5% of injuries, followed by falls (37.8%).
  • In specific regions like Afghanistan, war wounds surpassed MVCs and falls as the primary cause.
  • AIS/Frankel grade A was the most common classification, indicating neurological deficits, with nearly 95% of patients showing deficits.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Retrospective Nature: Most included studies were retrospective, limiting the ability to establish causality and trends.
  • Incomplete Data: Many studies reported only a subset of TSCI patients (e.g., hospital survivors), excluding those who died before reaching care, thus underestimating the true burden.
  • Varied Case Definitions: Inconsistent case criteria and study periods made direct comparisons difficult.
  • Lack of National Registries: The absence of comprehensive national registries in many Asian countries hinders accurate epidemiological assessment.

Future Work Recommendations:

  • Establish National Registries: Implement standardized TSCI registries across Asian countries.
  • International Methodological Uniformity: Promote consistent data collection methods and case definitions.
  • Collaborative Studies: Encourage cross-country collaborations to gather larger, more comparable datasets.
  • Prospective Studies: Conduct prospective research to collect robust, valid comparative data on TSCI in Asia.

Summary updated

Abstract

TSCI is an important public health problem and a major cause of paralysis. We must understand the epidemiology to implement appropriate preventative measures. Asian epidemiology is different from that in other regions, so intervention measures must be established according to population-specific characteristics.
BibTeX
@article{ning2012epidemiology,
  author = {Guangzhi Ning and Qiang Wu and Yulin Li and Shiqing Feng},
  title = {{Epidemiology of traumatic spinal cord injury in Asia: A systematic review}},
  journal = {Journal of Spinal Cord Medicine},
  year = {2012},
  doi = {10.1179/2045772312y.0000000021},
}
Figure