Epidemiology and treatment of 23 musicians with task specific tremor

André Lee, Shinichi Furuya, Eckart AltenmüllerJournal of Clinical Movement Disorders 2014 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates task-specific tremor in musicians (TSTM), a debilitating condition affecting their ability to play. It reveals TSTM is a diverse disorder with a male predominance, sharing traits with primary writing tremor (PWT) but also showing unique characteristics like proximal muscle involvement. While no single treatment is universally effective, Botulinum toxin, Primidone, and Propranolol show promise, and the potential for early deep brain stimulation is raised.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Musicians rely on fine motor control for their livelihood, and conditions that impair this control can be devastating. Task-specific tremor (TST) is a neurological disorder characterized by tremor that occurs only during a specific activity. In musicians, this is known as task-specific tremor in musicians (TSTM). While TST has been studied, particularly primary writing tremor (PWT), research on TSTM has been limited to small sample sizes, primarily focusing on string instrumentalists and primary bowing tremor (PBT). This paper aims to provide a more comprehensive understanding of TSTM by examining its epidemiology, phenomenology, and treatment options in a larger cohort of 23 musicians across various instruments, comparing findings to existing knowledge on PBT and PWT.

Methods

The researchers conducted a study involving 23 professional musicians diagnosed with TSTM. Data was collected through anamnesis (medical history), clinical examination, and mail or telephone surveys. Information gathered included epidemiological details (age, age of onset, duration of tremor), phenomenological aspects (tremor frequency, location, spreading to other tasks), risk factors (previous trauma, family history), and treatment responses. Tremor was objectively quantified using electromyography and accelerometry in most participants. Statistical analyses, including chi-squared tests, were used to assess gender distribution and compare findings to existing literature on PWT and PBT.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on data collected from the 23 participating musicians.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • TSTM is Diverse: Contrary to earlier assumptions, TSTM isn't just a tremor of bowing in string players. This study shows it affects musicians across a range of instruments, including woodwinds, guitar, piano, and percussion.
  • Beyond the Fine Motor: While PWT primarily affects distal hand muscles, TSTM can involve proximal muscles of the upper extremity. This suggests a broader range of motor control disruption.
  • Risk Factors Emerge: Previous trauma and overuse injuries appear to be significant risk factors for developing TSTM, highlighting the importance of injury prevention in musicians.
  • Genetic Link Possible: A positive family history for tremor disorders was observed in a substantial portion of participants, suggesting a potential genetic predisposition.
  • No Magic Bullet Treatment: The study reinforces that there's no single "best" medication for TSTM. Treatment needs to be highly individualized, with Botulinum toxin, Primidone, and Propranolol showing the most consistent positive responses.
  • Early Intervention for DBS? Given the success of deep brain stimulation (DBS) in some PWT cases and a promising case report in an oboist, the authors propose considering DBS earlier in the TSTM treatment pathway, not just as a last resort.

Key Results

  • Demographics: The study included 23 musicians (4 female, 19 male) with a mean age of 51.5 years. Tremor onset occurred around age 44.6, with an average of 35.1 years after starting their instrument.
  • Instrument Distribution: The majority were string instrumentalists (69.6%), followed by woodwind instrumentalists (17.4%).
  • Risk Factors: 39% reported a prior trauma or injury to the affected limb, and 39% had a positive family history for tremor disorders.
  • Phenomenology: Tremor frequency averaged 6.5 Hz. Type B tremor (position-specific) was more common than in PWT. Tremor could spread to other activities in 48% of patients, typically within 1-6 years of onset. Alcohol responsiveness was noted in some, but not to the point of complete remission.
  • Treatment Efficacy: Botulinum toxin showed the highest response rate (80% improvement in 4 out of 5 patients treated). Primidone (75% improvement in 3 out of 4 patients) and Propranolol (60% improvement in 9 out of 15 patients) were also effective. Other medications had limited or no reported benefit.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the distinction between type A and type B tremor can be debatable. They also note that the question of trauma is subject to recall bias. Future research should focus on larger, multi-center studies to further elucidate the epidemiology and phenomenology of TSTM. More controlled trials are needed to definitively establish the efficacy of various treatments, including the potential role of early deep brain stimulation in managing this complex disorder. Further investigation into the genetic underpinnings of TSTM is also warranted.

Summary updated

Abstract

Task specific tremor in musicians is a heterogeneous disorder with a male gender predominance that shares many commonalities with PWT. The onset age as well as the time between starting to play the instrument and tremor onset has a wide range. Because previous trauma and overuse appear to be risk factors, preventive measures against playing related injuries are necessary. There appears to be a genetic predisposition for TST. No single beneficial medication exists and treatment of patients remains highly individual. It should be discussed, whether deep brain stimulation should be offered not only to patients that do not respond to any other medication but early in the course of the disease.
BibTeX
@article{lee2014epidemiology,
  author = {André Lee and Shinichi Furuya and Eckart Altenmüller},
  title = {{Epidemiology and treatment of 23 musicians with task specific tremor}},
  journal = {Journal of Clinical Movement Disorders},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1186/2054-7072-1-5},
}
Figure