Epidemiological features of seasonal influenza transmission among 11 climate zones in Chinese Mainland

Xiaohan Si, Liping Wang, Kerrie Mengersen, Wenbiao HuInfectious 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that seasonal influenza transmission in China exhibits distinct spatial and temporal patterns across 11 Köppen Geiger climate zones. By analyzing influenza case data alongside climate classifications, the research identifies high-risk zones and temporal dynamics, paving the way for more targeted and effective early warning systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Seasonal influenza is a major global health concern, but understanding its transmission patterns has been challenging due to the vast geographical and climatic diversity within large countries like China. Previous studies often focused on administrative regions or broad latitudinal bands, potentially overlooking how specific ecological conditions, as defined by climate zones, influence influenza's spread. This paper aims to bridge this gap by systematically analyzing influenza epidemiology through the lens of the Köppen Geiger climate classification system, a more nuanced approach that considers temperature and precipitation patterns. The goal is to identify distinct epidemiological characteristics within these climate zones and assess their utility for developing a more precise early warning system.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach to analyze seasonal influenza transmission:

  • Climate Zone Classification: They utilized the Köppen Geiger climate classification system, specifically an updated map based on meteorological observations up to 2016, to categorize China into 11 distinct climate zones.
  • Epidemiological Data Analysis: Weekly influenza case data from 2014-2019, collected from the China National Notifiable Infectious Disease Report Information System (NIDRIS), formed the basis of their analysis. This data included clinically diagnosed and laboratory-confirmed cases at the county level.
  • Temporal Analysis:
    • Epidemic Temporal Indices: They calculated Frequency, Duration, and Intensity indices to characterize the temporal patterns of influenza outbreaks within each climate zone.
  • Seasonality Decomposition: This technique was used to separate the seasonal component from the incidence rate time series, allowing for a clearer understanding of recurring patterns.
  • Cross-Correlation Analysis: This was performed to identify lag effects in influenza transmission between different climate zones.
  • Spatial Analysis:
    • Local Indicators of Spatial Association (LISA): This method, specifically using local Moran's I, was applied to identify spatial autocorrelation and pinpoint "hot spots" (high-high clusters) of influenza incidence.
  • Kriging Method: Used to predict and visualize potential high average incidence rate areas and spatial cluster patterns through heat maps.
  • Statistical Analysis: One-way Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) was used to test for significant differences in weekly average cases and incidence rates between climate zones and across different age groups.

Datasets

  • Influenza Case Data: Weekly influenza case numbers (clinically diagnosed and laboratory-confirmed) at the county level from the China National Notifiable Infectious Disease Report Information System (NIDRIS) for the period 2014-2019 (5 surveillance years). Age group-specific data was available for 2015-2019 (4 surveillance years).
  • Population Data: Annual population size data at the county level from 2014-2019, obtained from the China National Bureau of Statistics.
  • Climate Zone Data: Geographical data of the Köppen Geiger climate classification at 1 km resolution, updated by Beck in 2016.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Climate as a Primary Driver: The study strongly suggests that climate zones are a fundamental determinant of seasonal influenza's spatial and temporal behavior in China, offering a more ecologically relevant framework than administrative boundaries.
  • Distinct Temporal Signatures: Different climate zones exhibit unique patterns of influenza peaks, including the timing of primary and secondary winter-spring peaks, and the presence or absence of summer peaks.
  • Age-Specific Vulnerabilities: The 0-14 age group shows distinct patterns, including dual peaks in winter-spring and an earlier peak in winter, highlighting their unique susceptibility.
  • High-Risk Zones Identified: The study pinpoints specific climate zones (Cfa, Cwa, and BSk) as posing a higher risk for seasonal influenza epidemics, providing crucial information for targeted surveillance and intervention.
  • Early Warning Potential: The temporal dynamics observed within climate zones offer a promising avenue for developing more accurate and localized early warning systems by leveraging predictable meteorological conditions.

Key Results

  • Seasonal Peaks: All climate zones experienced winter-spring peaks. Tropical and savannah zones (Aw, Cwa) were unique in also showing summer peaks. The arid, desert, cold zone (BWk) was the first to show a winter-spring peak.
  • Highest Incidence: The temperate, no dry season, hot summer zone (Cfa) had the highest average incidence rate (IR) at 1.047/100,000.
  • Spatial Clustering: Global Moran's I indicated a significant clustered trend in average IR (z=53.69, P < 0.001), with local Moran's I identifying high-high clusters predominantly in Cfa and Cwa.
  • Age Group Differences: Significant differences in IR were observed across age groups (0-14, 15-64, >65) and between climate zones. The 0-14 age group had the highest average IR in Cwa and Cfa.
  • Temporal Indices: The Cfa zone showed the highest average incidence rate and intensity index. The BSk zone had the highest duration index, and Dwb had the highest frequency index. BWk and Cwb zones experienced the most prevalent waves.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Influenza Subtypes: The study acknowledges a limitation in not differentiating between influenza subtypes (e.g., Influenza A vs. B), as some subtypes have distinct epidemic patterns (e.g., dual peaks vs. single peak). Future research could benefit from subtype-specific data.
  • Am Zone Data: The Am zone, with only one county and limited age group data, was excluded from detailed discussion due to its non-representative nature.
  • Socioeconomic Factors: The study did not incorporate spatial variations in social and economic factors (e.g., human migration, population density) which could also influence transmission.
  • Future Work: The authors propose incorporating more detailed socio-environmental factors and developing an integrated early warning system (EWS) that combines big data sources (internet search queries, mobile data, socio-ecological factors, weather changes) to improve predictive accuracy. They aim to develop climate-driven EWS with spatiotemporal models.

Summary updated

Abstract

Seasonal influenza exhibited distinct spatial and temporal patterns in different climate zones. Seasonal influenza primarily emerged in BWk, subsequently in Cfa and Cwa. Cfa, Cwa and BSk pose high risk for seasonal influenza epidemics. The research finds will provide scientific evidence for developing seasonal influenza early warning system based on climate zones.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{si2024epidemiological,
  author = {Xiaohan Si and Liping Wang and Kerrie Mengersen and Wenbiao Hu},
  title = {{Epidemiological features of seasonal influenza transmission among 11 climate zones in Chinese Mainland}},
  booktitle = {Infectious},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1186/s40249-024-01173-9},
}
Figure