Ephemeroptera (Mayflies) Assemblages and Environmental Variation along Three Streams Located in the Dry-Hot Valleys of Baima Snow Mountain, Yunnan, Southwest China

Muhammad Farooq, Xianfu Li, Lu Tan, Davide Fornacca, Yanpeng Li, Nima Cili, Zhen Tian, Lu Yang, Xiaoling Deng, Shuoran Liu, Wen XiaoInsects 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how environmental factors influence mayfly communities in three distinct streams within China's Baima Snow Mountain. It reveals significant differences in mayfly assemblages across these streams, with altitude, conductivity, and water chemistry being key drivers of species composition, highlighting the vulnerability of these sensitive insects to environmental heterogeneity.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Mountain freshwater ecosystems are incredibly biodiverse but also highly sensitive to environmental changes, including those driven by human activities. Mayflies (Ephemeroptera) are particularly valuable indicators of water quality due to their sensitivity to habitat disturbance. However, knowledge about their species richness and diversity in remote mountainous regions, like the Baima Snow Mountain in Southwest China, remains limited. This paper aims to fill this gap by characterizing mayfly communities and understanding how environmental variations, particularly along elevational gradients in a "dry-hot valley" environment, shape these communities. The researchers want to identify which environmental factors are most influential in determining mayfly distribution and diversity in this unique ecosystem.

Methods

The study employed a combination of field sampling and advanced statistical analyses.

  • Field Sampling: Researchers collected biological (mayfly specimens) and environmental data from 35 sites across three tributary streams (Benzilan, Sharong, and Yeri) in the Baima Snow Mountain. Mayfly nymphs were collected using Surber nets, preserved, and identified to genus or morphospecies level. Physicochemical variables (water temperature, conductivity, dissolved oxygen, pH, etc.) were measured in situ and in the lab.
  • Statistical Analyses:
    • Environmental Variation: ANOVA and Kruskal-Wallis tests were used to compare environmental factors between the three streams.
  • Community Composition: Non-metric multidimensional scaling (NMDS) was used to visualize differences in mayfly community composition between streams. PERMANOVA (adonis) and PERMADISP were employed to statistically confirm these differences and assess dispersion.
  • Taxon Contribution: Similarity Percentage analysis (SIMPER) was used to identify which mayfly taxa contributed most to the dissimilarity between streams.
  • Environmental Influence: Redundancy Analysis (RDA) was the primary tool to correlate environmental variables with mayfly community composition, identifying which factors explained the most variation.
  • Diversity Indices: Shannon and Simpson diversity indices were calculated for each site and analyzed in relation to altitude.

Datasets

The study utilized biological data (mayfly specimens) and environmental data collected from 35 sampling sites across three streams in the Baima Snow Mountain. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing methods for mayfly identification and environmental parameter measurement were applied.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Mayflies as Sensitive Indicators: The study reinforces the role of mayflies as sensitive indicators of environmental conditions, showing distinct community shifts even within a relatively small geographic area.
  • Dry-Hot Valley Ecosystems: The research highlights the unique environmental conditions of "dry-hot valleys" and their impact on aquatic invertebrate communities, suggesting these areas may harbor distinct assemblages.
  • Altitude as a Major Driver: Altitude emerged as a critical factor influencing mayfly diversity and distribution, underscoring the importance of elevational gradients in shaping mountain biodiversity.
  • Environmental Heterogeneity is Key: The significant differences in mayfly communities between the three streams are directly linked to the high environmental heterogeneity present, particularly in the Sharong stream.

Key Results

  • Community Differences: The mayfly community composition differed significantly across the three streams (Benzilan, Sharong, and Yeri).
  • Dominant Taxa: Baetis sp. and Baetiella marginata were the most dominant mayfly taxa, accounting for over 50% of the dissimilarity between streams.
  • Stream Quality: The Yeri stream generally provided better habitats, exhibiting the highest species richness and diversity. The Benzilan stream followed, while the Sharong stream showed lower mayfly assemblages, likely due to its higher environmental heterogeneity.
  • Environmental Predictors: RDA analysis revealed that altitude, conductivity, total dissolved solids, water temperature, dissolved silicon, and pH were the most significant environmental factors explaining variation in mayfly species composition. Altitude alone explained 17.74% of this variation.
  • Altitude and Diversity: Diversity indices were negatively impacted by altitude in the Sharong and Benzilan streams, suggesting that as altitude increases, mayfly diversity tends to decrease in these areas.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Taxonomic Resolution: The study acknowledges a lack of detailed taxonomic investigation for mayflies in northwest Yunnan, suggesting that increased taxonomic resolution would make biological and ecological studies more meaningful.
  • Human Impact Assessment: While the study identifies environmental factors, it calls for further research to evaluate the scale of threats to mayfly populations, particularly the impact of human-induced disturbances like land-use changes.
  • Generalist vs. Specialist Species: The Sharong stream's low diversity was attributed to the prevalence of widespread and generalist species, implying that more specialized species may be absent or rare. Future work could focus on understanding the ecological plasticity of different mayfly species.
  • Broader Conservation: The findings emphasize the need for comprehensive conservation strategies for mountain freshwater systems, considering local to watershed scales and the interactions between terrestrial and aquatic environments.

Summary updated

Abstract

Mountain freshwater ecosystems are threatened all over the world by a range of human-induced stresses, ensuing in a rapid loss of habitats and species diversity. Many macroinvertebrates are reactive to habitat disturbance, and mayflies (Ephemeroptera) are amongst the most sensitive groups. Despite they are susceptible to environmental deviation, knowledge concerning their species richness and diversity is still unknown in remote areas. The objectives of this study were to (1) investigate the mayfly species assemblage and community composition along different mountain streams and assess potential differences, and (2) identify the environmental variation and its influence on the structure of mayfly communities within such freshwater systems. We collected biological and environmental data from 35 sites situated along elevation gradients in the Baima Snow Mountain, northwest Yunnan, China. Multivariate analyses were performed on the environmental variables and the mayfly species composition, as well as on richness and diversity indices. We found that the community composition of mayflies was different across all three watercourses. Among the 18 Ephemeroptera taxa identified, <i>Baetis</i> sp. and <i>Baetiella marginata</i> were highly dominant, accounting for over 50% of the dissimilarity of each stream. In terms of species assemblages, almost all sites in the Yeri stream hosted good-quality habitats for several mayfly species, as reflected by the highest species richness. The Benzilan stream followed, whereas the Sharong stream showed relatively low mayfly assemblage. This variation was explained by the high environmental heterogeneity between the three watercourses. In particular, the RDA model revealed that among the different environmental factors analyzed, altitude, conductivity, total dissolved solids, water temperature, dissolved silicon, and pH explained most of the variation in species composition. Moreover, the altitude alone explained 17.74% of the variation, and in-depth analysis confirmed its significant effect on diversity indices. Further research should focus on evaluating the scale of threats to this important group of insects in the mountain freshwater ecosystem, particularly the impact of human-induced disturbances such as land use/landcover alterations.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{farooq2021ephemeroptera,
  author = {Muhammad Farooq and Xianfu Li and Lu Tan and Davide Fornacca and Yanpeng Li and Nima Cili and Zhen Tian and Lu Yang and Xiaoling Deng and Shuoran Liu and Wen Xiao},
  title = {{Ephemeroptera (Mayflies) Assemblages and Environmental Variation along Three Streams Located in the Dry-Hot Valleys of Baima Snow Mountain, Yunnan, Southwest China}},
  booktitle = {Insects},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/insects12090775},
}
Figure