Environmental Regulation, Two-Way Foreign Direct Investment, and Green Innovation Efficiency in China’s Manufacturing Industry

Zhijun Feng, Bo Zeng, Ming QianInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how environmental regulations and foreign direct investment (FDI) influence green innovation efficiency in China's manufacturing sector. It finds that while FDI generally boosts green innovation, the impact of environmental regulations is complex and depends on industry type, often leading to a "crowding-out effect" on innovation investment.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

China's manufacturing sector is a powerhouse, but its rapid growth has come at a significant environmental cost. The country faces a dual challenge: improving its industrial competitiveness while simultaneously addressing severe pollution and resource depletion. Green innovation is seen as a crucial pathway to achieve this, but its adoption is influenced by various factors. This paper aims to untangle the complex interplay between government environmental regulations (ER) and two-way foreign direct investment (FDI) – both inward (IFDI) and outward (OFDI) – on the green innovation efficiency (GIE) of China's manufacturing industries. Understanding these relationships is vital for crafting effective policies that promote sustainable industrial development.

Methods

The researchers employed a two-stage approach. First, they measured the green innovation efficiency (GIE) of China's manufacturing industries using a Super-efficiency Slacks-Based Measure (Super-SBM) model. This advanced data envelopment analysis (DEA) technique is designed to handle multiple inputs and outputs, including undesirable outputs (like pollution), and can rank decision-making units even when they achieve optimal efficiency.

Second, they used a panel data model to analyze the impact of environmental regulation and two-way FDI on GIE. Crucially, they incorporated interaction terms between environmental regulation and both IFDI and OFDI to explore how ER might moderate the effects of FDI. They also accounted for industry heterogeneity by analyzing patent-intensive and non-patent-intensive manufacturing sectors separately.

Datasets

The study utilized panel data from 27 manufacturing industries in China for the period 2009-2015. The data was sourced from various official Chinese statistical yearbooks, including:

  • China Science and Technology Statistical Yearbook
  • China Industrial Economics Statistical Yearbook
  • China Foreign Direct Investment Statistics Bulletin
  • China Statistical Yearbook
  • China Environmental Statistical Yearbook

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Green innovation efficiency in China's manufacturing is generally low, indicating significant room for improvement. This suggests that current policies and industry practices are not fully leveraging the potential for cleaner production.
  • Industry heterogeneity matters significantly. Patent-intensive industries, which are characterized by key technologies and core patents, exhibit much higher green innovation efficiency than non-patent-intensive ones. This highlights the importance of technological capacity in driving green innovation.
  • Environmental regulations can have a "crowding-out effect" on green innovation investment. Instead of investing in innovation to comply with regulations, some firms may prioritize direct pollution control costs or even shift production abroad, thus hindering innovation.
  • Inward FDI (IFDI) generally promotes green innovation, especially in patent-intensive sectors. This is attributed to the transfer of advanced technologies, management practices, and increased competition that drives local firms to improve their green capabilities.
  • Outward FDI (OFDI) also shows a positive impact, suggesting that Chinese firms learn from and bring back advanced green technologies and practices from abroad, contributing to domestic green innovation.
  • The interaction between ER and FDI is crucial. While ER can positively regulate IFDI's impact in non-patent-intensive sectors, it can negatively affect OFDI's contribution, potentially due to pollution transfer motives or tightened domestic liquidity constraints for outward investment.

Key Results

  • The average green innovation efficiency across all 27 manufacturing industries from 2009-2015 was 0.4697.
  • Patent-intensive manufacturing industries had a mean GIE of 0.5852, significantly higher than non-patent-intensive industries with a mean GIE of 0.4018.
  • For the overall manufacturing industry:
  • Environmental Regulation (ER) had a significantly negative impact on GIE.
  • Outward FDI (OFDI) had a significantly positive impact on GIE.
  • The interaction of ER and OFDI (ER × OFDI) had a significantly negative impact on GIE.
  • For patent-intensive manufacturing:
  • ER had a significantly negative impact on GIE.
  • Inward FDI (IFDI) had a significantly positive impact on GIE.
  • The interaction of ER and IFDI (ER × IFDI) had a significantly negative impact on GIE.
  • For non-patent-intensive manufacturing:
  • IFDI had a significantly positive impact on GIE.
  • The interaction of ER and IFDI (ER × IFDI) had a significantly positive impact on GIE.
  • The interaction of ER and OFDI (ER × OFDI) had a significantly negative impact on GIE.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Data limitations: The study is based on a specific dataset for China's manufacturing industry from 2009-2015. Future research could benefit from expanded data, potentially including more recent years or a broader range of industries.
  • Environmental Regulation Measurement: The study used a single indicator for environmental regulation (cost of pollution control facilities). Future work could explore a more nuanced classification of environmental regulations, differentiating between command-and-control measures and market-based instruments, and their varying impacts.

The authors suggest that future research should focus on expanding the dataset and further classifying environmental regulations to provide a more granular understanding of their effects on green innovation.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper adopts 2009 to 2015 panel data from 27 manufacturing industries in China. A Super-SBM model is used to measure the green innovation efficiency (GIE) of China's manufacturing industry. A panel data model is then built to systematically examine the impact of environmental regulation (ER) and two-way foreign direct investment (FDI) on the GIE of China's manufacturing industry under a unified analysis framework. The results are as follows: (1) the overall level of the green innovation efficiency in China's manufacturing is low, and there is still great potential for improvement. Considering industry heterogeneity, the green innovation efficiency of patent-intensive manufacturing is significantly higher than that of non-patent-intensive manufacturing; (2) in terms of the whole manufacturing industry, ER and the interaction between ER and outward foreign direct investment (OFDI) have significantly negative effects on GIE, OFDI has significantly positive effects on GIE. (3) when considering industry heterogeneity, for patent-intensive manufacturing, ER and the interaction between ER and inward foreign direct investment (IFDI) have significantly negative effects on GIE, while IFDI has significantly positive effect on GIE. For non-patent-intensive manufacturing, ER and the interaction between ER and OFDI have significantly negative effects on GIE, while IFDI and the interaction between ER and IFDI have significantly positive effects on GIE.
BibTeX
@article{feng2018environmental,
  author = {Zhijun Feng and Bo Zeng and Ming Qian},
  title = {{Environmental Regulation, Two-Way Foreign Direct Investment, and Green Innovation Efficiency in China’s Manufacturing Industry}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph15102292},
}
Figure