Environmental Regulation Intensity, Foreign Direct Investment, and Green Technology Spillover—An Empirical Study

Jiangfeng Hu, Zhao Wang, Qinghua Huang, Xiaoqin ZhangSustainability 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how different types of Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) interact with environmental regulation intensity to influence green technology spillovers and improve green total factor productivity (GTFP) in China. The findings suggest that while stringent environmental regulations are crucial for fostering green technology spillovers from both labor-based and capital-based FDI, the optimal intensity and impact vary significantly between these FDI types.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The global economy increasingly relies on Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) for growth. However, a persistent concern is whether FDI leads to environmental degradation, particularly in developing countries with potentially lax environmental regulations (the "pollution haven" hypothesis). Conversely, some argue that FDI can bring cleaner technologies and practices (the "pollution halo" hypothesis). While research has explored the links between FDI, environmental regulation, and productivity, a critical gap exists in understanding how different types of FDI (e.g., labor-intensive vs. capital-intensive) respond to varying intensities of environmental regulation in generating green technology spillovers. This paper aims to fill this gap by examining the nuanced threshold effects of environmental regulation on the green technology spillover potential of labor-based FDI and capital-based FDI in China.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted econometric approach to analyze the complex relationships:

  • Static Linear Panel Model: This served as a baseline to assess the direct impact of FDI and environmental regulation on GTFP, including their interaction.
  • Static Panel Threshold Model: This advanced model was used to identify specific "thresholds" of environmental regulation intensity where the effect of FDI on GTFP changes. This is crucial for understanding if there's an optimal level of regulation.
  • Dynamic Panel Threshold Model: To ensure robustness and account for potential endogeneity and lagged effects, a dynamic model was utilized, incorporating a lagged dependent variable (previous period's GTFP).

The measurement of Green Total Factor Productivity (GTFP) was a key methodological component. It was calculated using a directional distance function that accounts for both expected outputs (e.g., industrial sales) and unexpected outputs (e.g., pollution emissions like chemical oxygen demand, ammonia nitrogen, SO2, and smoke/dust). The Global Malmquist-Luenberger (GML) index was used for this calculation.

Datasets

The study utilized panel data from 36 industrial sectors in China spanning from 2003 to 2015. The data was sourced from:

  • China Industrial Economy Statistical Yearbook
  • China Energy Statistical Yearbook
  • China Environment Statistical Yearbook

The authors also performed data processing to ensure consistency, particularly for industry classifications before and after 2012, and employed linear fitting to fill in missing employment data for 2012.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Environmental Regulation as a "Screen": The study strongly suggests that stringent environmental regulations act as a crucial "screening" mechanism, filtering out less environmentally friendly FDI and encouraging those that can contribute to green technology spillovers.
  • Heterogeneity Matters: The impact of FDI on green productivity is not uniform. Labor-based FDI and capital-based FDI respond differently to environmental regulations, highlighting the need for tailored policy approaches.
  • The "Pollution Haven" vs. "Pollution Halo" Nuance: While labor-based FDI might initially seem to contribute to a "pollution haven" effect under low regulation, intensified regulation can mitigate this. Capital-based FDI shows a more direct positive link with GTFP under certain regulatory conditions.
  • Thresholds are Critical: Simply having environmental regulations isn't enough; their intensity is key. The study identifies multiple thresholds where the relationship between FDI and GTFP shifts, indicating that there isn't a single "one-size-fits-all" regulatory level.

Key Results

  • Static Linear Model: In models without interaction terms, both labor-based and capital-based FDI showed a negative impact on GTFP, with labor-based FDI's spillover being statistically significant. However, when interaction terms were included, the relationship became more complex and often positive, especially for capital-based FDI.
  • Static Threshold Model:
    • Labor-based FDI: Showed a double-threshold effect. Under low regulation, its impact was negative. In the medium regulation range, the impact became significantly negative. Only at high regulation intensity did the effect become positive, though not always statistically significant.
  • Capital-based FDI: Also exhibited a double-threshold effect. It positively impacted GTFP at low and high regulation intensities, but negatively in the intermediate range.
  • Dynamic Threshold Model: This robustness check indicated that when environmental regulation intensity surpassed a certain threshold (specifically, exceeding the third threshold of 3.28), both labor-based and capital-based FDI could indeed lead to green technology spillovers. This suggests that continuous strengthening of environmental regulation is necessary.
  • Control Variables: R&D intensity positively impacted GTFP for labor-based FDI. Energy production efficiency consistently showed a significant positive impact across models.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Limitations: The study acknowledges the difficulty in obtaining precise labor time data, using average employee numbers as a proxy for human capital investment. Data inconsistencies and the need for processing for certain industry classifications were also noted.
  • Subjectivity in Median Classification: The paper mentions that previous studies used median-based classification for environmental regulation intensity, which can be subjective. Their use of threshold models aims to overcome this.
  • Future Work: The paper implicitly suggests that further research could explore more granular FDI types, specific industry-level responses, and the long-term dynamic evolution of these relationships. The findings also point towards the need for developing countries to carefully design and implement environmental policies that consider the specific characteristics of incoming FDI to maximize positive spillovers and minimize environmental harm.

Summary updated

Abstract

Many researchers have studied the relationships among heterogeneous foreign direct investment (FDI), environmental regulation, and green total factor productivity. However, no research has been done on how different types of FDI can result in green technology spillover under different levels of environmental regulation intensity. To address this research gap, in this paper, we build a static linear panel model, a static panel threshold model, and a dynamic panel threshold model to investigate the environmental regulatory threshold effect of labor-based FDI and capital-based FDI in terms of their green technology spillover. Based on the measurement of green total factor productivity (GTFP) of 36 industry sectors in China from 2003 to 2015, we first compare the threshold effects of environmental regulation on green technology spillover between labor-based FDI and capital-based FDI with a static linear model and a static threshold model. The results show that environmental regulation is unable to significantly promote the green technology spillover of labor-based FDI. However, intensifying environmental regulation can reduce the negative impact of labor-based FDI on GTFP. The effect of environmental regulation on green technology spillover of capital-based FDI is more complex. In the static linear model, environmental regulation can significantly promote the green technology spillover of capital-based FDI. In the static threshold model, the green technology spillover of capital-based FDI exists only when the environmental regulation intensity is sufficiently low or sufficiently high. Finally, the dynamic threshold model is adopted for robustness check. The results show when the environmental regulation intensity is higher than a threshold, both types of FDI can indeed result in green technology spillover. In short, our results prove that to ensure that FDI results in green technology spillover, it is necessary to continue to strengthen environmental regulation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hu2019environmental,
  author = {Jiangfeng Hu and Zhao Wang and Qinghua Huang and Xiaoqin Zhang},
  title = {{Environmental Regulation Intensity, Foreign Direct Investment, and Green Technology Spillover—An Empirical Study}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/su11102718},
}
Figure