Environmental factors shape methionine metabolism in p16/MTAP deleted cells

Sydney M. Sanderson, Peter G. Mikhael, Ziwei Dai, Jason W. LocasalebioRxiv 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that while the deletion of the MTAP gene in cancer cells creates a distinct metabolic signature, this signature is largely overshadowed by environmental factors like nutrient availability and cell type. This suggests that targeting MTAP-deleted cancers might require a more nuanced approach that considers these external influences.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cancer cells often harbor genetic alterations that affect both tumor suppressors and nearby metabolic genes. A common example is the co-deletion of CDKN2a (which encodes p16, a tumor suppressor) and MTAP, a gene involved in methionine metabolism. This co-deletion presents an interesting opportunity for synthetic lethality – targeting a metabolic vulnerability created by a genetic defect. However, the broader impact of such co-deletions on cellular metabolism, especially considering how it interacts with nutrient availability and the cell's tissue of origin, remains poorly understood. This paper aims to dissect these complex interactions, specifically focusing on MTAP deletion and its influence on methionine metabolism.

Methods

The researchers employed a comparative metabolomics approach using liquid chromatography coupled with high-resolution mass spectrometry (LC-HRMS) to analyze the metabolic profiles of cancer cell lines. They compared cell lines with and without MTAP deletion under various nutrient conditions (methionine, serine, and cysteine restriction). To analyze the vast metabolomic data, they utilized:

  • Unsupervised Hierarchical Clustering: To identify patterns in metabolite levels and group samples based on similarity.
  • Network-Based Pathway Analysis: To understand which metabolic pathways were most affected by MTAP deletion or nutrient changes.
  • Principal Component Analysis (PCA): To reduce the dimensionality of the data and visualize the major sources of variation (e.g., MTAP status, tissue type, cell line).
  • Machine Learning (Support Vector Machine - SVM): To quantitatively assess the predictive power of MTAP status versus nutrient availability in determining metabolic profiles.

Datasets

The study utilized a panel of 10 tissue-matched cancer cell lines, sourced from the American Tissue Culture Collection (ATCC) and other institutions. These cell lines were characterized by either homozygous deletion of p16 and MTAP (MTAP-/-) or no alterations in this locus (MTAP+/+).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • MTAP deletion creates a "signature," but it's fragile: While MTAP deletion does lead to a consistent change in metabolite levels across different cell lines when grown in standard conditions, this signature is highly sensitive to environmental changes.
  • Nutrients are the dominant players: Changes in the availability of methionine, serine, and cysteine had a much larger impact on cellular metabolism than MTAP status alone. This suggests that dietary interventions or nutrient dependencies could be more significant therapeutic targets than the genetic deletion itself.
  • Cell identity matters more than genetics: The inherent differences between individual cell lines (likely reflecting their tissue of origin and other cellular characteristics) contributed more to metabolic variation than MTAP status or even tissue type.
  • MTAP's role in salvage is context-dependent: The accumulation of MTA, a key indicator of MTAP's role in methionine salvage, was abolished under methionine restriction, highlighting how cellular adaptations can overcome genetic defects.
  • Re-expressing MTAP has limited impact: Restoring MTAP expression in deleted cells had only modest effects on metabolism, failing to override the influence of nutrient availability.

Key Results

  • MTAP-deleted cell lines showed significantly higher levels of MTA compared to MTAP-expressing lines in standard culture.
  • PCA revealed that while MTAP status could separate some groups, individual cell line variability accounted for the largest portion of metabolic variance.
  • Under methionine restriction, the distinct MTAP metabolic signature was diminished, and MTA levels were significantly reduced across most cell lines.
  • Responsiveness to changes in methionine, serine, or cysteine availability was largely independent of MTAP status, with cell-to-cell variability being the primary driver of differential responses.
  • Machine learning analysis showed that nutrient availability was a stronger predictor of metabolic state than MTAP status.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their findings are based on a specific set of cell lines and nutrient conditions. Future work could explore a wider range of cell types, nutrient combinations, and longer-term adaptation studies. The study also highlights the need to consider the complex interplay of genetic and environmental factors when developing therapeutic strategies for MTAP-deleted cancers, suggesting that targeting nutrient dependencies or exploiting cell-identity-specific metabolic vulnerabilities might be more fruitful avenues.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The co-deletion of a common tumor suppressor locus and neighboring metabolic gene is an attractive possible synthetic dependency of tumor suppression on metabolism. However, the general impact that these co-deletions have on metabolism, which also dependent on nutrient availability and the tissue of origin, is unknown. As a model to investigate this question, we considered a set of tissue-matched cancer cells with homozygous co-deletions in CDKN2a and MTAP , genes respectively encoding the most commonly deleted tumor suppressor p16 and an enzyme involved in methionine metabolism. A comparative metabolomics analysis revealed that while there exists a definite pan-cancer metabolic signature of MTAP-deletion, this signature was not preserved when cells were subjected to changes in the availability of methionine, serine, or cysteine, nutrients related to methionine metabolism. Notably, the heterogeneity exhibited by these cells in their responsiveness to nutrient availability dominated both MTAP status and tissue-of-origin. Furthermore, re-expression of MTAP exerted a modest effect on metabolism. Together these findings demonstrate that environmental factors, particularly nutrition and tissue identity, may overwhelm the genetic effects of collateral deletions of metabolic genes.
BibTeX
@misc{sanderson2018environmental,
  author = {Sydney M. Sanderson and Peter G. Mikhael and Ziwei Dai and Jason W. Locasale},
  title = {{Environmental factors shape methionine metabolism in p16/MTAP deleted cells}},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1101/313288},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure