Environmental barriers, functioning and quality of life in 2008 Wenchuan earthquake victims with spinal cord injury eight years after the disaster: A cross-sectional study

Mengwei Xu, H Li, Zhao Zhang, Yang Yang, Zhihong Sun, Han Han, Xian Zhang, Jan D. ReinhardtJournal of Rehabilitation Medicine 2018 · DOI

Abstract

Wenchuan earthquake survivors with spinal cord injury (SCI) faced a considerable number of environmental barriers and showed decreased functioning and quality of life. Environmental barriers were strongly related to functioning and quality of life.

Introduction

Eight years after the devastating 2008 Wenchuan earthquake, survivors with spinal cord injuries (SCI) continue to face a staggering number of environmental barriers that severely diminish their physical functioning and quality of life. This study reveals that the "built environment"—from inaccessible public transport to financial instability—is a primary driver of long-term disability, suggesting that post-disaster recovery must prioritize accessible infrastructure as much as medical rehabilitation.

Methods

The researchers conducted a cross-sectional study eight years after the earthquake, visiting 32 adult survivors in their homes or residential centers across Sichuan Province. They used three primary validated instruments:

  • NEFI-SF (Nottwil Environmental Factors Inventory Short Form): A 14-item tool used to quantify perceived barriers (e.g., climate, transport, finances, social attitudes).
  • SF-36 (36-item Short-Form Health Survey): A standard metric for assessing physical and mental functioning.
  • WHOQOL-BREF: The World Health Organization’s brief quality of life assessment.

Survivors' scores were compared against normative data from a rural Sichuan reference population (for SF-36) and a massive mainland China general population sample (for WHOQOL-BREF).

Key Results

Staggering Environmental Barriers

Survivors perceived a mean of 8.9 barriers. Over 70% of participants reported that lack of long-distance transport and financial situations made their lives "a lot harder."

Perceived environmental barriers among SCI survivors

Significant Deficits in Functioning and Quality of Life

Survivors scored significantly lower across all domains of the SF-36 and WHOQOL-BREF compared to general population norms (p < 0.01 for most domains). The number of perceived barriers was strongly associated with decreased scores in mental health (Rho = -0.67) and role emotional functioning (Rho = -0.66).

Comparison of functioning and QoL scores against population norms

Discussion and Insights

  • The Environment as a Universal Bottleneck: Perception of these barriers did not vary significantly by age, gender, or lesion severity, suggesting the environment is a "universal" limiting factor for all SCI survivors in the region.
  • Mental Health vs. Physical Barriers: The strongest negative correlations were found between environmental barriers and mental health and social functioning. This implies that physical barriers lead directly to social isolation and psychological distress.
  • Failure of "Building Back Better": Despite international disaster recovery goals, the high number of reported physical barriers eight years later suggests that long-term accessibility was not sufficiently prioritized during the reconstruction of the Wenchuan region.

Conclusion

Policy-makers should look at removing specific environmental hurdles—like improving the accessibility of public transportation and providing better financial support—to improve the long-term outcomes for disaster survivors with disabilities. Rather than just focusing on clinical rehabilitation, community-based interventions are essential for long-term recovery.

Summary updated

Abstract

Wenchuan earthquake survivors with SCI faced a considerable number of environmental barriers and showed decreased functioning and quality of life. Environmental barriers were strongly related to functioning and quality of life.
BibTeX
@article{xu2018environmental,
  author = {Mengwei Xu and H Li and Zhao Zhang and Yang Yang and Zhihong Sun and Han Han and Xian Zhang and Jan D. Reinhardt},
  title = {{Environmental barriers, functioning and quality of life in 2008 Wenchuan earthquake victims with spinal cord injury eight years after the disaster: A cross-sectional study}},
  journal = {Journal of Rehabilitation Medicine},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.2340/16501977-2380},
}
Figure