Environmental and financial performance of mechanical recycling of carbon fibre reinforced polymers and comparison with conventional disposal routes

Xiang Li, Ruibin Bai, Jon McKechnieJournal of Cleaner Production 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the environmental and financial viability of mechanically recycling carbon fiber-reinforced polymer (CFRP) waste, comparing it to landfilling and incineration. While mechanical recycling shows promise for reducing greenhouse gas emissions, its high cost, driven by dismantling and low recyclate value, makes it financially unfeasible under current market conditions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Carbon fiber-reinforced polymers (CFRPs) are increasingly used in lightweight applications like aerospace and automotive industries due to their high strength-to-weight ratio. However, the production of virgin carbon fiber (vCF) is energy-intensive and costly. As CFRP usage grows, so does the volume of waste from manufacturing and end-of-life products. Effectively managing this waste is crucial for environmental sustainability and resource conservation. Current disposal methods like landfilling and incineration have their own drawbacks, and there's a need to understand the economic and environmental trade-offs of alternative recycling technologies, particularly mechanical recycling, which is a mature technology but faces challenges with CFRPs.

Methods

The study employs a Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) and Life Cycle Costing (LCC) approach to evaluate three CFRP waste treatment routes: landfilling, incineration with energy recovery, and mechanical recycling. The functional unit for the analysis is one tonne of CFRP waste.

  • LCA: Quantifies environmental impacts, focusing on Global Warming Potential (GWP), primary energy use, and landfill waste generation.
  • LCC: Calculates the total cost of each waste treatment route, including pre-treatment, transport, and disposal/recycling fees, as well as potential revenues from recyclates.
  • System Boundary: The "gate-to-grave" approach is used for landfilling and incineration, starting from waste collection and ending with final disposal. For recycling, a "gate-to-gate" approach is used, focusing on the recycling process itself and the use of recyclates. The initial production and use phases of CFRP are excluded.
  • Scenarios: The study considers different scenarios for the use of recycled carbon fibers (rCF), including displacing virgin glass fiber (vGF) and virgin carbon fiber (vCF).

Datasets

Not explicitly detailed as distinct datasets, but the study relies on:

  • Publicly available data: Used for costs, energy requirements, and material properties related to dismantling, shredding, transportation, and recycling processes.
  • LCA databases: Such as Ecoinvent, are used to supplement process-specific data for a comprehensive life cycle assessment.
  • Literature data: From previous studies on CFRP recycling, waste management policies, and market values of materials.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Incineration's GHG Paradox: While incineration with energy recovery reduces primary energy consumption, it surprisingly results in the highest net greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions among the evaluated options. This is because the carbon released from the composite during combustion outweighs the CO2 savings from displacing grid electricity and heat.
  • Mechanical Recycling's Environmental Win (with caveats): Mechanical recycling, especially when residual materials are landfilled, offers the lowest GWP, significantly reducing emissions by displacing virgin glass fiber production. However, this environmental benefit comes at a steep financial cost.
  • Landfill Tax as a Driver: The UK's landfill tax effectively shifts waste away from landfilling towards incineration, but this has mixed environmental consequences due to incineration's high GHG emissions.
  • Dismantling is the Cost Bottleneck: The high cost of manually dismantling CFRP components from end-of-life vehicles accounts for a substantial portion (approximately half) of the total mechanical recycling cost, making it a major barrier to financial viability.
  • Low Recyclate Value: The current market value of recycled carbon fibers (rCF), particularly when used to displace lower-cost materials like glass fiber, is insufficient to offset the high costs of mechanical recycling.

Key Results

  • GWP:
    • Landfilling: 24 kg CO2eq./t CFRP
    • Incineration: 2,011 kg CO2eq./t CFRP (highest)
    • Mechanical Recycling + Landfilling: -378 kg CO2eq./t CFRP (lowest, significant reduction)
    • Mechanical Recycling + Incineration: 750 kg CO2eq./t CFRP
  • Primary Energy Demand:
    • Incineration provides the greatest reduction in primary energy consumption (-22,880 MJ/t CFRP).
  • Mechanical recycling with landfilling of coarse fraction reduces primary energy by 6,740 MJ/t CFRP.
  • Cost:
    • Landfilling (without tax): £60/t CFRP
    • Landfilling (with tax): £132/t CFRP
    • Incineration: £115/t CFRP
    • Mechanical Recycling (displacing GF): Exceeds £2,500/t CFRP (significantly higher)
  • Recyclate Yield: Mechanical recycling yields approximately 24% fine fiber (rCF), 19% fine powder, and 57% coarse fraction.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Hypothetical Facilities: The study models hypothetical CFRP treatment routes, as dedicated facilities for mechanical recycling of CFRP do not widely exist in the UK. This introduces uncertainty in transport distances and operational costs.
  • Market Uncertainty: The markets for CFRP recyclates are highly uncertain. The study uses estimated market values based on displacement of existing materials, which may not reflect real-world scenarios.
  • Degradation of rCF Properties: Mechanical recycling leads to shorter fibers with degraded mechanical properties, limiting their use to lower-value applications. This is a significant barrier to achieving higher revenues.
  • Future Work Suggestions:
    • Improving Fiber Recovery: Advanced thermal recycling technologies (pyrolysis, fluidised bed) that can achieve near-100% fiber recovery and better maintain mechanical properties are crucial.
  • Higher Value Applications: Identifying and developing markets for rCF that can displace higher-value materials (like vCF) is essential for financial viability.
  • Design for Disassembly: Implementing design-for-disassembly principles in automotive components could significantly reduce the costly dismantling process.
  • Comprehensive Assessment of Advanced Processes: Further investigation into the life cycle costs and environmental impacts of advanced recycling technologies is needed to understand their trade-offs and net benefits.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{li2016environmental,
  author = {Xiang Li and Ruibin Bai and Jon McKechnie},
  title = {{Environmental and financial performance of mechanical recycling of carbon fibre reinforced polymers and comparison with conventional disposal routes}},
  journal = {Journal of Cleaner Production},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1016/j.jclepro.2016.03.139},
}
Figure