Environment-Assisted Quantum Transport in Ordered Systems

Ivan Kassal, Alán Aspuru‐Guzik2016

TL;DR

This paper investigates how environmental noise can surprisingly enhance quantum transport in ordered systems, a phenomenon known as Environment-Assisted Quantum Transport (ENAQT). The authors demonstrate that while noise can suppress coherent transport in disordered systems by breaking localization, in ordered systems, it can optimize transport efficiency by fine-tuning the system's dynamics, particularly when considering loss and trapping mechanisms.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Photosynthetic light-harvesting complexes exhibit remarkably high efficiency in transferring energy, even in their noisy biological environments. This has led to the concept of Environment-Assisted Quantum Transport (ENAQT), where noise, rather than being detrimental, can actively improve quantum transport. While ENAQT has been understood in disordered systems as a way to overcome coherent localization, its existence and mechanisms in ordered systems, which lack inherent disorder, were less clear and even predicted to be impossible in certain configurations. This paper addresses this gap by exploring how ENAQT can manifest in ordered systems, specifically in linear chains and circles, and by identifying the conditions under which it occurs and its underlying mechanisms.

Methods

The authors model the ordered system as a one-dimensional array of N identical sites, coupled to their nearest neighbors, described by a tight-binding Hamiltonian. To study transport efficiency, they introduce two attenuation mechanisms: irreversible loss from each site at a rate $\mu$, and trapping at a specific site at a rate $\kappa$. These are incorporated by adding a non-Hermitian part to the Hamiltonian. The efficiency ($\eta$) is defined as the overall probability of the particle being productively trapped.

Environmental effects are modeled using pure dephasing, acting independently on all sites with an equal rate $\gamma$. This is a simplified but relevant form of noise. The authors employ a master equation approach to describe the time evolution of the system's density matrix, incorporating both the Hamiltonian dynamics and the dephasing process. They derive analytical solutions for the efficiency in finite chains and circles, allowing them to systematically study the dependence of efficiency and ENAQT on the dephasing rate ($\gamma$), trapping rate ($\kappa$), and loss rate ($\mu$). For infinite chains, they use numerical simulations.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on theoretical modeling and analytical solutions, with numerical simulations used to explore specific cases.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • ENAQT in Ordered Systems is Not an Oxymoron: Contrary to prior predictions, ENAQT is shown to be possible and even significant in ordered systems, not just disordered ones.
  • Beyond Breaking Localization: In ordered systems, ENAQT doesn't rely on breaking localization. Instead, it arises from the interplay between coherent dynamics, dephasing, and attenuation (loss/trapping) that can optimize the probability of reaching the trap.
  • The "Goldilocks" Zone for ENAQT: ENAQT is most pronounced in a "sweet spot" where neither loss nor trapping is overwhelmingly dominant. Dephasing can then tip the balance in favor of trapping.
  • End-to-End Transport is the Exception: The paper rigorously proves that ENAQT is impossible only in the specific case of end-to-end transport in a linear chain, where the initial and trap sites are at opposite ends. This is attributed to the symmetry of coherent evolution that can lead to perfect recurrences.
  • Symmetry Plays a Crucial Role: In symmetric configurations (like a trap in the middle of a chain with an odd number of sites), ENAQT can be particularly high. Dephasing helps overcome the limitations imposed by coherent dynamics in these symmetric setups.
  • Infinite Chains Exhibit ENAQT via Diffusion Control: In infinite chains, ENAQT arises from dephasing slowing down ballistic transport. This prevents particles from escaping too far (where they'd be lost) while still allowing them to diffuse into the trapping region.

Key Results

  • Finite Chains: For a three-site chain, the transport efficiency ($\eta$) is maximized at an optimal dephasing rate ($\gamma_{opt}$). ENAQT ($\xi$) is defined as the difference between this maximum efficiency and the efficiency without dephasing ($\eta_0$). The paper provides analytical expressions for $\eta$ and characterizes the regions of $\kappa$ and $\mu$ where ENAQT is significant.
  • Circles: Similar to chains, ENAQT is possible on a circle, with the exception of end-to-end transport. High ENAQT is observed in symmetric configurations.
  • Infinite Chains: Numerical simulations on infinite chains show that ENAQT is possible and can reach values up to $\approx 0.1233$ for specific parameters. ENAQT tends to zero as loss or trapping rates become too high or too low.
  • End-to-End Limitation: The paper analytically demonstrates that for end-to-end transport in a linear chain, ENAQT is zero. This is a key finding that explains a previously observed anomaly.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Pure Dephasing: The study primarily uses pure dephasing as the noise model. The authors acknowledge that real-world systems might experience more complex noise, and exploring the influence of different noise types on ENAQT is an open question.
  • Unified Picture: The authors leave open the question of whether the various mechanisms of ENAQT (including those in disordered systems) can be understood within a unified theoretical framework.
  • Analytical Solutions for Complex Systems: While analytical solutions are provided for finite chains and circles, the exact analytical solution for infinite chains remains elusive, relying on numerical simulations.
  • Generalization to Higher Dimensions: The current work focuses on one-dimensional systems. Extending these findings to higher-dimensional ordered systems would be a natural next step.

Summary updated

Abstract

(Article begins on next page) The Harvard community has made this article openly available. Please share how this access benefits you. Your story matters.
BibTeX
@misc{kassal2016environment,
  author = {Ivan Kassal and Alán Aspuru‐Guzik and Ivan Kassal},
  title = {{Environment-Assisted Quantum Transport in Ordered Systems}},
  year = {2016},
}
Figure