Entropy Transportation Equation Based Loss Mechanism Analysis with High Fidelity Turbulence Simulation Results

Hui Li, Xinrong Su, Xin YuanProceedings 2019 · DOI

Abstract

The entropy analysis method based on the second law of thermodynamics has been widely used to evaluate the sources of irreversibility in components and systems, but this method is limited to global analysis. The local entropy production method can accurately calculate the sources of energy loss and its location, which is beneficial to improve the performance and efficiency of apparatus. According to the time-averaging the transport equation for entropy, the intrinsic relationship between irreversible energy loss and entropy production is found, and the mechanisms of entropy production contain four terms, which are dissipation in a mean and fluctuating velocity field and heat flux in a mean and fluctuating temperature field respectively. Since the real flow is unsteady turbulent flow, the contribution of unsteady fluctuating terms in entropy production cannot be ignored, and the amount of the unsteady fluctuating terms is also the key to improve the performance of components. Combined with the hybrid RANS/LES simulation method, a linear shroudless rotor with flat tip is analysed by local entropy production. For high fidelity turbulence simulation results, the four different mechanisms of entropy production are obtained. It is found that fluctuating dissipation is accounts about 30% of the total local entropy generation where the tip leakage flow occurs. Due to the existence of tip leakage vortex, passage vortex and the interaction of such complex vortices, the local turbulence intensity is enhanced. The local entropy production method can effectively analyse the loss mechanism and its distribution of turbulent flow, especially the contribution of unsteady fluctuating in entropy production.

Introduction

In the design of high-performance turbines and compressors, engineers traditionally rely on global metrics like total pressure loss or enthalpy loss coefficients. While these "black-box" values are useful for overall efficiency ratings, they fail to provide spatial information regarding where energy is being lost or physical insight into why it occurs.

To bridge this gap, researchers are increasingly turning to the second law of thermodynamics, specifically local entropy production. Entropy is a direct measure of irreversibility and energy loss. However, standard models often simplify flows as steady-state, ignoring the complex, fluctuating nature of real-world turbomachinery. This paper presents a high-fidelity approach that decomposes the entropy transport equation to account for both mean and fluctuating components, specifically targeting the complex tip leakage flows in shroudless rotors.

Methodology and Simulation Setup

The researchers derived a time-averaged entropy transport equation for incompressible fluids, breaking down entropy production into four distinct mechanisms: dissipation in the mean velocity field, dissipation in the fluctuating (turbulent) velocity field, and heat flux in both mean and fluctuating temperature fields.

To capture these critical fluctuations, the study utilizes Delayed Detached Eddy Simulation (DDES). This hybrid method applies Reynolds-Averaged Navier-Stokes (RANS) near walls for efficiency while switching to Large Eddy Simulation (LES) in separated flow regions to resolve unsteady vortical structures. The simulation was performed on a linear shroudless rotor cascade with a 1% tip gap, utilizing a high-resolution mesh of approximately 9.11 million points, including 53 layers within the tip clearance to resolve the viscous sublayer.

Visualization of the complex vortical structures including the separation vortex, tip leakage vortex (TLV), and passage secondary vortex (PSV).

Key Insights: The Role of Turbulence in Energy Loss

The high-fidelity mapping revealed that losses are not uniformly distributed but are concentrated in regions of intense vortex interaction. A major finding is that fluctuating dissipation—the energy lost to turbulent eddies—accounts for roughly 30% of the total local entropy generation in the tip leakage region. Traditional steady-state analyses that ignore these fluctuations significantly underestimate real-world losses.

Spatial mapping identified that the Tip Leakage Vortex (TLV) begins forming at 25% of the axial chord. The highest entropy production occurs not at the core of these vortices, but where the TLV interacts with the Passage Secondary Vortex (PSV) and the casing wall. In these interaction zones, high local deformation and turbulence intensity drive the irreversibility.

Contour plot of local entropy production (S_phi) showing high loss concentrations near the suction side (SS) and tip region.

Conclusion

The local entropy production method, combined with high-fidelity DDES, provides a powerful tool for pinpointing loss mechanisms in turbulent flows. By identifying the significant contribution of unsteady fluctuations, this approach offers a more accurate roadmap for aerodynamic optimization than global loss coefficients.

Future work will address the current study's limitation of a stationary endwall by incorporating relative motion, which more closely mimics real turbine operating conditions. Additionally, the heat flux terms of the entropy equation, though derived here, warrant further investigation in non-adiabatic cases such as cooled turbine blades.

Summary updated

Abstract

The entropy analysis method based on the second law of thermodynamics has been widely used to evaluate the sources of irreversibility in components and systems, but this method is limited to global analysis. The local entropy production method can accurately calculate the sources of energy loss and its location, which is beneficial to improve the performance and efficiency of apparatus. According to the time-averaging the transport equation for entropy, the intrinsic relationship between irreversible energy loss and entropy production is found, and the mechanisms of entropy production contain four terms, which are dissipation in a mean and fluctuating velocity field and heat flux in a mean and fluctuating temperature field respectively. Since the real flow is unsteady turbulent flow, the contribution of unsteady fluctuating terms in entropy production cannot be ignored, and the amount of the unsteady fluctuating terms is also the key to improve the performance of components. Combined with the hybrid RANS/LES sim`ulation method, a linear shroudless rotor with flat tip is analysed by local entropy production. For high fidelity turbulence simulation results, the four different mechanisms of entropy production are obtained. It is found that fluctuating dissipation is accounts about 30% of the total local entropy generation where the tip leakage flow occurs. Due to the existence of tip leakage vortex, passage vortex and the interaction of such complex vortices, the local turbulence intensity is enhanced. The local entropy production method can effectively analyse the loss mechanism and its distribution of turbulent flow, especially the contribution of unsteady fluctuating in entropy production.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2019entropy,
  author = {Hui Li and Xinrong Su and Xin Yuan},
  title = {{Entropy Transportation Equation Based Loss Mechanism Analysis with High Fidelity Turbulence Simulation Results}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.33737/gpps19-bj-032},
}
Figure