Entrepreneurship and Export Product Quality Improvement

Lei Liu, Kai He, Yi Qiao, Peilin Fu, Qinggang MengSustainability 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how entrepreneurship influences the quality of export products in China. It finds that entrepreneurial spirit significantly boosts export quality, primarily by enhancing firms' total factor productivity. However, this effect varies across different types of enterprises, with privately-owned and independent entities benefiting the most.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

China's economic growth has historically been characterized by high investment and output, but often at the expense of quality and sustainability. As the global economic landscape shifts, there's a growing emphasis on "high-quality development," where the quality of exports is a crucial indicator. While entrepreneurship is recognized as a driver of economic growth, its specific impact on the quality of export products, rather than just quantity, remains less understood. This paper aims to fill this gap by empirically examining how entrepreneurial innovation and venture spirit affect export product quality in China, and to uncover the underlying mechanisms and conditions that influence this relationship.

Methods

The researchers employed a panel data econometric model to analyze the relationship between entrepreneurship and export product quality. They matched macro-level provincial data on entrepreneurship with micro-level enterprise data on export quality. To measure export product quality, they utilized a demand information backpropagation method, which considers both quality and quantity of products, and then standardized these measures. Entrepreneurship was measured at the provincial level using indicators for both innovation spirit (e.g., granted patents per capita) and venture spirit (e.g., per capita number of private and self-employed enterprises).

To address potential endogeneity issues, the study used the System Generalized Method of Moments (GMM) approach. They also conducted robustness tests using alternative measurement methods and high-dimensional fixed effects to control for industry-specific policies and heterogeneity. Finally, they employed mediation and moderation analyses to explore the mechanisms through which entrepreneurship impacts export quality and how market regulations influence this relationship.

Datasets

The study utilized two primary datasets:

  • China Industrial Enterprise Database: This database provided micro-level information on basic and financial aspects of state-owned and non-state-owned industrial enterprises above a certain scale in China.
  • China Customs Import and Export Trade Database: This dataset contained monthly transaction data for Chinese import and export enterprises, including HS 8-digit codes, quantities, amounts, and destination country information.

The data spanned the period from 2000 to 2013. Provincial-level data for market regulation indicators were also incorporated.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Entrepreneurship as a Quality Driver: The core finding is that entrepreneurship is not just about creating more businesses or jobs, but it directly contributes to improving the quality of goods that Chinese firms export.
  • Total Factor Productivity as the Key Mechanism: The study highlights that entrepreneurship doesn't directly translate to higher export quality in a vacuum. Instead, it acts through enhancing a firm's overall efficiency and productivity (Total Factor Productivity - TFP). This suggests that entrepreneurial firms become more efficient, allowing them to invest in and produce higher-quality products.
  • Heterogeneity Matters: The impact of entrepreneurship on export quality is not uniform across all types of firms. State-owned and collective enterprises showed little to no significant improvement, likely due to their stable market positions and less pressure to innovate for survival. In contrast, privately-owned, independent legal entities, and foreign-funded enterprises saw substantial gains, indicating that competitive pressures drive entrepreneurial efforts towards quality improvement.
  • The Importance of the Business Environment: The study emphasizes that entrepreneurship thrives and its positive effects are amplified in a supportive environment. Improvements in the rule of law, reduced government intervention, and well-developed factor and product markets all play a crucial role in fostering entrepreneurship and, consequently, enhancing export quality.

Key Results

  • Entrepreneurial innovation spirit and entrepreneurial venture spirit both significantly and positively promote the improvement of export product quality.
  • Total Factor Productivity (TFP) acts as a significant mediating mechanism, explaining 30.23% of the effect of entrepreneurial innovation and 38.70% of the effect of entrepreneurial venture on export product quality.
  • Entrepreneurship has a significant positive impact on export product quality for privately-owned, independent legal entities, Hong Kong-Macao-Taiwan, and foreign-funded enterprises. The effect is particularly strong for privately-owned and independent legal entity enterprises.
  • State-owned and collective enterprises did not show a significant positive impact of entrepreneurship on their export product quality.
  • Improvements in the rule of law, government control (streamlining administration), non-public economy development, elemental market development, and product market development all positively moderate the relationship between entrepreneurship and export product quality.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Data Granularity: They were unable to obtain entrepreneurial spirit data at the enterprise level, relying instead on provincial-level data. This limits the precision of the analysis.
  • Data Vintage: The study's data only extends to 2013, preventing the analysis of more recent trends and policy impacts.

For future research, the authors suggest:

  • Measuring entrepreneurial spirit and export product quality at the enterprise level for more granular insights.
  • Updating the data to include more recent years.
  • Employing alternative methodologies like difference-in-differences to analyze specific policy interventions related to entrepreneurship.
  • Utilizing wavelet models and machine learning techniques for more advanced data analysis.

Summary updated

Abstract

Entrepreneurship is the sustainable driving force and stable source of economic development, and it is an important guarantee for the continuous improvement of export product quality and high-quality economic development. This paper selects entrepreneurship and export product quality as research objects. It measures the export product quality at the enterprise level using data from the China Industrial Enterprise Database and the China Customs Import and Export Trade Database. Furthermore, based on matching entrepreneurship at the macro-level and the export product quality at the micro-level, the impact and mechanism of entrepreneurship on the export product quality are empirically examined. It was found that entrepreneurial innovation and entrepreneurship further significantly contribute to the improvement of export product quality by promoting the total factor productivity of enterprises. Entrepreneurial innovation and entrepreneurship do not significantly contribute to the export product quality of state-owned and collective enterprises, while they significantly contribute to privately-owned, independent legal entities, Hong Kong–Macao–Taiwan, and foreign-funded enterprises. Furthermore, the promoting effect on privately-owned and independent enterprises is greater than that on Hong Kong–Macao–Taiwan and foreign-funded enterprises. Further analysis shows that improving the rule of law, reducing excessive government intervention, and improving the market mechanism for products and production factors, as well as vigorously developing the non-state-owned economy, will all be conducive to the cultivation and development of entrepreneurs and better promotion of the improvement of export product quality.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2023entrepreneurship,
  author = {Lei Liu and Kai He and Yi Qiao and Peilin Fu and Qinggang Meng},
  title = {{Entrepreneurship and Export Product Quality Improvement}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/su151612315},
}
Figure