Enterococcus lactis is ecologically and genetically distinct from the major opportunistic pathogen Enterococcus faecium

Terry Ross, Jessin Janice, Sergio Arredondo-Alonso, Iren H. Löhr, Einar Holsbø, Jukka Corander, Anna K. Pöntinen, Michael Kampffmeyer, Kristin HegstadMicrobial 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that Enterococcus lactis, a close relative of the opportunistic pathogen Enterococcus faecium, is an older, more genetically diverse species with a distinct ecological niche. By analyzing a large dataset of whole-genome sequences, researchers found that E. lactis exhibits lower recombination rates and higher allelic variation in its core genome, suggesting a longer period of occupying its ecological niche.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Enterococcus faecium is a well-known opportunistic pathogen responsible for various infections, particularly in healthcare settings, due to its antimicrobial resistance and ability to adapt to harsh environments. Its close relative, Enterococcus lactis, is less understood, especially regarding its genetic relationship and ecological distinctiveness. Previous studies have often focused on the clinically relevant E. faecium clades, leaving E. lactis relatively undersampled and its evolutionary history and ecological niche poorly characterized. This paper aims to bridge this knowledge gap by performing a comprehensive genomic comparison of a large number of E. lactis and E. faecium isolates to understand their evolutionary divergence, genetic makeup, and ecological roles.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted genomic analysis approach. They utilized whole-genome sequencing (WGS) of both short-read and long-read technologies to assemble high-quality genomes. Key analytical methods included:

  • Pangenome Estimation: Using Panaroo, they analyzed the entire gene repertoire of the species, identifying core genes (present in most isolates) and accessory genes (variable across isolates).
  • Allelic Diversity and Recombination Analysis: They computed Diversity Indices (DI) for core genes to quantify allelic variation and Consistency Indices (CI) to infer rates of homologous recombination. Lower CI values suggest higher recombination.
  • Phylogenetic Analysis: Maximum likelihood phylogenies were constructed using RAxML-NG and FastTree to visualize evolutionary relationships. Bayesian population clustering (fastbaps) was used to define population structures.
  • Horizontal Gene Transfer (HGT) Inference: Panstripe was used to estimate gene gain and loss events, particularly in the accessory genome, and to assess HGT rates.
  • Plasmidome Analysis: mlplasmids and PlasmidFinder were used to identify and characterize plasmids, investigating their potential role in gene exchange between species.
  • Resistance and Virulence Factor Screening: AMRFinderPlus and custom databases were used to identify antimicrobial resistance (AMR) and virulence genes.

Datasets

The study utilized a substantial dataset comprising 3,007 whole-genome sequences of E. faecium and E. lactis. This included:

  • 1,286 novel Norwegian isolates: Sourced from clinical, commensal (human gut), and marine environments.
  • Publicly available whole-genome sequences: From various sources, including previous studies by Arredondo-Alonso et al., Rios et al., and Lebreton et al., as well as sequences from the National Center for Biotechnology Information (NCBI).

This combined dataset represents one of the largest collections of E. lactis genomes analyzed to date, providing a more balanced representation compared to previous studies.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • E. lactis as an "Older" Species: The higher allelic diversity and lower recombination rates in the core genome of E. lactis suggest it has occupied its ecological niche for a longer period than E. faecium. This implies a more stable evolutionary history.
  • Distinct Ecological Niches: E. faecium shows a broader range of host species, with specific clades adapted to domesticated and pet animals, while E. lactis is less common in these niches. This points to divergent ecological specializations.
  • Plasmid-Mediated Gene Exchange: The presence of the repUS15 megaplasmid in both species, and its detection on large contigs, suggests a significant mechanism for horizontal gene transfer and potential sharing of genetic material, including resistance and virulence genes, across the species boundary.
  • Divergent Metabolic Pathways: Differences in core and soft-core genes, particularly those involved in carbohydrate and amino acid metabolism, highlight distinct metabolic capabilities that may have driven the evolutionary divergence of the two species.

Key Results

  • Phylogenetic and ANI Separation: Both phylogenetic analysis and Average Nucleotide Identity (ANI) confirmed a clear separation between E. lactis and E. faecium, with inter-species ANI values significantly below the 95% speciation threshold.
  • Intra-species Diversity: E. lactis exhibited higher intra-species ANI variation between its two main clades (B1 and non-B1) compared to the intra-species variation within E. faecium clades (A1 and non-A1).
  • Isolation Source Specificity: E. faecium clade A1 showed high isolation source specificity (primarily hospitalized individuals), while non-A1 E. faecium and E. lactis populations displayed more diverse isolation sources.
  • Core Genome Differences: E. lactis possesses more allelic diversity in its core genome and significantly lower recombination rates than E. faecium.
  • Accessory Genome HGT: E. faecium, particularly clade A1, demonstrated higher rates of accessory gene HGT compared to E. lactis, suggesting a greater reliance on mobile genetic elements for adaptation.
  • AMR and Virulence Factors: E. faecium generally harbored more acquired AMR and virulence factors than E. lactis. However, E. lactis had one more intrinsic resistance factor.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Temporal and Geographic Bias: The study acknowledges that the E. lactis sample population, while large, was primarily sourced from a specific Norwegian population and time frame (Tromsø7 study, 2015-2016). A more globally dispersed E. lactis population would likely exhibit even higher core genome diversity.
  • Time-Calibrated Phylogeny Challenges: High rates of homologous recombination in both species made time-calibrated phylogenetic analyses and robust dating of speciation events challenging.
  • Plasmid Transfer Mechanisms: While evidence of plasmid mobilization across species was found, further study is needed to fully understand the genomic content being transferred and reconcile findings with previous research on plasmid specificity.
  • Probiotic Potential: The study suggests that E. lactis's lower prevalence of acquired AMR and virulence factors could make it a safer candidate for probiotic applications, warranting further investigation.
  • Understanding Host Adaptation: The observed differences in HGT rates and host adaptation trends between E. faecium clades and E. lactis suggest avenues for future research into the evolutionary drivers of these bacterial populations.

Summary updated

Abstract

<i>Enterococcus faecium</i> is a major human opportunistic bacterial pathogen and a close relative of the recently established species <i>Enterococcus lactis</i>. As a species, commensal <i>E. lactis</i> remains relatively understudied, and its genetic connectivity with <i>E. faecium</i> is not thoroughly understood. Here, we introduce a large collection of whole-genome sequenced isolates comprising 894 <i>E. faecium</i> and 392 <i>E. lactis</i> genomes. Using these genomes to complement publicly available data, we studied the genome content and the evolutionary relationship between these species. A wider range of host species was observed in <i>E. faecium</i>; in particular, there is a radiation of <i>E. faecium</i> clades specialized to domesticated and pet animals among which <i>E. lactis</i> is uncommon. Of note, pangenome analyses reveal that <i>E. lactis</i> has significantly more allelic variation and lower recombination rates in core genes compared with <i>E. faecium</i>. These observations suggest that <i>E. lactis</i> represents a population that has occupied its ecological niche longer than <i>E. faecium</i> has. This study enhances understanding of the evolutionary histories of these species and highlights the importance of sampling and studying closely related commensal bacteria in addition to clinically relevant opportunistic pathogens.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ross2025enterococcus,
  author = {Terry Ross and Jessin Janice and Sergio Arredondo-Alonso and Iren H. Löhr and Einar Holsbø and Jukka Corander and Anna K. Pöntinen and Michael Kampffmeyer and Kristin Hegstad},
  title = {{Enterococcus lactis is ecologically and genetically distinct from the major opportunistic pathogen Enterococcus faecium}},
  booktitle = {Microbial},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1099/mgen.0.001420},
}
Figure