Entanglement is necessary for emergent classicality

Jonathan G. Richens, John H. Selby, Sabri W. Al-SafiarXiv 2017 · arXiv

Introduction

Quantum entanglement, famously dubbed "spooky action at a distance" by Albert Einstein, has long been viewed as one of the most counter-intuitive features of quantum mechanics. For decades, the central question has been whether entanglement is a peculiar "add-on" to our physical laws or a fundamental necessity. Recent research suggests the latter: any physical theory that is not purely classical but possesses a well-defined "classical limit" must inevitably contain entangled states. This finding implies that the very existence of our macroscopic, classical-looking world necessitates the "spookiness" of the quantum realm.

The Generalized Probabilistic Theories (GPT) Framework

To investigate these foundational questions, researchers utilize the Generalized Probabilistic Theories (GPT) framework. GPT acts as a mathematical "meta-theory" capable of describing a vast array of physical systems—from classical and quantum mechanics to more exotic, hypothetical theories. In this framework, a theory is defined by its:

  • States: How a system is prepared.
  • Effects: The possible outcomes of measurements.
  • Transformations: The physical processes that evolve states.

Geometrically, these states form a "state space." A classical system is represented by a simplex (like a triangle or tetrahedron), where every point is a unique convex combination of the vertices. Non-classical theories, such as quantum mechanics, feature more complex geometries like the Bloch sphere.

Examples of state spaces in GPTs: (a) the Bloch sphere of a qubit, (b) a square state space, and (c) a triangular simplex representing a classical three-level system.

Decoherence and the Classical Limit

The transition from the quantum to the classical world is typically explained through decoherence. This is the process by which a system interacts with its environment, causing its non-classical correlations to dissipate until it appears classical to a macroscopic observer.

The authors define a generalized decoherence map to describe how any non-classical system "settles" into a classical state space. The pivotal question is whether a theory can support such a map without allowing for entanglement between its subsystems. In GPT terms, a "no-entanglement" theory is one that uses the minimal tensor product composition rule, where the only allowed joint states are those that can be written as convex combinations of product states.

The Inevitability of Entanglement

The core finding of the paper is that if a theory lacks entanglement, its decoherence mechanism becomes "trivial." Specifically, the authors prove that for any non-entangled theory with a classical limit, the non-classical information is essentially a "sidecar"—it exists alongside the classical information but never truly interacts with it. When decoherence occurs, this sidecar is simply discarded.

Geometric representation of a state space cone $\mathcal{K}_A$. The authors use these geometric constraints to show that non-trivial integration between classical and non-classical components requires entanglement.

This leads to Theorem 1, the paper's primary result. It states that if a theory decoheres to a classical theory and lacks entanglement, then the state space must be a simple composite of a classical space and an internal non-classical space. The decoherence map then acts merely as a "discarding" map. Consequently, any theory that is "more than classical" and interacts with the classical world in a non-trivial way must possess entangled states.

Conclusion: A Top-Down View of Physics

Traditionally, we view classical physics as an emergent property derived from fundamental quantum laws. This research flips that perspective: the requirement that a theory must have a classical limit actually imposes the existence of non-classical features like entanglement.

While the paper proves that entanglement must exist, it leaves open questions regarding the "strength" of this entanglement—such as whether it must always violate Bell inequalities. Nonetheless, this work paves the way for a "top-down" reconstruction of physical laws, suggesting that many "weird" quantum features might be derivable solely from the existence of our macroscopic classical experience.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{richens2017entanglement,
  author = {Jonathan G. Richens and John H. Selby and Sabri W. Al-Safi},
  title = {{Entanglement is necessary for emergent classicality}},
  year = {2017},
  eprint = {1705.08028},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1705.08028},
}

Loading related content...

Figure