Entanglement in a Valence-Bond Solid State

Heng Fan, V. E. Korepin, Vwani RoychowdhuryPhysical 2004 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We study entanglement in a valence-bond solid state, which describes the ground state of an Affleck-Kennedy-Lieb-Tasaki quantum spin chain, consisting of bulk spin-1's and two spin-1/2's at the ends. We characterize entanglement between various subsystems of the ground state by mostly calculating the entropy of one of the subsystems; when appropriate, we evaluate concurrences as well. We show that the reduced density matrix of a continuous block of bulk spins is independent of the size of the chain and the location of the block relative to the ends. Moreover, we show that the entanglement of the block with the rest of the sites approaches a constant value exponentially fast, as the size of the block increases. We also calculate the entanglement of (i) any two bulk spins with the rest, and (ii) the end spin-1/2's (together and separately) with the rest of the ground state.

Introduction

In the quest to understand quantum phases of matter, entanglement has emerged as a primary lens. For "critical" (gapless) systems, entanglement entropy typically grows logarithmically with the size of a subsystem. However, for "gapped" systems like the Affleck-Kennedy-Lieb-Tasaki (AKLT) model, it was conjectured that entanglement should saturate—meaning a large enough block of spins eventually stops gaining new entanglement with the rest of the universe.

This study provides a rigorous characterization of entanglement within the Valence-Bond Solid (VBS) state, the ground state of the AKLT quantum spin chain. Understanding the specific structure of this entanglement is crucial not just for theoretical physics, but for practical applications like the Density Matrix Renormalization Group (DMRG) algorithm and potential architectures for universal quantum computation.

The Valence-Bond Solid State

The researchers employ an analytical approach based on the unique representation of the VBS state. The VBS state can be visualized as a chain of virtual spin-1/2 singlets where adjacent spins are projected onto a symmetric spin-1 subspace.

Schematic representation of the Valence-Bond Solid (VBS) state construction.

As shown in the figure above, the state is constructed by placing two virtual spin-1/2 particles at each site (represented by circles). Adjacent virtual spins from neighboring sites are paired into a singlet state $|\Psi^-\rangle$. The two virtual spins at each physical site are then projected onto the triplet (spin-1) subspace. This construction leaves two unpaired spin-1/2 particles at the boundaries of the chain.

Analytical Methods

Key techniques used to characterize entanglement include:

  • Reduced Density Matrices ($\rho$): By tracing out the degrees of freedom of the rest of the chain, the authors isolate the state of specific subsystems (blocks of spins or boundary spins).
  • Von Neumann Entropy ($S$): Used as the primary measure of entanglement between a subsystem and the rest of the chain.
  • Concurrence ($C$): Used to quantify the entanglement specifically between two individual spins.
  • Mathematical Proofs: The authors prove a theorem showing that the reduced density matrix of a continuous block of spins depends only on the length of the block ($L$), making it independent of the total chain length ($N$) or the block's position.

Key Insights and Results

The study reveals several fundamental properties of entanglement in the AKLT model:

  1. Saturation of Entropy: The entanglement entropy $S_L$ for a block of length $L$ approaches a constant value (specifically, 2) exponentially fast as $L$ increases. The formula involves $p(L) = (-1/3)^L$, leading to rapid convergence: $S_1 \approx 1.58$, $S_2 \approx 1.97$, and by $S_6$, it is essentially 2. This confirms that the VBS state has "short-ranged" entanglement correlations.
  2. Independence of Environment: A surprising finding is that the state of a block of spins is independent of the total chain length or the block's location. This locality is a hallmark of gapped quantum systems and explains why numerical methods like DMRG are exceptionally efficient for these states.
  3. Boundary Paradox: The two spin-1/2 particles at the ends of the chain are each maximally entangled with the rest of the system (entropy = 1), yet they share zero entanglement with each other. The reduced density matrix for a single boundary spin is shown to be the identity matrix in two dimensions, proving it is in a maximally disordered state.
  4. Bulk Entanglement: Every single spin-1 in the bulk of the chain is maximally entangled with the rest of the system ($S = \log 3$). For two bulk spins separated by $M$ sites, the entanglement with the rest of the system reaches its maximum value exponentially fast as the distance $M$ increases.

Conclusion and Future Directions

While these results are robust for 1D chains, the behavior of entanglement in higher-dimensional AKLT models remains an open question. Future work should focus on evaluating entropy in 2D or 3D AKLT models, studying AKLT states on arbitrary graphs, and exploring these states as resources for measurement-based universal quantum computation.

Summary updated

Abstract

We study entanglement in a valence-bond solid state, which describes the ground state of an Affleck-Kennedy-Lieb-Tasaki quantum spin chain, consisting of bulk spin-1's and two spin-1/2's at the ends. We characterize entanglement between various subsystems of the ground state by mostly calculating the entropy of one of the subsystems; when appropriate, we evaluate concurrences as well. We show that the reduced density matrix of a continuous block of bulk spins is independent of the size of the chain and the location of the block relative to the ends. Moreover, we show that the entanglement of the block with the rest of the sites approaches a constant value exponentially fast, as the size of the block increases. We also calculate the entanglement of (i) any two bulk spins with the rest, and (ii) the end spin-1/2's (together and separately) with the rest of the ground state.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{fan2004entanglement,
  author = {Heng Fan and V. E. Korepin and Vwani Roychowdhury},
  title = {{Entanglement in a Valence-Bond Solid State}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2004},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevlett.93.227203},
}
Figure