Entanglement generation in atoms immersed in a thermal bath of external quantum scalar fields with a boundary

Jialin Zhang, Hong YuPhysical 2007 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We examine the entanglement creation between two mutually independent two-level atoms immersed in a thermal bath of quantum scalar fields in the presence of a perfectly reflecting plane boundary. With the help of the master equation that describes the evolution in time of the atom subsystem obtained, in the weak-coupling limit, by tracing over environment (scalar fields) degrees of freedom, we find that the presence of the boundary may play a significant role in the entanglement creation in some circumstances and the new parameter, the distance of the atoms from the boundary, besides the bath temperature and the separation between the atoms, gives us more freedom in manipulating entanglement generation. Remarkably, the final remaining entanglement in the equilibrium state is independent of the presence of the boundary.

Introduction

In the field of quantum information, environmental interactions are traditionally seen as detrimental, leading to decoherence and the destruction of fragile quantum states. However, recent theoretical developments have suggested that a shared environment can facilitate the creation of entanglement between otherwise independent systems by acting as a mediating reservoir. This paper explores how the introduction of a physical boundary—specifically, a perfectly reflecting plane—modifies the thermal fluctuations of a scalar field and, consequently, the entanglement dynamics between two atoms.

The primary motivation is to determine if the presence of a wall can be used as a "control knob" to enhance entanglement generation, potentially allowing it to occur at higher temperatures than in free space.

Physical Model and Methodology

The researchers model a system consisting of two identical two-level atoms (qubits) interacting weakly with a thermal bath of massless quantum scalar fields. The atoms are positioned at a distance $z$ from a perfectly reflecting boundary and are separated from each other by a distance $L$, as illustrated in Figure 1.

Schematic of the two-atom system near a reflecting boundary. The atoms are separated by distance $L$ and positioned at a distance $z$ from the wall.

To analyze the system's evolution, the authors employ the framework of Open Quantum Systems. They derive a Kossakowski-Lindblad master equation for the reduced density matrix of the atomic subsystem by tracing over the degrees of freedom of the scalar field. The effect of the reflecting boundary is incorporated using the "method of images," which accounts for the boundary conditions by introducing virtual image sources.

Entanglement is quantified using two primary metrics:

  1. Peres-Horodecki Criterion: Used to detect the onset of entanglement from an initially separable state.
  2. Concurrence: Used to measure the degree of entanglement as the system reaches equilibrium.

Key Insights and Results

The study reveals that the boundary significantly alters the field correlations, leading to several notable effects:

1. Enhanced Temperature Robustness

One of the most significant findings is that the boundary can make entanglement generation much more resilient to thermal noise. In free space, for a transition frequency corresponding to a hydrogen atom, entanglement only forms if the bath temperature is below approximately 262.6 K. By placing the atoms near a boundary ($z/L \ll 1$), this threshold increases to 379.7 K. This 117-degree improvement suggests that boundaries could be leveraged to maintain quantum correlations at room temperature.

2. Geometric Control

The distance $z$ from the boundary introduces a new degree of freedom. Because the scalar field must vanish at the boundary, interference patterns are created in the vacuum and thermal fluctuations. The ability to generate entanglement oscillates as the distance $z$ varies, reflecting the wave-like nature of these field correlations. When the atoms are close to the boundary and their separation $L$ is small (within a few radiation wavelengths), the boundary significantly enhances the probability of entanglement creation.

3. Equilibrium Independence

A surprising theoretical result is that while the boundary is critical for the generation of entanglement, it has no impact on the final equilibrium state. If the atoms are separated ($L > 0$), any generated entanglement eventually decays. If they are at the same location ($L = 0$), the remaining entanglement in the steady state depends only on the initial state and the bath temperature; the terms associated with the boundary mathematically cancel out in the long-term limit.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This research demonstrates that physical boundaries can be powerful tools for manipulating quantum entanglement in thermal environments. By carefully choosing the geometry ($z$ and $L$), researchers can overcome thermal decoherence that would otherwise prevent entanglement in open space.

However, several limitations remain for future study. The use of a scalar field is a simplification; real atoms interact with vector electromagnetic fields, which may introduce polarization-dependent effects. Additionally, the assumption of a perfectly reflecting boundary ignores the finite conductivity and absorption of real materials. Future work could also explore more complex geometries, such as cavities or spherical boundaries, to further optimize entanglement control.

Summary updated

Abstract

We examine the entanglement creation between two mutually independent two-level atoms immersed in a thermal bath of quantum scalar fields in the presence of a perfectly reflecting plane boundary. With the help of the master equation that describes the evolution in time of the atom subsystem obtained, in the weak-coupling limit, by tracing over environment (scalar fields) degrees of freedom, we find that the presence of the boundary may play a significant role in the entanglement creation in some circumstances and the new parameter, the distance of the atoms from the boundary, besides the bath temperature and the separation between the atoms, gives us more freedom in manipulating entanglement generation. Remarkably, the final remaining entanglement in the equilibrium state is independent of the presence of the boundary.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2007entanglement,
  author = {Jialin Zhang and Hong Yu},
  title = {{Entanglement generation in atoms immersed in a thermal bath of external quantum scalar fields with a boundary}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2007},
  doi = {10.1103/physreva.75.012101},
}
Figure