Enhancing the Activity of the DLPFC with tDCS Alters Risk Preference without Changing Interpersonal Trust

Haoli Zheng, Siqi Wang, Wenmin Guo, Shu Chen, Jun Luo, Hang Ye, Daqiang HuangFrontiers in Neuroscience 2017 · DOI

Abstract

Interpersonal trust plays an essential role in economic interactions and social development. Extensive behavioral experiments have examined the nature of trust, particularly the question of whether trusting decisions are connected to risk preferences or risk attitudes. Various laboratory observations have been reported regarding the difference between trust and risk, and neural imaging studies have demonstrated that the right dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (rDLPFC) is more activated when individuals decide to trust other human beings compared with individuals decide to invest in a non-social risk condition. Moreover, the rDLPFC has been found to exhibit an intimate relationship with risk preference in previous neuroscience studies. However, the causal relationship between the rDLPFC and trust has rarely been revealed. Whether modulating the excitability of the rDLPFC, which shares roles in both trust and risk decisions, alters the trust or risk preference of participants remains unknown. In the present study, we aimed to provide evidence of a direct link between the neural and behavioral results through the application of transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) over the rDLPFC. We found that activating the rDLPFC altered the risk preferences of our participants, whereas no such significant effect over interpersonal trust was observed. Our findings indicate that enhancing the excitability of the rDLPFC using tDCS leads to more conservative decision-makings in a risk game, and this effect is specific to non-social risk rather than social-related trust.

Introduction

Is trusting a stranger just a specific type of "social gambling," or is it a fundamentally different psychological process? Economists and psychologists have long debated whether interpersonal trust is simply a subset of an individual's general risk preference. While neuroimaging (fMRI) has shown that the right dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (rDLPFC) is active during both trust-based and risk-based decisions, fMRI can only show correlation. This paper seeks to establish causality: if we artificially modulate the excitability of the rDLPFC, do we change trust, risk-taking, or both?

Methods

The researchers conducted two experiments using transcranial Direct Current Stimulation (tDCS), a technique that applies a weak electrical current to the scalp to increase (anodal) or decrease (cathodal) neuronal excitability. The study utilized primary behavioral data collected from 120 healthy, right-handed subjects (mostly university students).

  • Experiment 1: 90 participants were split into three groups: Anodal (enhancing rDLPFC), Cathodal (inhibiting rDLPFC), and Sham (a placebo control).
  • Experiment 2 (Control): 30 participants received anodal stimulation with a different electrode placement to ensure the results in Experiment 1 were actually due to the rDLPFC and not the "return" electrode placed over the visual cortex.
Electrode placement for tDCS targeting the rDLPFC (F4) and the reference electrode (Oz).

Participants played two games programmed in z-Tree:

  1. The Trust Game: A participant (trustor) decides how much money to send to a human partner (trustee). The amount is tripled, and the partner decides how much to send back. This involves "social risk" (fear of betrayal).
  2. The Risk Game: Identical to the Trust Game, but the "return" is determined by a computer algorithm rather than a human. This involves "non-social risk" (probability).

Key Results

The study revealed a clear functional dissociation between social trust and non-social risk within the rDLPFC.

  • Risk Game: Participants in the Anodal group (enhanced rDLPFC activity) invested significantly less (mean = 5.20 tokens) compared to the Sham group (mean = 7.17 tokens) and the Cathodal group (mean = 7.07 tokens). This indicates that enhancing the rDLPFC makes individuals more conservative in non-social contexts.
  • Trust Game: There were no significant differences in investment across the Anodal, Cathodal, or Sham groups. Bayesian analysis confirmed that this "null result" for trust was actual evidence that the stimulation had no effect on trust levels.
Mean investment levels in Trust and Risk games across stimulation types, showing a significant decrease in risk-taking under anodal stimulation.

Discussion and Insights

The most significant insight is the functional "split" in the rDLPFC. While the region is involved in executive function and impulse control, its role in decision-making is specific to non-social contexts. The lack of effect on the Trust Game suggests that "trusting" involves a much broader network of brain regions—such as the amygdala or striatum—and social preferences like altruism or "betrayal aversion" that the rDLPFC alone does not control.

This study moves beyond fMRI "blobs" to show that the rDLPFC is a causal lever for risk, but not for the social nuances of trust. However, limitations remain. Trust is likely a "whole-brain" effort, and future work should look at modulating other regions like the ventromedial prefrontal cortex (vmPFC) or the temporoparietal junction (TPJ). Additionally, as the games were "one-shot" interactions, future research could explore whether these neural mechanisms differ in repeated interactions where trust is built over time.

Summary updated

Abstract

Interpersonal trust plays an essential role in economic interactions and social development. Extensive behavioral experiments have examined the nature of trust, particularly the question of whether trusting decisions are connected to risk preferences or risk attitudes. Various laboratory observations have been reported regarding the difference between trust and risk, and neural imaging studies have demonstrated that the right dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (rDLPFC) is more activated when individuals decide to trust other human beings compared with individuals decide to invest in a non-social risk condition. Moreover, the rDLPFC has been found to exhibit an intimate relationship with risk preference in previous neuroscience studies. However, the causal relationship between the rDLPFC and trust has rarely been revealed. Whether modulating the excitability of the rDLPFC, which shares roles in both trust and risk decisions, alters the trust or risk preference of participants remains unknown. In the present study, we aimed to provide evidence of a direct link between the neural and behavioral results through the application of transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) over the rDLPFC. We found that activating the rDLPFC altered the risk preferences of our participants, whereas no such significant effect over interpersonal trust was observed. Our findings indicate that enhancing the excitability of the rDLPFC using tDCS leads to more conservative decision-makings in a risk game, and this effect is specific to non-social risk rather than social-related trust.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zheng2017enhancing,
  author = {Haoli Zheng and Siqi Wang and Wenmin Guo and Shu Chen and Jun Luo and Hang Ye and Daqiang Huang},
  title = {{Enhancing the Activity of the DLPFC with tDCS Alters Risk Preference without Changing Interpersonal Trust}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Neuroscience},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3389/fnins.2017.00052},
}
Figure