Enhancing selenium biofortification: strategies for improving soil-to-plant transfer

Qing Liao, Ying Xing, Ao‐Mei Li, Liang PanXia, Jiang Ze-pu, Yongxian Liu, Dongliang HuangChemical 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This review synthesizes current strategies to overcome the "soil-to-plant" bottleneck in selenium (Se) biofortification. By manipulating soil chemistry (pH, redox, ions) and leveraging microbial "activators," researchers aim to convert unusable soil selenium into bioavailable forms, providing a safer, natural alternative to direct human supplementation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Selenium is a double-edged sword: essential for human immune and thyroid function in trace amounts, but toxic in excess. Globally, many regions suffer from Se-deficient soils, leading to insufficient intake for an estimated 39–61% of residents in countries like China.

The core challenge isn't always a total lack of selenium in the soil, but rather its bioavailability. Selenium often exists in "locked" forms—such as elemental Se (0) or selenides (-II)—that plant roots simply cannot absorb. This paper addresses the technical gap in how we can effectively "activate" these dormant soil reserves to enhance the nutritional value of crops, a process known as agronomic biofortification.

Methods

As a comprehensive review, the authors systematically categorize and synthesize decades of research on selenium dynamics. They evaluate two primary classification systems for soil Se:

  1. Chemical Valence Forms: Categorizing Se by oxidation state (Selenate [VI], Selenite [IV], Elemental Se [0], and Selenide [-II]).
  2. Extraction Forms: Categorizing Se based on how it binds to soil components (e.g., water-soluble, organic-matter bound, or iron-manganese oxide bound).

The paper then maps out the metabolic pathways of Se within the plant (from root uptake via sulfate transporters to the synthesis of selenomethionine) and evaluates the efficacy of various intervention strategies, ranging from soil moisture management to the inoculation of specific "seleno-bacteria."

Datasets

As this is a review article, it does not introduce a new experimental dataset. Instead, it synthesizes findings from 82 peer-reviewed sources, including field studies on staple crops (wheat, rice, maize), pot experiments involving microbial inoculants, and chemical modeling of soil-ion competitions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Valence Paradox: While Selenate (VI) is highly mobile in soil, it is often less bioavailable for conversion into organic Se forms within the plant compared to Selenite (IV). However, Selenite is easily "fixed" or trapped by soil minerals, making it harder for plants to reach.
  • The pH Lever: In acidic soils (common in Southern China), Se is tightly bound and unavailable. Increasing soil pH can "release" this Se, though if the pH goes too high (8–12), the resulting selenates may again become fixed or less absorbable.
  • Microbial "Bio-activators": The paper highlights specific bacterial strains, such as Bacillus cereus (YLB1-6), that can actively transform residual, insoluble soil Se into soluble forms (SOL-Se6+), significantly boosting plant uptake without the need for chemical fertilizers.
  • Organic Matter Dualism: Soil organic matter is a "double-edged sword." While mineralization releases Se, high levels of humic acid can actually sequester Se, making it less available than soils dominated by fulvic acids.
  • Rhizosphere Synergy: The "hotspot" of activity is the rhizosphere. Plant root exudates can change local pH and recruit beneficial microbes, creating a localized micro-environment that is far more efficient at Se-transfer than the bulk soil.

Key Results

  • Soil Composition: On average, soil Se is distributed as: Selenites (40%), Organic Se (25%), Elemental/Selenides (25%), and Selenates (10%).
  • Plant Efficiency: Wheat is a standout for biofortification; research shows up to 84.4% of total Se in wheat is organic, with over half of that being high-value selenoproteins.
  • Uptake Pathways: The paper confirms that Se uptake primarily hijacks the plant's existing sulfur machinery, specifically using sulfate transporters (SULTR1;1 and SULTR1;2).
  • Foliar vs. Soil: While soil activation is more sustainable, foliar (leaf) sprays are noted for their speed, though they face challenges with volatility and environmental runoff.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors identify several critical gaps:

  • Lack of Integration: Most studies look at either chemical valence or extraction forms. Future research needs to integrate these to understand which specific chemical species are being extracted by which methods.
  • Theoretical vs. Applied: Much of the data on ion competition and moisture management remains theoretical or limited to pot experiments. Large-scale field validation is needed.
  • Complexity of Synergy: We don't yet fully understand how multiple factors (e.g., pH, microbes, and phosphorus levels) interact simultaneously. The authors call for "integrated agricultural practices" rather than silver-bullet single-factor solutions.
  • Advanced Detection: Current direct detection methods (like X-ray diffraction) require Se concentrations much higher than what is typically found in nature, necessitating the development of more sensitive analytical tools.

Summary updated

Abstract

Selenium (Se) is one of the essential trace elements for humans. Plants are the main source of Se for humans, while soil Se is the primary source of Se for plants. Biofortification, which involves the transfer of Se from soil to plants and animals, is currently recognized as the safest and most effective approach for Se supplementation for humans. However, Se in soil primarily exists in forms that plants cannot easily utilize, so enhancing Se transfer from soil to plants is crucial for optimal Se utilization. In this paper, we provided a comprehensive analysis of Se forms in soil. Then we summarized the strategies for enhancing Se transfer from soil to plants. These strategies include adjusting redox potential, managing soil moisture, modulating pH value, improving organic matter, optimizing ion competition, promoting beneficial microbes, and considering the synergy between plant rhizosphere and soil. Furthermore, we reviewed Se forms and metabolism after uptake into plants to better understand its role in human health. Finally, we came up with the challenges and perspectives, to provide new insights for further study in this area. This work also offers potential solutions for enhancing Se transformation from soil to plants and utilizing soil Se to produce naturally Se-rich products.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liao2024enhancing,
  author = {Qing Liao and Ying Xing and Ao‐Mei Li and Liang PanXia and Jiang Ze-pu and Yongxian Liu and Dongliang Huang},
  title = {{Enhancing selenium biofortification: strategies for improving soil-to-plant transfer}},
  booktitle = {Chemical},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1186/s40538-024-00672-z},
}
Figure